Thinking the unthinkable?
Thinking the unthinkable?
As the authorities remain silent in the face of rising demands
for openness, the desire for further democratization snowballs. A
short while ago, House Speaker Wahono asked lawmakers to reflect
on their performances as representatives of the people. Now
several scholars are also airing their ideas on how to make the
country's political system more efficient.
Noted Moslem scholar Nurcholish Madjid voiced his opinion,
suggesting that the checks-and-balance system be improved by
allowing the two political parties outside the government -- the
United Development Party (PPP) and the Indonesian Democratic
Party (PDI) -- to act as opposition parties. According to
Nurcholish, if the two function as opposition parties, the
executive branch could effectively be kept in check.
Under the present circumstances, however, the meritorious idea
sounds both unthinkable and unworkable, even though two political
observers from Yogyakarta's Gadjah Mada University have voiced
the same idea. In their view this country is badly in need of
opposition parties, not only to make the system more effective,
but because the New Order has lost its reformist touch.
The two political parties have long complained about the
confusion surrounding their identity and purpose. The authorities
have repeatedly said that they are neither opposition parties nor
government parties.
Many questions have been raised about the nature of their
existence. If they are not opposition parties, then why are they
kept outside of the administration? Even when the United
Development Party legitimately won the general elections in
Jakarta and South Kalimantan in 1971 and every election in Aceh
from 1971 to 1982, the doors to local administrative leadership
remained closed.
To the uninformed, the system is confusing because the two
parties are demanding the same treatment that the administration-
backed Golkar party receives during general elections. They say
they should have the right to open branch offices below the
regency level. Golkar does not need such a presence because all
the authorities are Golkar members and activists and in many
cases it is difficult to distinguish between the two.
As is to be expected, the authorities continue to frown on new
ideas about political reform. They would prefer to preserve the
status quo and brush aside reform initiatives that would help
make our system more viable amid a growing number of democratic
countries. Minister of Home Affairs Moch. Yogie SM, who is
responsible for political development in this country, has
rejected the ideas. He has said that they are "not needed" and
that the current political system is useful.
Some experts suspect that the authorities object to the word
"opposition" because it sounds liberal. Yet there is no doubt
that few of us, if any, want a return to the "liberalist"
political chaos that prevailed in the 1950s. While political
parties were born from the womb of the western political system,
the explanation of our aversion to the term may found in local
tradition. Here it is common for the Javanese to call the tiger
mbah (grandfather in Javanese) instead of macan (tiger in
Javanese) in the belief that the beast must be respected, lest it
cause you harm.
Opposition, in the truest meaning of the word, may not be
harmful to any mature political system. The idea needs to be
discussed, as does the meaning of the Indonesian (1945)
Constitution's stipulation that the People's Consultative
Assembly, the country's highest law-making body, makes its
decisions by majority vote.
More from 8 September 1995 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/thinking-the-unthinkable-1447893297-1187295)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post