Hamzah will likely be first victims of the bill
Kornelius Purba
Staff Writer
The Jakarta Post
Jakarta
korpur@yahoo.com
Hamzah will likely be first victims of the bill
There was a strong sense of resentment among the participants
of the panel discussion on the bill of national education system,
organized by St. Anna Catholic Church in East Jakarta on Sunday,
when a participant mentioned the name of Vice President Hamzah
Haz as a strong supporter of the much-criticized bill.
They were clearly angry when reminded over Hamzah's criticism
over those who opposed the bill. Their anger reflected the
general grudge among Catholic and Protestant schools which will
be forced by the law --if passed-- to provide Muslim teachers to
teach Islamic religious instruction to Muslim students. In
addition, as their church was bombed by a group of Muslim
extremists in 2001, the participants are apparently more
sensitive against any hostile attitude to them.
They did not realize that Hamzah-- even the Vice President
himself may not realize too-- could be among first victims of the
bill itself, not just Catholic and Protestant-ran schools as they
feared.
Hamzah's often-doubted honorary doctorate, which he received
from distance-learning American World University in 1998, is
among the target to be punished by the bill drafters. Hamzah
reportedly paid less than US$ 2,000 for the degree.
The university name can not be found at the National Education
Ministry's list of accredited universities, and Hamzah often uses
the honorary degree in official documents. According to Article
60 of the bill, anyone who use a degree from unaccredited
university can be sentenced up to five years or fine up to Rp 500
million.
When the Vice President is aware of the legal threat he may
join the non Islamic schools to reject the bill for different
reasons. Hamzah's unawareness reflects general public's attention
only to the Article 13 of the bill and negligence against other
parts of the bill.
According to the article 13, "each student has the rights to
get religious education in line with his/her religion and will be
taught by en educator who has the same religion with the
student." The bill is still under deliberation by the House of
Representatives (DPR). Muslim-oriented parties like the United
Development Party (PPP) strongly endorse the bill, while major
factions like Golkar and the Indonesian Democratic Party of
Struggle (PDI Perjuangan) seem hesitant.
Nowadays, all students at Catholic schools are obliged to
attend Catholic religious learning, and the same practice
reportedly also happens with Islamic schools like the prestigious
Al-Azhar school. Until 1980s Catholic schools became favorite
destinations for middle and upper class families including
Muslims. However the influence then slowly declines following the
emergences of more other private schools and the betterment of
public schools. Currently, only few of the students at Catholic
and Protestant schools are Muslims.
There is long and strong suspicion from Muslim sides that
Catholic and Christian Protestant schools use their advantage for
their Christianization mission, although their argument is not
backed by data on how many Muslims have converted after attending
the Catholic or Protestant schools.
The essence of problems here actually is more substantial than
the pros and cons on the education bill. This article itself is
not intended to deeply discuss over the inter-religion problem in
Indonesia, but more as a reminder about the danger of the
education bill.
The Christians and Catholics oppose the bill because they feel
their advantage on education is their last sovereignty from the
Islam side. Learning from the past experience they have no
distrust toward any government's equality principle assurances.
There is growing feeling they are facing more discriminations
from the state, directly or indirectly, just because of their
religion.
It becomes much more difficult now to obtain permit to build
church, and even if there is a government permit, Muslim
neighbors often do not allow the construction. Attacks against
churches are increasing.
Christianization fear still haunts Muslim side although their
population is not less than 87 percent of national population.
Due to his own paranoid against the threat of Islam to his power,
Soeharto hired many non Muslims in key government and military
posts. Until after early 1990s he portrayed himself as a Muslim
leader. Many Muslims believe they are only majority in population
but a minority in terms of economy because non Muslims control
the economy.
Back to national education system bill, it is regretful that
President Megawati Soekarnoputri has not said anything to calm
down the supporters and opponents of the bill and to find a
compromise. The government apparently does not realize--
hopefully not because it does not care-- the danger of the bill
if it becomes law, at the grass-root level.
The government can easily argue that it can not do much to
stop the bill deliberation because the House has the final say on
a bill. It is true that the President can not veto the bill, but
the government must take all necessary measures to ensure the
aspirations of the two different camps can be accommodated in the
bill. It is not an easy task, especially when the government and
the House only thinks about next year's general elections and
presidential election.
Politically, it is safer and easier for President Megawati to
support the bill, because if she takes the opposite side, her
opponents will use it as an effective arms to block her in the
next year's election. However as a the head of the state and
statesman, the President is obliged by the Constitution to
protect all citizens regardless their background.
Regretfully the Article 13 of the bill has attracted most of
attention. Under current circumstances it is hard to expect that
the bill will enable the nation to achieve an ideal education
goal. The law--if the House eventually endorses it-- may deepen
the distrust, if not hatred, between the two different camps.
Is not it much wiser if the House and the government
reconsider the bill to enable them to find a much satisfactory
education bill for both sides? There is no easy answer for this
question. What is needed is statesmanship from those who are
responsible for protections of the whole citizens.
2. MONBIOT -- Poor, but pedicured
2 X 30
World Bank is not bothered to
produce measure of global poverty
Men who run the world do not care
about the impact on the poor
Poor, but pedicured
George Monbiot
Guardian News Service
London
The global economy is working. The rich may be acquiring an
ever greater share of the world's wealth, the ecosystem may be
collapsing, but -- or so we believe -- the poor are emerging from
poverty. This is portrayed as the ultimate test of the great neo-
liberal experiment: If, as the world's resources are privatized
and its corporations deregulated, the war against poverty is
being won, then the accompanying inequality and destruction can
be accounted as little more than collateral damage.
