'I don't care' about graft report: Minister

'I don't care' about graft report: Minister

Muninggar Sri Saraswati and Rendi A. Witular, The Jakarta Post, Jakarta

Government officials appeared indifferent when responding to a
survey by Transparency International Indonesia (TII), which
ranked Jakarta and the customs office most corrupt institutions.

"I don't care," was the simple response of Minister of Finance
Yusuf Anwar, who oversees the customs service, on Thursday when
commenting on the survey findings.

Meanwhile, Jakarta Governor Sutiyoso said that the fact that
his feif was the most corrupt city "makes sense".

Speaking at the State Palace, Yusuf said, "Just let it go. I
don't care. All I care about are the improvements in governance
and oversight that are taking place. It is more important to try
to make an effort instead of trying to make the headlines." He
added, "The public do not see our efforts, but things are
improving.

"TII can say what it likes as it is only looking for
headlines," he added.

Apart from the customs service, the finance ministry also
oversees the tax service, which is named as the eleventh most
corrupt institution in TII's list.

Yusuf claimed that the amount of state funds lost to
corruption was very small, pointing out that the issue was
"exaggerated by certain parties".

Citing an example, he said only 2 percent of the country's
three million taxpayers evaded paying taxes last year.

"The claim that 40 percent of the country's tax revenues are
embezzled is 'bullshit'," Yusuf said, referring to median
estimates of state losses in the tax and customs services made by
observers. "We have done a lot in trying to create accountable
and transparent systems in the tax and customs services."

"The director of the taxation service has dismissed six
officials so far this year for corruption. We have also improved
our supervision over the customs office at Tanjung Priok port,"
he added.

The 2004 Indonesian Corruption Perception Index survey,
conducted between last October and December with 1,305 business
owners and top managers of local and multinational firms as
respondents, revealed that the customs service had the highest
incidence of corrupt interactions at 62 percent.

Some 140 respondents said they had to pay bribes to the
customs service approximately 31 times per year, with each bribe
averaging Rp 38 million (US4,086).

Sutiyoso, meanwhile, said that with over 70 percent of the
country's economic transactions taking place in the capital city,
so "it makes sense that most corruption cases took place here".

The survey, he argued, was not about corruption "within the
city administration".

Sutiyoso also believed that the survey might have selected the
wrong respondents.

"Take the city public works agency as an example. With
hundreds of projects being put out to tender, many businessmen
fail to win contracts. If they were to respond to the survey, of
course they will accuse the tender winners of bribery."

The governor, who will end his second term in 2007, believed
that his administration could curb corruption by cooperating with
the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) in setting up a mail
box for the public to file complaints as well as establishing a
regional ombudsman.

The responses of the two officials were regretted by TII board
of directors member Todung Mulya Lubis.

"Those comments show the government's arrogance. They should
have been ashamed (with the survey findings) instead of getting
angry," he said. "The report reflects the business
community's perceptions on corruption. The government should have
reflected on its performance."

The noted lawyer reminded the government that the business
community had yet to see any of the changes promised by the new
government, including a renewed fight against corruption, the
resolving of high-profile disputes involving foreign investors,
improved legal certainty and attracting more investment.