Wed, 09 Mar 2005

RI needs diplomatic strength in dealing with Malaysia

Wahyu Susilo, Jakarta

The diplomatic tensions between Indonesia and Malaysia have been escalating over a border dispute concerning the oil in the Ambalat block. It started nearly two weeks ago when Malaysia's state oil company Petronas claimed that the oil field in the Sulawesi Sea was its exploitation area, and proceeded to sell a concession to the multinational company, Shell.

The unilateral decision by the state company promptly received a strong reaction from the Indonesian government, which also claimed that Ambalat was an inseparable part of the unitary state of the Republic of Indonesia. The oil dispute became a full- fledged crisis after warships and fighter jets were deployed to the area by both countries. The ships are apparently still there on high alert.

As a background, Malaysia's bold claim on Ambalat was not only based on historical considerations, but also on Malaysia's analysis of the performance of Indonesian diplomacy, which has always "lost" to Malaysia. In previous weeks, Malaysia noticed its "victory" in the diplomacy of migrant worker deportation, though it had been cornered by the case of Damansara Damai, which revealed Malaysian companies' wage payment arrears and deliberate recruitment of migrant workers without documents.

In the beginning, Indonesia aggressively declared that there was "something serious about the issue of migrant workers without documents in Malaysia" and even planned to hire 10 renowned lawyers in Malaysia to sue the companies in order to make them bankrupt. But the Malaysian government was not deterred and stuck to its guns, believing that, "migrant workers without papers is a crime so they have no right to sue". Finally, Indonesia backed down -- with an anticlimax at the summit meeting between President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono and Premier Abdullah Badawi on Feb. 14, 2005.

When the Indonesian public expected the meeting to improve the fate of migrant workers without documents (particularly on the issue of unpaid wages), the result was the reverse. Instead of urging Malaysian firms to pay the wages overdue, the Indonesian government left its settlement fully to Malaysia and agreed to allow the stern actions against Indonesian illegal workers. The Indonesian "agreement" legitimized the Malaysian operation. Indonesia's "defeat" was apparent with the cancellation of the Indonesian government's lawsuit against the Malaysian firms.

This failure in Indonesian diplomacy encouraged Malaysia to launch its political maneuver by claiming the Ambalat offshore area as its territory. The move will again force Indonesia to solve the Ambalat border crisis through the mechanism of diplomacy. Indonesia will definitely avoid settling the dispute through the international court because of the trauma of its loss in the 2002 Sipadan-Ligitan case in this tribunal.

I predict that by inviting Indonesia to bilateral diplomatic talks, there will certainly be room for negotiation on the control over Ambalat. Should Indonesia be trapped in a fait accompli, it would mean that Ambalat will indeed be recognized legally as Malaysia's oil field.

The Indonesian government should conduct a profound evaluation of its performance of foreign diplomacy. Admittedly, Indonesia has so far been ensnared in the myth of the "common ethnic family" policy with Malaysia, so that the pattern of diplomacy tends to avoid the approach of bargaining and be more oriented to the politics of harmony.

By the model that gives prominence to the politics of harmony, the interests of migrant workers demanding their rights and protection were brushed aside for the sake of harmony in bilateral relations. So, if in this process of the Ambalat diplomacy, Indonesia still applies the politics of harmony, the outcome will again harm Indonesian interests. In a territorial dispute, our diplomacy should be totally maximized by pooling all political resources.

Observing the main issues in the Indonesia-Malaysia bilateral crisis (migrant workers and territorial dispute), Indonesia should strengthen its political bargaining position in its diplomacy by analyzing the interdependence between Malaysia's economy and the labor market. On Saturday, March 5, a Malaysian delegation under Interior Minister Azmi Khalid visited Jakarta to meet with Indonesian Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Fahmi Idris for a discussion on the quick return of the migrant workers who left Malaysia during the amnesty period.

