Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Indonesia in transition: Some parting thoughts

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Indonesia in transition: Some parting thoughts

By J. Stapleton Roy

This is the second and last part of a presentation by the
outgoing U.S. Ambassador to Indonesia at the Indonesian Council
on World Affairs (ICWA) in Jakarta on Wednesday.

JAKARTA (JP): As many Indonesian observers have pointed out,
the 1945 Constitution gives great power to the President and the
Executive Branch of government. Article 17, for example, gives
the president the sole power to appoint and dismiss cabinet
ministers. There is no provision that the DPR must approve such
appointments. Indeed, the Interpretation of the Constitution
makes clear that the president is not responsible to the DPR,
except insofar as its members are also members of the MPR. Even
in the case of ordinary legislation, Article 22 gives the
president the power to govern by government regulations in lieu
of statutes "should exigency compel." While these "regulations in
lieu of statutes" must be approved by the DPR in its next
session, this provision has in practice enabled the presidency to
use such authority to undercut and bypass the legislative body.

In an equally important area relating to the judiciary,
neither Article 24 nor 25 of the constitution provides for an
independent judiciary. Without such a provision, the judiciary
cannot serve as a genuine check on a strong executive. To perform
this function, the judiciary must be able to undertake vigorous,
independent, judicial review of government actions, to balance
the traditionally strong executive and a newly invigorated
legislature. The courts are also paramount in resolving issues
related to individual freedoms and rights, as the process of
reform proceeds. Individuals should be able to depend on the
right to due process to prevent abuse of authority. The need for
public order must be balanced by respect for legally enforceable
individual human rights. The judiciary needs modernization and
empowerment as an independent branch of government to enable it
to enforce the rule of law and ensure good governance, free of
interference or corruption.

The effectiveness of the courts in upholding human rights can
easily be undermined if protection for these rights is not
guaranteed in the constitution. Article 28, which deals with
fundamental freedoms such as freedom of association and assembly
and of written and oral expression, refers to these freedoms but
does not guarantee them. Instead it specifies that these freedoms
will be prescribed by statute. As we know from the history of
press laws in many countries, that provides little or not
protection to these freedoms.

A free press in Indonesia, as in other countries, is
absolutely essential as a check on governmental abuses, whether
in the form of corruption or of arbitrary use of power. A free
press can alert governments to rising sentiments of
dissatisfaction in time for correction action to be taken.
Governments that suppress a free media live in perpetual fear of
the people they govern since they lack a barometer on public
opinion. A free press can provide a forum for discussion of major
national issues and an outlet for the expression of views on
Indonesia's future. A free press is a necessary precondition for
true pluralistic, participatory democracy, because only a well-
informed electorate can make intelligent choices. I congratulate
the Minister of Information, Muhammad Yunus, for his support of
press freedom. At the same time, Indonesia's own experience would
suggest that stronger constitutional guarantees are needed to
protect press freedom in the future.

Finally, given the explicit language in Article 37 on how to
alter the Constitution, one wonders why there is so much
discussion over how or whether to do this. This is one provision
where the constitution is completely clear, and yet it has never
been used. Since a constitution is the basic law of the land, the
underlying principle is that it should be harder to amend a
constitution than to enact ordinary legislation, but it should
not be so hard as to make it impossible. This is already provided
for in Article 37, which requires a two-thirds vote of the MPR
with two-thirds of the members present to amend the constitution.
Only simple majorities are required to pass other legislation.
Establishing the tradition that the constitution can be changed
without reopening basic issues that underpin the unity and
integrity of Indonesia with all its diversity represents a real
but surmountable challenge.

Obviously, there are many other key issues that we have no
time to address today. These include the role of the armed forces
in political life; the role of government in the economy; the
allocation of responsibility between the central government and
the regions; and how to promote economic development in ways that
do not destroy Indonesia's great heritage of a beautiful natural
environment. The advantage of a democratic system is that it
creates the means for addressing such issues peacefully through
decisions of the people and their elected representatives.

Political stability will facilitate implementation of economic
reforms. Establishing Indonesia on sound growth path calls for a
predictable legal environment and the development of public
economic institutions that, like a properly functioning
judiciary, exercise their regulatory power in a sure and
objective manner. The political transition has given the nation
an opportunity to determine what aspects of the past it wishes to
retain and which to change. National sentiment appears
overwhelmingly to endorse perfecting, not rejecting, Indonesia's
market-based economic system, maintaining trade and financial
links with the global community, and drawing upon private sector
resources to finance future development. Reform efforts center on
eradicating opportunities for future abuse of power and
privilege.

In Indonesia as in other countries, conducting business
relationships openly, fairly, and objectively is the best way to
ensure confidence in the system and in the country. In settling
business disputes, the fairness of the process even more than the
specific outcomes will help convince investors, foreign and
domestic, that Indonesia is worthy of their confidence.

Signs of economic recovery at present are encouraging but
fragile. The process could still be derailed, especially if
partisan political maneuvering distorts implementation of
economic policy. Sound economic recovery can only be impeded by
deviations from consistent, dispassionate economic policy-making
and implementation. The activism of Indonesia's media means that
distortions will be revealed. Distortions in turn sap domestic
and international investors'' confidence, a critical but
intangible factor in Indonesia's efforts to spur a return to
growth and reduce the costs of recovery to be borne by
Indonesia's future generations.

