Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Your Letters

Your Letters

Traffic problem

I would like to take this opportunity to address Jakarta's
most critical problem--its menacing traffic jams. Every day, the
citizens of Jakarta commute through aggravating circumstances to
reach their destinations. Excessive time is spent waiting for
adequate public transportation needs.

The time to reach work in the morning is at least tripled due
to the inadequate logistical transportation plans. Everyday, this
costs the economy billions of rupiah in efficiency and
productivity. Fuel consumption costs also escalate due to the
situations above. Psychologically, doctors have discovered that
employees tend to be more frustrated, less patient and suffer
other psychological and physiological disorders (such as
pollution related disorders) due to traffic jams in big cities.

To deal with the problems we have built new roads, enlarged
existing ones, developed three-in-one zones, provided more buses
and other public transportation facilities, charged high consumer
prices for oil and private cars (oil prices in Indonesia are the
highest among the oil exporting countries in the world), and
encouraged transmigration projects. But more needs to be done. It
should be recognized that many middle to upper class people still
prefer to use their own private cars to commute because they have
"no choice."

Inadequate security, comfort and cleanliness of the public
buses discourages private car owners from using alternative
transportation facilities. To help ease the traffic situation, we
should focus on a crash program to guarantee security on these
public transports. Air-conditioned buses and higher levels of
cleanliness and services should be encouraged so that any
businessman or executive would not hesitate to use these
transportation services. The goal is to fulfill all
transportation needs for all citizens of Jakarta and not just
those forced to accept lower standards of quality.

PREM M. MULANI

Jakarta

Zionist
propaganda

Mr. David Jardine made a number of rather naive remarks in his
letter Schindler's List not Zionist propaganda (The Jakarta Post,
April 11, 1994), which I feel call for a response. He said that
there are Jews who do not believe in the legitimacy of the state
of Israel and who find the perpetrator of the Hebron massacre
anathema. In fact, he shudders whenever he hears people
identifying all Jews with the action of one or a group of violent
Jews, or when people make the equation that Jew equals Zionist
equals Israeli.

Of course, no one in his right mind would believe that all
Jews are violent or murderous just because a few of them are,
anymore than all Englishmen are rapists just because a few of
them are. Further, David Jardine should not worry about people
mixing a Jew and a Zionist, because anybody with common sense
would surely make the simple and clear cut distinction between
the two. A Jew is a Jew, but a Zionist is someone who believes in
the ideology that strives to create a national homeland for the
Jews in Palestine, even at the expense of the Arabs who have been
living in the area continuously and almost exclusively far at
least 1300 years.

As for David Jardine's objection to the second part of the
equation (which equates Zionist with Israeli), I simply disagree
because all four million Israeli Jews, that is Jews who are
citizens and residents of Israel, are Zionists by definition
since the very foundation of Israel itself is based on Zionism.
And because the majority of the four-and-a-half million Jews in
the United States are most probably also Zionists (thanks to
their consistent and considerable financial and moral support for
Israel), one may conclude that the vast majority of Jews in the
world are Zionists, including a few extreme ones who would murder
praying Moslems in a mosque. The anti-Zionist Jews, whom I would
call the good Jews, or to use David Jardine's words, Jews who do
not believe in the legitimacy of the state of Israel, are sadly a
small minority indeed.

Referring now to the film Schindler's List, I think one does
not need to have actually seen it in order to say that it is part
of a Zionist propaganda. I have seen some of the films with
similar themes (i.e. Nazi persecution of Jews during World War
II) which have been made before by Hollywood. One common aim of
such films is obviously to elicit sympathy for the Jews from the
audience. Indeed, the Jewish film-makers hope the audience to be
sympathetic not only to the Jews in the film, but also to Jews in
general, including, in a subtle way the Zionist Jews in Israel.

I would urge the authorities to ban the film in Indonesia
completely, because a screening of the film could cause massive
protests and street demonstrations, especially with the tragedy
of the Hebron massacre still fresh in people's minds (even if the
carnage was probably the work of a demented Zionist).
Alternatively, the authorities could censor parts of the film and
pass the rest. In this case, the film's director Steven Spielberg
will undoubtedly withdraw the whole film (as he previously
threatened to do in the Philippines), to which of course I shall
have no objection.

MASLI ARMAN

Jakarta

Three swords
for Bapindo

From Tempo

Two magnificent "swords" are being used to resolve the Bapindo
credit scam.

