Behind the US–Iran Peace: Israel's Disappointment and Washington's Economic Calculus
When US President Donald Trump and Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkin signed a memorandum of understanding paving the way for 60 days of peace negotiations, the world’s attention immediately turned to the end of tensions that have shaken the Middle East for over three months.
However, behind the euphoria of this diplomacy, two major narratives are running in parallel: Israel’s deep disappointment and the economic pressures driving Washington to end its confrontation with Tehran.
For Israel, this agreement is not merely a diplomatic step but a strategic shift that could potentially reduce its manoeuvrability in facing Iran and its allied groups. It is unsurprising that media and political circles close to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have accused the Trump administration of making excessive concessions to Tehran. Some have even used harsh terms, claiming that Washington has “sold out Israel” to reach a deal with Iran.
Tel Aviv’s disappointment is understandable when looking at the substance of the circulating memorandum. The agreement reopens shipping lanes in the Strait of Hormuz, reduces the blockade on Iran, extends a 60-day ceasefire, and paves the way for the easing of economic sanctions if negotiations proceed as planned. At the same time, the most sensitive issue for Israel—namely Iran’s ballistic missile programme and Tehran’s regional influence through Hezbollah and its allied groups—is not a primary condition in the initial stage of the agreement.
Furthermore, Israeli sources reveal that Washington is pushing for the withdrawal of Israeli forces from several points in Southern Lebanon and the Mount Hermon region in Syria to maintain diplomatic momentum with Iran. For Netanyahu, these demands mean sacrificing what is considered Israel’s security achievements on the northern front.
However, reading this agreement solely from Israel’s security perspective would cause us to lose the bigger picture. The more important question is why Trump chose to seek peace now? The answer lies in economics.
Behind the language of diplomacy and regional stability, there are global economic interests too large for Washington to ignore. During the conflict, the Strait of Hormuz—a route through which approximately 20 per cent of the world’s oil trade and most energy exports from Gulf nations pass—experienced serious disruptions. The closure and restrictions on shipping in the region not only disrupted global energy supply chains but also triggered surges in logistics costs and international market uncertainty.
The agreement signed by Washington and Tehran specifically mandates the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz within 30 days, the lifting of the American naval blockade on Iranian ports, and the provision of relief for some of Iran’s oil sanctions. Additionally, the United States has reportedly agreed to the release of approximately US$25 billion in frozen Iranian assets and has committed to not imposing new sanctions during the negotiation process.
Market reactions demonstrate the immense economic dimension of the deal. Immediately after the memorandum of understanding was announced, global oil prices fell sharply. Brent crude dropped to the US$7lag 78 per barrel range, while West Texas Intermediate (WTI) fell to around US$75 per barrel, the lowest level since the outbreak of the conflict. Investors anticipate that reopening the Strait of Hormuz will return tens of millions of barrels of oil, which were held in the Gulf region during the conflict, to the global market. Reuters even reported that approximately 54 supertankers, carrying nearly 87 million barrels of oil, are awaiting the normalisation of these shipping lanes.
For Donald Trump, these figures are far more important than a mere symbolic victory in the geopolitical arena. Energy price stability means reduced inflationary pressure, lower transport costs, and improved American consumer sentiment. Conversely, a prolonged war with Iran risks driving oil prices back to levels that could disrupt US economic growth. Therefore, the agreement with Tehran is essentially a pragmatic step to secure domestic economic interests while calming global energy markets.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/behind-the-us-iran-peace-israels-disappointment-and-washingtons-economic-calculus-1781995826)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tgyaof451/di-balik-damai-amerikairan), translated from Indonesian