To manage its diverse society successfully, Indonesia needs to
continue developing as a "civil society," that is, a society in
which citizens are free to participate, and indeed are-expected
to participate' in institutions which contribute to decision-
making' through non-governmental organizations as well as through
official or governmental bodies. An active civil society'
supported by civic education in the schools to prepare young
people for responsible citizenship, helps citizens make informed
choices and take part in government and politics.

Ethnic and religious tolerance, long a positive attribute of
Indonesia, needs nurturing and support. The economic crisis
uncovered underlying tensions and feelings of injustice less
evident when the economy was growing. A legitimate government
with leadership able to transcend geographic, ethnic, and
religious boundaries will be best equipped to reduce tensions and
educate citizens to be tolerant of those who are different in one
way or another. As two countries with large and diverse
populations, the United States and Indonesia have much to learn
from each other in these areas.

As with all large countries, Indonesia also needs to find the
right balance between the interests of the central government and
the interests of the regions. Legitimate representative
government will make resolution of this issue more likely.
Meaningful decentralization should help ameliorate grievances and
feelings of injustice in Aceh, Irian Jaya, and elsewhere.

Before closing, let me comment briefly on East Timor, a
problem that has lingered for a quarter of a century and that has
been a burden for Indonesia both domestically and
internationally. Coinciding with its democratic transition,
Indonesia has created for itself an unprecedented opportunity to
put this issue onto a new footing that will benefit both
Indonesia and the people of East Timor. If conditions can be
created so that a truly valid voting process, internationally
supervised and internationally recognized, can take place on Aug.
30, then a major step will have been taken toward a solution,
whether by means of granting East Timor broad autonomy or by
separation from Indonesia.

Such a favorable outcome cannot yet be assured. Last month I
accompanied Assistant Secretary Stanley Roth to East Timor for a
three-day visit. Both of us were encouraged by the manner in
which registration was proceeding and by the improved cooperation
between UNAMET and the Indonesian military and police authorities
there. At the same time, both of us came away concerned about
security. For the consultation to be a success, all eligible
voters, whether proautonomy or pro-separation, must be free to
express their views and vote for their preferred outcome without
being subject to threat or intimidation. This includes the tens
of thousands of internally displaced persons who have been forced
to flee their homes due to violence and threats.

As provided for in the historic agreement signed in New York
on May 5 by Indonesia, Portugal, and the United Nations,
Indonesia is responsible for ensuring a peaceful environment in
East Timor so that the voting process can take place as
scheduled. We urge all parties to work together to create such
conditions, whether by ending intimidation, sequestering arms,
permitting Xanana Gusmao to travel to East Timor, or ensuring
fair and even-handed treatment for all sides.

No matter what the result of the voting process, it will be
important for all parties to respect the outcome. The problem of
East Timor will not end on Aug. 30. In fact, the most difficult
challenges may lie ahead: in making sure that autonomy works if
that is the choice of the East Timorese; or in ensuring that a
separate East Timor becomes a close friend and cooperative
partner of Indonesia if that is the preference of the majority of
East Timorese. In either case it will be essential that the
majority act in a manner that respects the interests and dignity
of the minority.

Given the special international character of the East Timor
problem, it is also important for friends of Indonesia to act
responsibly so that the treatment accorded East Timor does not
exacerbate separatist tendencies elsewhere in Indonesia, thus
enabling your country to provide a successful example of how to
maintain both unity and diversity. That can only be accomplished,
of course, by ensuring social justice for the whole Indonesian
people.

A commitment to fairness, justice, and humanity, as enshrined
in the 1945 constitution, must also be part of the solution to
the problem of the escalating violence in Aceh, a province that
played a significant role in Indonesia's own independence
struggle. When I visited Aceh in February it was vividly clear
that the root of the problem lay in deeply felt grievances among
the Acehnese over the perceived lack of justice, both in
accounting for current and past abuses in the province and in
sharing the province's natural wealth. Fortunately, the
Indonesian government is seeking to address these concerns, for
which there cannot be a purely military solution. A sustained and
comprehensive political approach to addressing the grievances in
the province would pay real dividends. Arbitrary violence there
by any party, whether directed at the security forces or by the
security forces themselves, will only victimize the people of
Aceh and prolong the task of finding a peaceful political
solution. My own country supports a resolution of these
grievances in the context of a stable unified Indonesian nation.

I have not tried to discuss every aspect of U.S.-Indonesian
relations over the time of my assignment as American Ambassador.
That would not be possible in the time we have together today.
Instead, I have focused on the political transition that
Indonesians initiated through a long year of dynamic domestic
debate and activity.

Now, I am preparing to leave for a new assignment in
Washington. My successor, Robert Gelbard, will arrive soon to
lead the American Embassy into the new millennium, and I hope he
will witness a period of new progress and growth in Indonesia.

Coincidentally, my assignment ends in the year, 1999, marking
the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations
between our two countries. A series of cultural and educational
events are taking place in both countries to celebrate this
Golden Anniversary. This year has been memorable for me
personally, but the importance of 1999, for Indonesia, is truly
historic.

More from 13 August 1999 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/indonesia-in-transition-some-parting-thoughts-1447893297-1442667)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print