According to Azmi Khalid, companies in Malaysia are facing a labor shortage due to the scarcity of low-wage migrant workers, and Malaysia expects the fulfillment of its industrial demand within two months (for around 300,000 migrant workers).

Therefore, this reality should serve as a political bargaining chip. The Indonesian government should not always comply with Malaysia's requests. Indonesia's bargaining position will rise if the government says, for instance: "Indonesia is prepared to speed up the return of 300,000 migrant workers to Malaysia, if within a month the Malaysian government is ready to force Malaysian firms to pay wages still overdue."

The government can add more demands including the arrest and punishment of Malaysian employees who deliberately recruited migrant workers without papers, make sure that the migrant raid proceeds peacefully without rights violation, and withdraw the unilateral claim on Ambalat."

The writer is a labor policy analyst in Migrant CARE -- Indonesian Association for Sovereign Migrant Workers.





News Search/Filter
Transaction Rates
10 Dec 18
Buy
Sell
AED1
3,945.27
3,945.27
AFN1
191.01
191.01
ALL1
133.25
133.25
AMD1
29.86
29.86
ANG1
8,164.82
8,164.82
AOA1
46.82
46.82
ARS1
388.05
388.05
AUD1
10,405.53
10,405.53
AWG1
8,050.55
8,050.55
AZN1
8,511.57
8,511.57
BAM1
8,431.27
8,431.27
BBD1
7,245.48
7,245.48
BDT1
173.05
173.05
BGN1
8,452.70
8,452.70
BHD1
38,436.54
38,436.54
BIF1
8.11
8.11
BMD1
14,490.96
14,490.96
BND1
9,195.00
9,195.00
BOB1
2,096.99
2,096.99
BRL1
3,708.22
3,708.22
BSD1
14,490.96
14,490.96
BTC1
51,648,460
51,648,460
BTN1
204.70
204.70
BWP1
1,360.84
1,360.84
BYN1
6,796.56
6,796.56
BZD1
7,188.51
7,188.51
CAD1
10,871.18
10,871.18
CDF1
8.90
8.90
CHF1
14,638.39
14,638.39
CLF1
598,453.78
598,453.78
CLP1
21.47
21.47
CNH1
2,099.64
2,099.64
CNY1
2,107.56
2,107.56
COP1
4.55
4.55
CRC1
24.21
24.21
CUC1
14,490.96
14,490.96
CUP1
562.75
562.75
CVE1
149.12
149.12
CZK1
638.47
638.47
DJF1
81.40
81.40
DKK1
2,212.98
2,212.98
DOP1
288.12
288.12
DZD1
122.24
122.24
EGP1
810.00
810.00
ERN1
966.62
966.62
ETB1
516.66
516.66
EUR1
16,519.29
16,519.29
FJD1
6,857.47
6,857.47
FKP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
GBP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
GEL1
5,472.02
5,472.02
GGP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
GHS1
2,903.91
2,903.91
GIP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
GMD1
292.45
292.45
GNF1
1.59
1.59
GTQ1
1,875.48
1,875.48
GYD1
69.10
69.10
HKD1
1,853.93
1,853.93
HNL1
593.77
593.77
HRK1
2,234.87
2,234.87
HTG1
192.66
192.66
HUF1
51.10
51.10
IDR1
1.00
1.00
ILS1
3,882.34
3,882.34
