Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesian diplomats

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Indonesian diplomats

It was a shock to me to read the news report which disclosed
that our diplomats are poor debaters. (The Jakarta Post, Sept.
22). Since the opinion was expressed in the House of
Representatives, it is worth commenting.

There is no doubt about the credibility of the judgment,
coming as it did from the number one diplomat, to quote the Post.
However, our legislators must know that functionally speaking the
diplomatic mission can be classified into two categories.

The first category is pure functionalism as it covers the
general function of representing the sending state in the
receiving state, reporting to the sending state conditions and
developments in the receiving state, promoting friendly relations
and developing cultural, economic and scientific ties between the
sending and the receiving states.

The second category requires professionalism in as much as the
job demands high skill in know-how, proficiency in foreign
languages and expert knowledge. It is in evidence in conducting
negotiations with the receiving state.

The aforementioned functions are set out in the Vienna
Convention on Diplomatic Relations of 1961, which came into force
on April 24, 1964. But literature of international law adds
another prominent function which squarely fits in the context of
modern practice. This is the promotion of trade between both
states and the promotion of public relations in the receiving
state. This may be amplified by the promotion of technological
know-how to the mutual benefit of both states.

As a matter of fact, it is in the field of negotiations, and
not necessarily in debates, where the skillfulness, eloquence and
intelligence of the diplomat are required.

Extemporaneous debates can arise, of course, in such forums as
the UN General Assembly, the UN Security Council and in
specialized international conferences. But in the daily ordinary
life of the diplomat relating to the performance of his job, it
is the functions of the first category that prevail.

After all, a debate would be pointless if the counterpart is
outwitted in the process of verbal entanglement, causing him to
walk out. Since negotiation requires language proficiency and
expert knowledge, these are the skills which are foremost and
need to be implanted within the rank and file of our diplomats of
the younger generation. Without mastery of such qualities, they
will probably not be able to conduct negotiations satisfactorily,
let alone debate.

In the history of Indonesian diplomacy, beginning with the
signing of the Linggardjati Agreement in 1947, Agus Salim, L.N.
Palar and Mohamad Roem were reputed for their diplomatic
negotiating skills. Prof. George Kahin of Cornell University
values Roem's gentleness of manner behind his toughness, capacity
to grasp different viewpoints, political perceptivity and
unswerving honesty as factors toward his considerable
contribution to the good of the country.

Name and Address

known to the Editor

More from 6 October 1995 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesian-diplomats-1447893297-1205091)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print