Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Part 2 of 2

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Part 2 of 2

The ASEAN model of economic integration

Romeo A. Reyes, Jakarta

It is now evident but not yet widely recognized that economic
integration is the key to enhance competitiveness of Southeast
Asian countries. ASEAN can play a significant facilitating role
to make this market imperative happen.

Many years of regional cooperation have paved the way for an
increasingly higher comfort level among ASEAN countries to
further deepen and broaden such cooperation. This was
demonstrated when ASEAN Leaders declared in Bali Concord II the
creation of the AEC by 2020.

They envision in the AEC a stable, prosperous and highly
competitive region functioning as a single market and production
base, in which there is free flow of goods, services and skilled
labor and a freer flow of capital, along with equitable economic
development and reduced poverty and socio-economic disparities.

It is important to note that economic integration is not an
end in itself. Rather, it is a tool for enhancing
competitiveness, which is an economic imperative for sustained
economic growth. But more importantly, it is also a tool for
reducing poverty and realizing equitable and inclusive
development within and across ASEAN countries. This is another
important feature of the ASEAN economic integration model.

In pursuing the AEC, the Leaders decided to accelerate
economic integration in 11 priority sectors by 2010, and
instructed their Economic Ministers to prepare Roadmaps for
integration in those 11 priority sectors for possible adoption at
the forthcoming Summit in Vientiane in November 2004.

A sector based approach is yet another feature of the ASEAN
economic integration model. The approach focuses integration
efforts initially on a few selected sectors with a view to
scaling them up later and then applying lessons learned earlier.
A minimum necessary condition for any sector to function as a
single market and production base would be removal of tariff
barrier on its final and intermediate products.

However, it is possible if not likely that a critical
intermediate input to the sector is produced by another sector
not yet covered by integration measures. Unless tariff barriers
on that input are similarly dismantled, the sector cannot
effectively function as a single production base as outsourcing
of that input from one ASEAN country by another would be
hindered.

Another distinct feature of ASEAN economic integration is non-
formation of a Customs Union. As Singapore is already a free
port, formation of a Customs Union would mean that the other nine
countries would reduce their external tariff to zero or Singapore
would impose external tariff.

At best, harmonization of external tariff is being floated
around to minimize competitive distortion across member
countries, if ASEAN is to function as a single production base.
It would also facilitate negotiation of a Free Trade Agreement
between ASEAN and a number of its dialogue partners, including
China, even as ASEAN countries have agreed to form AFTA and
integrate themselves into one economic community. This suggests
that regional economic integration being pursued by ASEAN is in
the context of open regionalism.

As of Jan. 1, 2002, Common Effective Preferential Tariff
(CEPT) under AFTA had already been reduced to a range of 0 to 5
percent. However, due to difficulties in meeting the Rules of
Origin (ROO) to qualify for CEPT rate and the small margin
between MFN and CEPT rates, only 5 percent of intra-ASEAN trade
has actually made use of CEPT rates. This highlights the critical
importance of removing non-tariff barriers (NTBs) to the flow of
goods and services across national borders so that they could
freely flow as if the AEC is one country composed of ten
provinces.

There are many kinds of NTBs. Some are cross-border deriving
from complicated and cumbersome customs procedures, including
product valuation. Others are behind the border and are sometimes
referred to as technical barriers. They arise from differences in
technical regulations for safety and health reasons, product
quality standards, and testing/certification procedures.

To eliminate these NTBs, ASEAN countries would need to
liberalize, harmonize and automate their customs procedures. They
should also align and then mutually recognize their regulations,
standards, and the results of their testing procedures.
Otherwise, even with zero tariff, the vision of a single market
and production base can not be realized.

Removal of barriers to the flow of capital and labor in the
factor market poses a bigger challenge because of their political
sensitivity. With respect to capital, the notion of a foreign
investor freely setting and doing business and making and
repatriating profit continues to provoke and harbor nationalist
sentiments that find expression in national laws favoring
domestic investors.

But the key to the free flow of investment is to accord
national treatment to foreign investors, both from within and
outside ASEAN. The challenge for ASEAN is to change the public
mindset regarding foreign investment and to inculcate into that
mindset the long term benefit to ASEAN peoples as consumers
(rather than as profit seeking investors) of trade and investment
liberalization. Without this change in mindset, the political
will to amend the laws for national treatment of foreign
investors cannot be mustered.

With respect to labor, AEC envisions a free flow only of
skilled labor. Considering the sector based approach of the ASEAN
model of economic integration, the challenge is to agree on a
common definition of "skilled labor" in each of the 11 priority
sectors, harmonize their qualification standards, and mutually
recognize them so that skilled labor could flow freely in the
factor market.

Their availability and mobility across national borders would
be an important consideration when investors take a decision
whether to locate the production base of a skilled labor
intensive production process in ASEAN, or alternatively in China.
Their mobility should not be confused with movement of
professionals, self-employed or otherwise, in the trade of non-
factor services, which is also important if ASEAN is to function
as a single market.

ASEAN countries are now preparing Roadmaps for economic
integration in the 11 priority sectors. The big question is
whether the measures contained therein would be adequate and
effective in removing barriers to the flow of goods and services
in the product market and to the flow of capital and skilled
labor in the factor market, so that the AEC would function as a
single market and production base by 2010.

If they are, a related question is how to ensure that those
measures are implemented and enforced given the limited if not
lack of authority of the Secretariat for verification and
enforcement of compliance. Indeed, realization of the AEC would
depend not so much on the capacity as the political will of the
ASEAN countries to formulate, adopt and internally police
implementation of those measures.

The writer is Senior Adviser, ASEAN-UNDP Partnership Facility.
The views expressed herein are personal and do not necessarily
reflect those of ASEAN Secretariat, any of the ASEAN member
countries, or UNDP.

More from 20 July 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/bpart-2-of-2b-1447893297-1506545)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print