IMP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
INR1
203.02
203.02
IQD1
12.17
12.17
IRR1
0.34
0.34
ISK1
119.01
119.01
JEP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
JMD1
114.06
114.06
JOD1
20,421.16
20,421.16
JPY1
128.79
128.79
KES1
141.47
141.47
KGS1
210.90
210.90
KHR1
3.60
3.60
KMF1
33.58
33.58
KPW1
16.10
16.10
KRW1
12.89
12.89
KWD1
47,664.02
47,664.02
KYD1
17,392.14
17,392.14
KZT1
39.09
39.09
LAK1
1.69
1.69
LBP1
9.60
9.60
LKR1
81.17
81.17
LRD1
91.68
91.68
LSL1
1,022.65
1,022.65
LYD1
10,375.47
10,375.47
MAD1
1,528.63
1,528.63
MDL1
841.22
841.22
MGA1
4.06
4.06
MKD1
268.19
268.19
MMK1
9.28
9.28
MNT1
5.90
5.90
MOP1
1,800.00
1,800.00
MRO1
40.59
40.59
MRU1
397.01
397.01
MUR1
421.25
421.25
MVR1
937.92
937.92
MWK1
19.60
19.60
MXN1
714.22
714.22
MYR1
3,477.97
3,477.97
MZN1
239.32
239.32
NAD1
1,022.65
1,022.65
NGN1
39.75
39.75
NIO1
447.04
447.04
NOK1
1,704.59
1,704.59
NPR1
127.93
127.93
NZD1
9,914.71
9,914.71
OMR1
37,644.23
37,644.23
PAB1
14,490.96
14,490.96
PEN1
4,303.81
4,303.81
PGK1
4,301.65
4,301.65
PHP1
274.86
274.86
PKR1
104.30
104.30
PLN1
3,848.72
3,848.72
PYG1
2.45
2.45
QAR1
3,979.94
3,979.94
RON1
3,553.10
3,553.10
RSD1
139.56
139.56
RUB1
218.11
218.11
RWF1
16.25
16.25
SAR1
3,862.40
3,862.40
SBD1
1,823.83
1,823.83
SCR1
1,062.82
1,062.82
SDG1
304.37
304.37
SEK1
1,602.73
1,602.73
SGD1
10,566.56
10,566.56
SHP1
18,431.57
18,431.57
SLL1
1.72
1.72
SOS1
25.05
25.05
SRD1
1,943.00
1,943.00
SSP1
111.24
111.24
STD1
0.68
0.68
STN1
673.99
673.99
SVC1
1,655.92
1,655.92
SYP1
28.15
28.15
SZL1
1,022.65
1,022.65
THB1
441.39
441.39
TJS1
1,537.35
1,537.35
TMT1
4,128.52
4,128.52
TND1
4,899.73
4,899.73
TOP1
6,326.47
6,326.47
TRY1
2,722.18
2,722.18
TTD1
2,149.85
2,149.85
TWD1
468.43
468.43
TZS1
6.30
6.30
UAH1
520.80
520.80
UGX1
3.87
3.87
USD1
14,490.96
14,490.96
UYU1
451.83
451.83
UZS1
1.74
1.74
VEF1
0.05
0.05
VND1
0.62
0.62
VUV1
131.01
131.01
WST1
5,557.92
5,557.92
XAF1
25.18
25.18
XAG1
211,705.28
211,705.28
XAU1
18,100,350.99
18,100,350.99
XCD1
5,361.95
5,361.95
XDR1
20,162.54
20,162.54
XOF1
25.18
25.18
XPD1
17,707,317.07
17,707,317.07
XPF1
138.43
138.43
XPT1
11,483,991.63
11,483,991.63
YER1
57.88
57.88
ZAR1
1,020.74
1,020.74
ZMW1
1,219.18
1,219.18
ZWL1
44.95
44.95
Taxation Exchange Rates
31 Aug 16 - 06 Sep 16
USD 1
13,232.00
AUD 1
10,043.30
CAD 1
10,213.70
DKK 1
1,999.40
HKD 1
1,706.22
MYR 1
3,283.28
NZD 1
9,623.63
NOK 1
1,605.23
GBP 1
17,433.70
SGD 1
9,757.68
SEK 1
1,569.45
CHF 1
13,631.10
JPY 100
13,101.00
MMK 1
11.01
INR 1
197.29
KWD 1
43,920.70
PKR 1
126.23
PHP 1
285.00
SAR 1
3,528.53
LKR 1
91.12
THB 1
382.08
BND 1
9,756.53
EUR 1
14,885.50
CNY 1
1,987.61

Okusi Associates: Indonesian Business & Management Services