Statesmanship needed
Statesmanship needed
Neighboring countries which have repeatedly proven their
capability in coming up with fresh ideas to solve international
conflicts in the past do well to solve any disputes that may
exist between them on a bilateral basis, rather than inviting a
third party to mediate.
At least that is what the Indonesian and Malaysian governments
agreed upon last week. And as we look into the background of the
dispute which is currently festering between the two nations, the
accord certainly sounds reasonable, not to say encouraging.
Although it may seem to be insignificant at present, the dispute
in question has the potential to become a serious conflict in the
future unless managed with wisdom.
Both countries seem to find it difficult to remove the islands
of Sipadan and Ligitan, located off the east coast of East
Kalimantan, from their respective national maps. Indonesia claims
its map is based on an agreement signed in 1891 between Britain
and the Netherlands, the respective colonial rulers of Malaysia
and Indonesia at that time. According to this pact the two small
islands are part of the territory of what was then the
Netherlands East Indies, the present independent state of
Indonesia.
Since that time, maps of the Indonesian archipelago have
incorporated those two islands. The Malaysians apparently did not
begin to include them on their maps until 1969. Jakarta insists
that Malaysia's claim over the islands did not come until after
Indonesia reasserted its ownership in 1967. Two years later
Malaysia put the two islands on its national maps as part of the
country's territory. And it was not until 1983 that Malaysia
started enforcing its claim with the passing of a state law.
Jakarta argues that all of this is a proof that Malaysia never
before showed any objection to the Indonesian claim over Sipadan
and Ligitan.
Nevertheless, the dispute has surfaced. But, in the spirit of
cooperation and ASEAN solidarity, which prevails in this region,
the two countries agreed in 1969 to maintain the status quo. And
in 1983, when President Soeharto met with Malaysian Prime
Minister Mahathir Mohamad on the Malaysian island of Langkawi,
the two leaders agreed to solve the problem through a negotiated
diplomatic settlement.
In September last year, however, Kuala Lumpur indicated that
it had lost confidence in the effectiveness of the ongoing
bilateral talks with Jakarta, or in a possible mediation through
the mechanism provided in the framework of the Association of
Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). The Secretary-General of the
Malaysian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ahmad Kamil Jaafar, who
was leading a delegation for the talks, said that the best
solution to the dispute would be to call in a third party.
The third party he had in mind was apparently the
International Court of Justice. However, it appeared that
Indonesia did not see much use or relevance in such a move.
This went on until last week when Indonesia and Malaysia
reportedly arrived at the same stance that the two countries,
which are expected to contribute more to efforts to settle
conflicts in the region and in the world, should avoid inviting
the involvement of a third party. This is understandable because
both countries traditionally believe in the wisdom of musyawarah,
or deliberation leading to consensus, or accord.
The fact is that the Sipadan and Ligitan dispute could easily
tarnish ASEAN's credibility if it were to be taken to the
International Court of Justice in The Hague, where the United
Nations judicial organization has its headquarters.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/statesmanship-needed-1447893297-1190671)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post