'Watching crime shows, I've become more afraid'

Like them or not, crime shows have become big parts of most TV stations' lineups. Despite the high ratings many of these shows earn, people are concerned about their possible impact on society. The Jakarta Post discussed the issue with several residents.

Wawan Kurniawan, 27, is a teacher at a private high school in Kebayoran Baru, South Jakarta. He lives in Rawamangun, East Jakarta, with his wife:

I think crime shows on TV have a negative impact on people, particularly young people who watch these programs with much enthusiasm. I'm afraid that by being exposed to such programs, they will resort to violence.

In a larger context, I'm worried that people may start to justify acts of violence by blaming the influence of these crime shows.

I disagree with the airing of violent shows. It is unnecessary to show vulgar pictures, and it will only make our country uncivilized.

I suggest TV stations edit the shows. TV stations must also consider the broadcast times as these programs are available nationwide.

Delila, 29, works at a company in South Jakarta. She lives in Radio Dalam, South Jakarta, with her family:

I think criminals should be treated harshly, like they are on these TV crime shows. However, TV stations must reduce the vulgarity in the shows. They shouldn't just pursue ratings.

Crime shows have gotten more and more vulgar in the reform era. They didn't have programs like this during the New Order.

Imported movies are censored, so why should local shows like these be left uncensored?

I'm afraid children will copy the scenes they see on TV. It's possible.

I also wonder about the importance of crime shows since they don't necessarily deter criminals. Drugs, rape and other crimes are all increasing. Maybe criminals are watching the shows to learn new ways to commit crimes.

Dati, 32, is a housewife who lives in Cijantung, East Jakarta:

I think TV crime shows are very good for housewives who spend most of their time at home. They give us information about what is going on out there. This information is useful every time I go out.

But now I tend to be negative and suspicious of other people, particularly when I'm on public transportation. The more I watch crime shows, the more frightened I become.

It's hard to say if I agree or disagree with the shows. On the one hand, the facts show that crime is increasing. On the other hand, these shows scare me and have affected me psychologically.

-- Leo Wahyudi S.