High-cost economy
High-cost economy
The high-cost economy issue has surfaced again. Interestingly,
the issue has been raised by senior economists who, as former
members of the national team of technocrats, helped bring
Indonesia's economy back from near ruin in the late-1960s.
Emil Salim, who held several ministerial positions in the
cabinets during the 1970s and 1980s, noted early this week that
Indonesia has now come to the point where irregularities,
corruption, bribes and similar traits are the major factors
affecting Indonesia's competitive position.
Subroto, another senior economist and former cabinet member,
has warned that the country's economy has reached a critical
point. He asserted that unless such high-cost components as red-
tape and malfeasance are removed, Indonesia's export
competitiveness could be eroded.
Subroto's remarks, made during a gathering of alumni from the
University of Indonesia's Djakarta School of Economics,
strengthened similar observations he made last May.
We took special note of Subroto's observations in view of his
ability to look at the country's condition from a fresh
perspective. He recently returned to Jakarta after living in
Vienna for more than six years as the secretary-general of the
Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries.
Having said that, we don't mean to imply that Subroto now
tends to assess things from the perspective of Western analysts.
He simply had the benefit of time and distance to become
sensitive to things that long-time residents now take for
granted.
Those in the government bureaucracy might not agree with
Subroto's attributing the high-cost economy to administrative
red-tape and malfeasance. Indeed, many packages of economic and
bureaucratic reform measures have been implemented since 1985.
Subroto was talking in terms of Indonesia's economic
competitiveness in the international market and not about what
the bureaucratic reforms have achieved. While the government
might think it has achieved bureaucratic reform, that
acchievement is still far from adequate to make the country's
economy highly competitive internationally. Many other countries
have accomplished more with regard to the development of
efficient and effective governance.
Public (government) services and licensing authority are a
problem because they are a government monopoly. Since users have
no alternative but to accept poor administrative service, the
layers of bureaucrats in charge rarely respond to the needs of
customers. Many members of the government and the public now
accept the practices as normal and tolerable when they are
considered irregularities overseas.
Some officials don't seem to realize that corruption and
other forms of bureaucratic excess severely distort normal market
operations. Simply put, corruption reduces the power of the state
and its ability to play its presumably corrective role in the
economy.
The government should be magnanimous in receiving criticism
and not immediately demand that the critics produce evidence to
support their points of views. Instead, the well-meaning
criticisms should prompt the government to make its rules and
regulations more transparent. Strengthening audits, checks and
other mechanisms of control over civil servants will also
contribute to an efficient and effective governance and
consequently to a more efficient economy.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/high-cost-economy-1447893297-1205082)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post