UI Professors Urge Supreme Court to See Beyond Procedure in Bahlil Dissertation Case
The Chair of the Board of Professors of the Faculty of Medicine, University of Indonesia (FKUI), Teddy Prasetyono, has requested that the Supreme Court look beyond mere administrative aspects in the cassation case regarding the cancellation of ethical sanctions against the dissertation promoter of the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, Bahlach Lahadalia.
He stated that violations of academic ethics must be viewed as a serious issue, the impact of which can damage the world of science. According to Teddy, ethical violations in the academic world have an impact no less serious than corruption, as they can undermine the process of producing scientific knowledge, which serves as the foundation for societal progress.
“When we as citizens see corruption, it is the entire nation that suffers. The academic world faces similar temptations,” said Teddy during an Amicus Curative press conference for the University of Indonesia at the UI Salemba Campus, Central Jakarta, on Thursday, 4 June 2026.
He noted that academics are required to produce scientific works and new knowledge. However, in the process, there is always the temptation to take shortcuts to achieve prestige, academic positions, or public recognition. Teddy argued that such practices are essentially a form of ‘scientific corruption’ because they produce academic products that are not obtained through legitimate and honest processes. “The world of science is being corrupted illegitimately and even unlawfully. Such products can be very dangerous because they are misleading,” he said.
He cited the impact of academic violations in the field of medicine, noting that invalid research results have the potential to influence medical practices and ultimately endanger patients. To illustrate the seriousness of academic ethics, Teddy recounted several cases of research forgery that have shaken world-renowned universities, such as a skin tissue development study on mice in the 1970s that was later revealed to be faked using permanent marker.
Teddy also mentioned several cases of academic integrity violations that have occurred at prestigious institutions such as the National University of Singapore (NUS), Harvard University, Oxford University, and Tsinghua University. However, he noted that these universities take decisive action when violations are discovered. “Renowned universities act decisively to ensure there is no room for academic violators,” he said.
Consequently, Teddy believes that the University of Indonesia’s decision to impose ethical sanctions on those deemed to have violated academic standards is part of the institution’s responsibility to maintain the integrity of science. He stated that the open stance taken by UI professors is not merely about one specific case, but an effort to protect the dignity of the university so that ethical violations are not allowed to pass without correction.
Teddy emphasised that universities possess an independence that must be respected, including in enforcing academic standards and imposing sanctions for violations within the campus environment. Therefore, he requested that the Supreme Court judges examining the cassation do not only look at procedural and administrative aspects but also consider the ethical dimension which is the core of the issue.
“The Judges at the Supreme Court are invited to not only look at the administrative issue, but to recognise that the academic world of the university possesses its own independence,” he said.
The cassation was filed after the Administrative Court (PTUN) granted the lawsuit filed by Bahlil Lahadalia’s dissertation promoter, thereby cancelling the ethical sanctions previously imposed by the University of Indonesia. This ruling triggered a response from UI professors, with 301 professors submitting an amicus curiae to the Supreme Court to support UI’s efforts to maintain its authority in enforcing academic integrity.
Teddy expressed hope that the panel of judges would view the case more broadly, as it concerns the future of academic governance and university autonomy in Indonesia. “Hopefully, the judges at the Supreme Court will follow their conscience and view the matter more wisely,” he said.
Bahlil Lahadalia has not yet responded to the ethical ruling or subsequent legal steps. In previous occasions, he only stated that he would follow the process and referred to the matter as an internal campus issue. “I respect whatever UI decides, because as a student, I will read and see what needs to be done,” Bahlil said in March 2025.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ui-professors-urge-supreme-court-to-see-beyond-procedure-in-bahlil-dissertation-case-1780602654)
Originally published by Tempo (Indonesian) (https://nasional.tempo.co/read/2106923/permintaan-guru-besar-ui-ke-ma-dalam-kasus-disertasi-bahlil), translated from Indonesian