East Timor's history ignored
East Timor's history ignored
Sri Pamoedjo Rahardjo
This is the first of two articles on East Timor.
JAKARTA (JP): Confusing signals from concerned international
agencies, the Indonesian government and politicians about the
East Timor issue have resulted in chaos. Government officials
seem to show ambivalence toward East Timor in response to
international pressure. Only a few months ago, the government
took a firm stand saying East Timor was an integral part of
Indonesia.
The meaning of reform has been muddled, from development to
drastic legislative change. In doing so, the government may seem
to have lost its vigor to protect its own people. The unique
facts and history of the country's provinces, including East
Timor, seem to have been forgotten. The conflict has claimed
thousands of lives of both ordinary citizens and the military.
The fate of disabled citizens, of crippled soldiers and the
welfare of thousands of others who are directly or indirectly
related to the victims has been compromised.
In a bizarre twist of events, the international community now
seem to regard "Xanana" Gusmao and Jose Ramos-Horta as heroes,
whereas Abilio Soares, the current governor, and prointegration
Timorese are the rebels. The Indonesian armed forces are seen as
the colonial force, Indonesian National Police as armed and
dangerous civilians.
We are now facing a comedy of errors. The current turmoil in
East Timor has been triggered by the political blunders made by
our own officials, by allowing the United Nations to raise East
Timor as an issue. Endorsing the UN's mediation implies lack of
historical knowledge on East Timorese's previous determination to
be one with the Republic of Indonesia.
Indonesia should learn from India when the country annexed Goa
decades ago. The Indian military forces stormed Goa. The
Portuguese army surrendered without a fight. The Indians were
welcomed by the people of Goa as liberators. Despite
international objections, India went ahead with annexation and
integration. Goa has become part of India.
Although there is some parallel between Goa and East Timor,
there is a difference. The Indonesian military forces were
invited by the pro-Indonesian forces to help stop the bloodshed
against the Fretilin forces.
Indonesia has maintained its stand as a non-expansionist
country. The government strove to get international recognition
for East Timor as part of Indonesia. Endorsement from our ASEAN
neighbors, non-aligned countries and some "friendly" countries
was forthcoming and Indonesia maintained endless diplomatic
initiatives on East Timor until the government decided overnight
to propose a vote, as if previous commitments had not been made.
This action was seized by secessionists groups to move into high
gear.
The international community has forgotten the background of
Indonesia's "invasion" of East Timor. At that time, the United
States was busy with its own war in Vietnam. During the Cold War,
the U.S. was worried by the apparent rise of a left-leaning
government in East Timor. As a proponent of the "domino theory",
Indonesia was urged to help avert the spread of communism in the
region. The deployment of Indonesian military volunteers to East
Timor was highly welcomed then.
What a price to pay! Today, the same superpower is backing up
the UN to possibly remove East Timor from the map of Indonesia.
Facts are now distorted to fit the image it wants to project. At
present, any discussion of East Timor is politically loaded with
human rights violations.
The prointegrationist faction requested that the territory
become part of Indonesia. The People's Consultative Assembly
(MPR) subsequently approved the request in 1976. Being a part of
Indonesia, the underlying assumptions for the structure of East
Timor's government apparatus and development plans were
integrated into the national government structure and development
plans for all the other provinces.
In addition, during the first decade after integration, huge
amounts of rupiah funds were pumped into East Timor to
rehabilitate and construct new infrastructure, among other things
roads, irrigation, public buildings, transport,
telecommunications, housing, health services and the school
system.
A conservative estimate of the cost is close to US$100 million
annually for the last 20 years. The aim was to provide basic
infrastructure in East Timor and close the gap between it and
other provinces in Indonesia. This kind of development was never
seen in East Timor in the hundreds of years under Portuguese
domination.
The deployment of human resources from other provinces was
necessary to support the developing infrastructure and administer
the laws of the Republic of Indonesia. Migrants from other
provinces, seizing this opportunity to build a better future for
themselves, entered the small-scale trade and the informal sector
in East Timor.
East Timorese and other Indonesians do not seem to realize
that all provinces under the Republic actually partake to
shoulder these huge development funds. In order to maintain
development in its provinces, the central government had to
obtain large loans from multilateral agencies, reaching $40
billion before the crisis.
The writer is a social and economic observer.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/east-timors-history-ignored-1447893297-1442607)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post