Your Letters
Your Letters
On street vendors
Chris Ashton's letter Street vendors and tourism (The Jakarta
Post, April 2, 1994) is shocking. His remarks are insulting and
remind us of "The ugly American."
The street vendors of Jakarta are what they are...but they are
at home here. The meager income they get for a long day of
hustling is well earned and Mr. Ashton -- with his prosperity
splashed all over his letter -- should be the one to keep
quiet...and, maybe, to be "put in a large cage and ferried..."
not to the outskirts of town, but out of Indonesia!
NANETTE NEWELL
CERISOLES
Jakarta
On author's
response
I am glad that our letters in The Jakarta Post caught the
attention of the author of the book Common Phrases for Teenagers.
I am also thankful for her realization of certain flaws in the
book. She admits that she would change some elements if she had
the chance. She also realizes that she should balance quality and
quantity. Her willingness to accept constructive criticism is
much appreciated.
Regarding her remark that I should have read the book before
sending any comments, I am obliged to clarify. Binny Buchori's
article was comprehensive enough with excerpts to give me a good
idea about the contents of the conversations, the inclusions of
four letter words and expressions like "I'm f...," "sucker for
big tits," etc...in the subject book, thereby prompting my
response to those specific portions.
More so because, the generalized title of the book suggests it
is meant for all teenagers and not just for those few who can
afford to study in an English speaking country or for those
affluent teenagers who watch foreign TV channels via parabola. (I
assume that the local TV channels do censor the obscene word as I
do not watch all the programs on all the channels. If they don't,
it is worthwhile to make them realize the importance of such
censorship). However the author is welcome to mail me a copy of
her book (addressed to Jl. Jemur Anda Yani XII/21, Surabaya) as I
can't locate it in leading book shops here in Surabaya.
A. KRISHNAN
Surabaya, East Java
Turn back
the clock?
This letter is a reaction to Mr. Ashton's letter of April 2,
1994 entitled Street vendors and tourism.
I could not agree more with Mr. Ashton's opinion, concerning
street vendors' making noise in the streets, thus disturbing
one's concentration while listening to the great Pavarotti.
As a matter of fact, in 1938, a law was passed, forbidding
"native" street vendors from entering the area around Oranje
Boulevard (Jl. Diponegoro), after 2 p.m., since these uncivilized
"natives" were disturbing the siestas of the Dutch community. A
similar law was passed in Hollandia, the then capital of former
Dutch West New Guinea, forbidding Papuans to enter the Dutch
residential areas in that city between 6 p.m. and 6 a.m. This was
before the Indonesian Republic took over the island and renamed
it Irian Jaya.
I fully support Mr. Ashton's proposal to revert to colonial
times, with colonial laws, when everything was so peaceful and
where one could comfortably listen to opera music, undisturbed by
cries from uncivilized vendors lining the streets. Where one
could sit in posh restaurants without having brown-skinned people
sitting at the next table, where you could swim in swimming pools
without the disturbing sight of brown-skinned children dipping in
the same waterpool and where you could enjoy a movie in first
class theaters with only white people around. The natives were
only allowed in front very close to the screen, provided that
they removed their shoes (their dirty shoes might tarnish the
floor).
I agree with Mr. Ashton of the need to take firm action
against these screaming wrongdoers in the streets, just like in
the good old colonial days.
I think Mr. Ashton makes a good point when he calls for
packing and moving all those screamers into an area far from the
civilized area, for the benefit of tourists.
Let us turn the clock back and again enjoy the privileges of
being born white.
I could not agree more with Mr. Ashton's ideas, yes I really
do.
SUMARSONO SASTROWARDOYO
Jakarta
Presidential
succession
From Kompas
Golkar chairman Harmoko said in Banjarbaru, South Kalimantan
recently that it was impolite to talk about succession now and
that the people should discuss it only after the general meeting
of the People's Consultative Assembly in 1998.
I think that rather than a matter of politeness or
impoliteness, it pertains to an organizational framework. In the
management system, drawing up a replacement table for vital posts
is a must. Such a table should be updated annually but drawn up
with a five-year forecast in mind.
Candidates should include between three to five persons who
demonstrate excellent leadership capabilities. They can be from
both inside or outside the organization.
This system is needed to usher in a smooth succession
mechanism without heated conflict.
Thus, listing candidates for vital postings is not an act
motivated by ill will. President Soeharto himself is wise enough
to say that he has no objection to discussing the topic as long
as it is done in line with the 1945 Constitution.
SOETJIPTO POERWOSOEDARNO
Jakarta
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/your-letters-1447899208-1021681)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post