Managing firms in ASEAN
Managing firms in ASEAN
By Bob Widyahartono
This is the second of two articles based on a paper presented
at the opening ceremony of the Magister Management program at the
Institute for Management Development of Indonesia on Jan. 27,
1996.
JAKARTA: Globalization has in one way or another paradoxical
effects. We recently became more aware of the "borderless world"
so acclaimed by Kenichi Ohmae, where business activities take
place wherever and whenever they prove profitable. And inevitably
creates an increased sense of groupism, and therefore it becomes
essential for managers to learn how to manage well in different
cultural contexts, sometimes changing or adapting their points of
reference and mind-sets.
As mentioned earlier, cultures implicitly contain the concepts
of ethical sensitivity. Our culture or mindscape conditions us in
the way we perceive the objective world and how we ought to
respond to it. It affects how we value, what we value, how we
behave in a certain situation, how we go about achieving what we
want to achieve in management, and therefore it strongly
influences what we strive to reach and how we assess other
people.
In interacting with Westerners or western-style educated
executives we often note their remarks of "Most Asian workers are
inscrutable and seem big on vagueness and equivocations."
Why do many (not all) Westerners and western educated managers
tend to label common Asian workers as lazy and superstitious? Is
it because of their western upbringing that they question
everything with: why, why not, what if or so what? Is it
realistic to accuse Asians of having no sense of time and of
ignoring "time management" and precision and therefore being
incapable of appreciating the essence of planning? In the Western
point of view and values, much of our behavior will indeed seem
as they describe.
These generalities are definitely non valid propositions. On
the other hand, are Westerners and western educated managers free
of weaknesses?
In my opinion, ASEAN managers have more commonalities than
their Western counterparts, in entering an era of total
competition. They are entering an era where winning is going to
be more and more difficult. Here lies the challenge for managers
to test their ability to formulate competitive strategies and
generate real and lasting competitive abilities. They too can be
tough in dealing with other people and still maintain their Asian
identity.
The ASEAN business community has a distinct cultural flavor,
particularly those businesses owned by ASEAN's ethnic Chinese (as
those in Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam
and Singapore). Matthew Montagu-Pollock in All the Right
Connections (Asian Business, Jan. 1991), mentioned that Chinese
businesses outside mainland China have amazing advantages over
"modern" methods. With their rational thinking, many Westerners
are of the opinion that the Chinese appear to be doing absolutely
nothing right according to western management standards, and they
must have succeeded for other reasons: because they are
constantly feeling insecure, are industrious Confucians, or
highly educated.
No one admitted until recently that Chinese firms have been
successful because they are well managed. After long neglect of
Chinese management (which sofar is not yet written as a standard
concept) Hong Kong University's Center for Asian Studies and its
Business School in 1990 put together a well-researched picture of
typical Chinese businesses (mostly family-owned with single
management).
It draws a broad contrast between the typical Chinese company
and the typical Western or even Japanese company. One difference
immediately stands out which entails guanxi (relationship or
networking) and shinyung (trust and confidence). Systems of
contacts based on mutual trust seem to be the most important
ingredient. Legal contracts are rare, and one has to know the
people one is dealing with.
It is a question of risk reduction. Chinese businesses are a
multiplicity of small firms. These small firms are interconnected
through networks. It is like a spider's web and not organized in
a formal way, and there is no formal contract. Most agreements
are oral. But due to the cultural background there is a rather
stable relationship.
Most firms are not large, but if you take the networks as a
whole, they are large. With guanxi and shinyung, the success of
Chinese firms (of course there are also failures) during the last
two decades owe a great deal to their advantages: flexibility,
speed and diversification.
Generally, Chinese firms in ASEAN or even in newly
industrialized economies are often low profile, and are
frequently in unglamorous businesses (except a handful of
conglomerates who like publicity as a means to promote
themselves).
Chinese businesses in Southeast Asia range from large and
modern conglomerates to small and medium enterprises and the core
family member is the top manager or chief executive officer. The
most common forms of overseas Chinese businesses are small and
medium enterprises. There is little formal organization, less
delegation of authority and little reliance on staff work even in
the largest firms.
Family in the Chinese context is quite unlike the West's
concept of family. It stretches to the furthest horizons, from
close family, to slightly distant, to more distant, embracing
people who are not really family but who are connected to someone
in one's family by marriage, to friends and family. The family is
really a system of contacts, rather than an emotional unit as in
the West.
As explained above, the successful Chinese entrepreneur is one
who is able to make guanxi work for him. He honors his
obligations and is a good and loyal friend. He has a reputation
for fairness, he gives partners their due share. He does favors,
he can be relied upon, he will reciprocate. He is fully civilized
because he is benevolent. A good businessperson is truly Chinese.
Of course there are many instances of bad and unreliable Chinese
businesspeople who have different characters. They will be
excluded from the normal business environment if they continue to
be unsavory.
The opening of world markets and intro-Asian trade has
triggered integration and liberalization movements as displayed
by GATT, APEC and AFTA and the Asian growth polygons. These
dynamic changes challenge senior executives and managers to be
more aware of what to expect from their managerial capabilities
as strategists, the essential success factors of investment
potentials and prospects.
Many ASEAN firms have opted to take up "modern management".
They select managers by publicly stated objective criteria and
establish clear management goals, giving managers the authority
to reach those objectives. They also formalize promotion systems
and face-to-face performance reviews. But this "modern
management" goes along the same lines as traditional management
where strategic decisions are still in the hands of a few (owner
and entrusted family members as senior managers) which has proven
to be successful. A kind of synergy between traditional and
modern rational management are entering the new era.
Henry-Claude de Bettinies in Management in Asia An Overview
rightly stated that the important issue, however, is not so much
how the West is able to anticipate the future of the Pacific's
dynamics, but rather how the main actors in the region can
control it effectively. The need today is to emphasize how much
technology (including management know-how) is a prerequisite to
development. Technology is the fuel, as human resources is the
locomotive.
The continuous growth, the development of the Asian region
during the decade leading to the year 2000, will therefore rely
to a large extent upon the availability of skills "to manage
change" and influence it strategically toward specific
objectives.
Managing organizations (business or otherwise) in ASEAN's
dynamic socioeconomic environment, with limited infrastructure
and technical skills, with flexible rules of the game, is part of
the challenge which executives still face in entering the
globalization era.
I agree with Henri-Claude de Bettignies that ASEAN countries
with the exception of Singapore still experience a significant
shortage of managerial talent, in spite of a large reservoir of
human resources. Not enough entrepreneurs and not enough managers
for development. This shortage contributes to inefficiency, a
waste of resources, and strategic mistakes. Three critical
ingredients are required for the long-term success: professional
skills, global vision and ethical behavior in line with
respective cultures.
Here lies the challenge of management education to provide the
appropriate blend of entrepreneurship, professionalism and
attitude. The challenge for management institutes is to produce
responsible entrepreneurial managers who have global vision and
who engage in ethical behavior. Developing ASEAN managers require
a greater understanding of ASEAN environmental conditions and
insight into societal values.
Management in ASEAN and Asia will not -- in the foreseeable
future -- become Westernized. It will keep an original ASEAN and
Asian identity, because management has to do with people.
Management skills will only become effective when they
integrate the values embodied within a given technology with what
gives individuals their own identities in the Asia-Pacific
dynamism.
Bob Widyahartono, Dean, Faculty of Economics, Indonusa Esa
Unggul University.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/managing-firms-in-asean-1447893297-1041932)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post