Yusril Says Gibran’s Plan to Prove His Diploma’s Authenticity at the Administrative Court Is Pointless
Coordinating Minister for Law, Human Rights, Immigration and Corrections Yusril Ihza Mahendra said that Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s planned legal effort to prove the validity of his senior-secondary-equivalent diploma through the Administrative Court would serve no purpose.
He said the Constitutional Court’s ruling was final and binding, leaving no further legal avenues available. The Supreme Court’s ruling was also final, he added. As a result, no party could seek a judicial review of the decisions.
“There is no point, because the Supreme Court’s ruling is already final; the subject matter is the same,” Yusril said at the Presidential Palace in Jakarta on Tuesday (10 November).
Yusril said the two rulings concerning Gibran’s certificate, issued by the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court, also reinforced one another.
“And there is nothing more that can be done, because the Constitutional Court’s ruling is final and binding, with no further legal remedies available, and the Supreme Court’s ruling is also final. Therefore, no party can seek a judicial review of that ruling,” he said.
Yusril explained that in the Supreme Court case, the defendant was the Director General at the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education. Gibran did not join the case as an intervening defendant and therefore could not appeal.
He said the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education also appeared not to have sought a judicial review and would soon implement the ruling.
“Once it has been implemented by the Minister of Primary and Secondary Education, as the superior of the Director General, the Supreme Court’s ruling will also be final,” he said.
He said the matter was a legal issue for the courts to decide, and that both the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court had already issued final rulings.
“The Supreme Court’s ruling is final because Mr Vice-President cannot seek a judicial review, as he was not a party to the case. In the Subhan case, he was not a party,” he said.
Yusril also said the case currently under way at the Administrative Court could be discontinued because the object of the dispute—the certificate—no longer existed.
“In the case brought by Ms Mercy—sorry, Mr Denny Indrayana—he joined as an intervening defendant and can file an objection. But I think the Supreme Court’s final ruling, which was uploaded today, could lead the Administrative Court to halt the lawsuit brought by Ms Mercy and Denny Indrayana, because the object of the dispute no longer exists,” he said.
“I think the court will discontinue the case on its own, because there is no longer an object in dispute, and it may be removed from the Jakarta Administrative Court’s case register,” he added.
Gibran was reported by the Presidential Palace to be considering resigning from his position as Vice-President of the Republic of Indonesia.
Minister of State Secretary Prasetyo Hadi said the eldest son of former president Joko Widodo had conveyed this intention to President Prabowo during a meeting that day.
“Regarding whether there was a meeting between the President and Vice-President this morning, we can confirm to the public that the Vice-President did meet the President this morning,” Prasetyo said at a press conference at the Palace on Tuesday (10 November).
However, two hours after Prasetyo Hadi’s statement, Gibran did not explicitly say that he would resign as Vice-President.
Instead, he said he was determined to keep fighting to prove the validity of the educational documents he used when running for Vice-President in the 2024 presidential election, by seeking judicial review of the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings concerning his diploma.
“One of his suggestions was that I continue to fight at the Administrative Court by presenting all my documents, from primary school through to my bachelor’s degree. And also coordinate with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education to seek judicial review at the Constitutional Court,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/yusril-says-gibrans-plan-to-prove-his-diplomas-authenticity-at-the-administrative-court-is-pointless-1794311487)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261110173941-32-1425531/yusril-soal-gibran-mau-buktikan-asli-ijazah-ke-ptun-tak-ada-gunanya), translated from Indonesian