The Attorney General's office is wielding one sword to prove
that collusion existed among the government, bank officials and
businessman Eddy Tansil. Perhaps it will also unravel a
conspiracy of internal and external powers which dip into
Bapindo's wealth.

The second sword is the Ministry of Finance which works to
salvage the bank from bankruptcy through a management contract
with a foreign bank.

This solution is being attacked by the public particularly
because Minister of Finance Mar'ie Muhammad seems to
underestimate the professionalism and patriotism of Indonesian
bankers. Who knows, maybe the younger generation has a stronger
sense of nationalism than their elders who displayed their
'nationalism' by stealing people's money.

Moreover, such a solution will not alleviate the problem
because it does not touch the core of it. In my opinion, the
scandal was not caused by the lack of professionalism of
Bapindo's executives, but by the lack of moral integrity and the
interference of external powers.

Hence, we need a third sword which is sharper and heavier.
That being the political will of the Indonesian government to
dismiss corrupt officials operating at all levels throughout the
country.

HERMAN W. SUTISNA

Bogor, West Java

Indorayon's
excesses

From Tempo

The poisonous gas explosion at the giant PT Inti Indorayon
Utama pulp and paper factory in North Sumatra in November 1991 is
still fresh in our minds. The accident caused great suffering to
the people living near the company's site.

And on March 3 a dam burst allowing poisonous liquid waste to
inundate the farms, houses and animals belonging to the people.
But again, PT Indorayon refused to accept responsibility. The
company argued that the problem was caused by the heavy rain and
that the dam wall was not strong enough to hold back the water.

A similar 'accident' occurred in 1988 when foul-smelling
blackish toxic waste ran from the dam down to the farms, houses
and livestock of Dolok Marpaung.

But even without these accidents, the Asahan river has been
heavily contaminated by waste from the PT Indorayon factory.

I don't think the accidents were caused by the sloppiness of
the workers or by nature (heavy rain), but happened because the
company displays tremendous disrespect toward the Indonesian
government and its people.

We saw on television recently that the State Minister of
Environment Sarwono Kusumaatmadja only ordered PT Inti Indorayon
to halve its production until the company fixed the waste dam. No
penalty nor sanctions have been given. It seems that the
government turns a blind eye in the face of such a giant company.

I don't know what kind of reference or 'powerful' letter the
company has to allow it to still grab as much profit as possible
at the expense of the people's suffering.

ELIAKIM SITORUS

Salatiga, Central Java

Land ownership

From Media Indonesia

With reference to Purwono Setiawan's article in this newspaper
on April 2, 1994, I am moved to write and express myself out of
concern over the fate of the future generation.

I share Mr. Purwono's concern about the idea to allow foreign
citizens to own land in Indonesia, which will only benefit the
real estate business. We must be aware of the suggestions that
sound good but will prove disadvantageous to the people. We have
the impression that there are efforts made to tap Indonesia's
richness. The Bapindo credit scam is an example. Eddy Tansil and
his collaborators shamelessly and irresponsibly drained the
people's money and invested it abroad--Hong Kong, Singapore and
his ancestors' country, leaving only worn-out articles worth
about 100 billion rupiah. In fact, Tansil is fully aware that the
Indonesian government tries hard to attract foreign loans to
support development.

Back to the problem of land ownership. The idea that foreign
people could own land and houses on Batam Island is very
dangerous and upsets the nation's political, economic and socio-
cultural systems. It is not unlikely that Batam could become
Singapore's second "province" because the foreigners generally
have a greater economic capacity than the Indonesian people. They
could have a strong economic influence on the country like the
Jews in the United States.

RIVAI RASYAD

Jakarta

Information
about AIDS

From Tempo

The ban preventing basketball star Earvin Magic Johnson from
entering Indonesia is a discriminatory expression of our
government's attitude towards AIDS sufferers.

Is this the attitude of people who 'think' that their
character is always based on Pancasila?

I think the incident means that the government and those
people, ironically, are against the national campaign of the
spread of AIDS. Discriminating against AIDS sufferers creates a
wrong opinion in the public about the spread of the disease.

How about tourists from foreign countries who have sex with
Indonesians? For instance, the tourists do not know that they are
infected by the disease or they do not confess that they are
suffering from AIDS, but they are allowed to come to this
country. It is ironic, isn't it?

To protect the people from the disease by giving the right
information is important, but to ban Magic Johnson from entering
this country is unfair.

SETIABUDI

Kediri, East Java

More from 14 April 1994 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/your-letters-1447899208-1021572)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print