There is only one set of figures which provides a global view
of whether the incomes of the poor are rising or falling, and it
is cited everywhere. The trend, it suggests, is slow but
significant: Between 1990 and 1999, the percentage of the world's
people living in absolute poverty fell from 29 percent to 23
percent. Ugly as some of its characteristics may be, the existing
economic model is helping the poor.
The figures are compiled by the World Bank. It claims to know,
to within the nearest 10,000, how many of the world's people are
living below the international poverty line. The response of
those who criticize the way the global economy works is to accept
the bank's calculations, but to argue that there are more
equitable and less destructive means of achieving the same
results. But the figures are without foundation.
A new paper by the economist Sanjay Reddy and the philosopher
Thomas Pogge (How Not to Count the Poor,
www.columbia.edu/:sr793/) demonstrates that the World Bank's
methodology is so flawed that its calculations cannot possibly be
correct. Not only does it appear wildly to underestimate the
level of global poverty, but the downward trend it purports to
show appears to be an artefact of the way in which it has been
compiled. The World Bank's figures, against which the success or
failure of the entire global economy is measured, are useless.
Most of the world's people do not use U.S. dollars to purchase
what they need, and a dollar's worth of currency in one part of
the world can buy more than a dollar's worth in another. So to
try to discover how many people live on less than the equivalent
of US$1.08 per day (deemed to be the absolute poverty line), the
World Bank employs a method called "purchasing power parity".
This measures the amount of goods or services which the
equivalent of a dollar can buy in different countries.
The bank's calculations suffer, the paper suggests, from
several fatal deficiencies. The most obvious of these is that its
estimate of the purchasing power of the poor is based on the
measure of their ability to buy any of the goods and services an
economy has to offer: Not only food, water and shelter but also
airline tickets, pedicures and personal fitness training.
The problem is that while basic goods are often more expensive
in poor nations than they are in rich ones, services tend to be
much cheaper, as the wages of the people providing them are
lower.
If, for example, one dollar in the United States can purchase
either the same amount of staple foods that 30 rupees can buy in
India, or the equivalent of 3 rupees' worth of services (such as
cleaning, driving or hairdressing), then a purchasing power
parity calculation which averages out these figures will suggest
that someone in possession of 10 rupees in India has the same
purchasing power as someone in possession of one dollar in
America.
But the extremely poor, of course, do not purchase the
services of cleaners, drivers or hairdressers. A figure averaged
across all the goods and services an economy can provide, rather
than just those bought by the poor, makes the people at the
bottom of the heap in this example appear to be three times
richer than they are.
The bank would derive a far more accurate view of the
purchasing power of the poor if it measured only the cost of what
they buy, rather than what richer people in the same economies
buy. Complete figures do not yet exist, but Reddy's and Pogge's
initial calculations, based on the cost of bread and cereals,
suggest that the bank's analysis might have underestimated the
number of the world's people living in absolute poverty by some
30 percent to 40 percent.
As the service sector expands in poor nations, the bank's
figures will create the impression that the purchasing power of
the poor is increasing, whether or not their real economic
circumstances have changed.
The same false trend is established by a shift to the service
sector in rich nations, as $1 there will then buy a smaller
proportion of the total of available goods and services. The
relative purchasing power per dollar of the people of poor
nations is increased by this measure, even though their absolute
cost of living remains unchanged. When house prices boom in New
York, the shanty-dwellers of Lusaka appear to get richer.
These statistical artifacts create a downward trend in the
poverty figures where no real trend exists. The bank has
exacerbated it by recalibrating the international poverty line to
reflect the pattern of total global consumption.
As the world economy migrates towards the service sector, the
poorest people in the poorest nations appear to require less
money than they might otherwise have needed to maintain their
standard of living.
Perhaps more gravely still, the figures which appear to be so
precise that we can tell to within the nearest 10,000 how many of
the world's 6 billion people are suffering from extreme poverty
are, in reality, based on a mixture of guesswork and wild
extrapolation.
The first of the bank's two principal surveys measured price
levels in only 63 countries. Embarrassingly, China was not among
them, and neither that nation nor India figured in the second
survey (from which the trend has been established).
A set of global poverty figures, presented with six-digit
precision, which contains no useful comparative data from the two
largest nations on earth, could be described as imaginative.
The bank's statistics, moreover, do not account for changes in
inequality. If a nation's total consumption is rising only
because the rich have become richer, the figures will not show
this: They will suggest, instead, that everyone has prospered.
Yet we know that in many countries -- especially those in
which the privatization, deregulation and reduction in social
spending introduced by the neo-liberal model have been most
extensive -- the rich are becoming richer at the expense of the
poor.
That the key global economic statistic has for so long been
derived by means which are patently useless is a telling
indication of how little the men who run the world care about the
impact of their policies. If they cannot be bothered even to
produce a meaningful measure of global poverty, we have no reason
to believe their claim that they wish to address it. Development
on earth proceeds at present without any reliable means of
determining whether or not it is making the poorest people
poorer.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/b-1447899208-1357094)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post