Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Your Letter

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Your Letter

Male chauvinism?

With reference to the article Foreign authors want banning of
books stopped (The Jakarta Post, April 2, 1994), firstly, I would
like to congratulate The Jakarta Post for giving such an
excellent coverage of the visit of PEN American Center's
delegation throughout the week. How I wish that other Jakarta
papers might have shown the same interest.

Secondly, I would like to know why your article made no
mention of women writers? In the original press release, Ms.
Siobhan Dowd, Ms. Bharati Mukherjee, and Mr. Clark Blaise give
the names of seven persons, including three women, as those
"writers, journalists and publishers interviewed about their
work." Your article added the adjective "well-known", and then
omitted the names of the three women, these being Toeti Heraty,
Debra Yatim and myself. Whether one is famous or infamous is, of
course, a matter of interpretation, but I strongly object to the
fact that women (again!) are eclipsed. In this wonderful month of
April, when Kartini looms larger than life on the calendar, male
chauvinism is really not appreciated.

MARIANNE KATOPPO

Jakarta

Note: No offense was intended in the article, certainly not
against Indonesia's women writers. The four writers mentioned in
the article were selected at random. -- Editor

Linking aid to
human rights

In his article Linked aid not improving human rights (The
Jakarta Post, March 22, 1994) Mei Li Vos raised some interesting
points on the use of economic sanctions to influence human rights
policy in foreign countries. Except in an incongruous call for
Western governments to meddle more in the affairs of Yugoslavia,
the writer argues that denying a country economic privileges
should not be used as a means to improve that country's human
rights. He suggests that doing this is ineffective and unfair,
but I do not think his reasons are convincing.

The writer says sanctions do not work because they make
repressive leaders even more repressive. In some headline-making
cases, like Iraq and Yugoslavia, this may be true. It is clear
that a ruthless and entrenched government, which has already
staked its authority on a course requiring large-scale military
engagement, is unlikely to back down simply because of economic
retaliation. But in many less well-publicized cases sanctions do
achieve the desired result. In Guatemala, for instance, the
"autogolpe" or President Jorge Serrano was overturned when other
American countries threatened to stop investments and Serrano's
support among business and military sectors collapsed.

The writer also complains that the brunt of economic sanctions
is borne by the poor. While this might be true of a trade
blockade, it hardly applies to such things as development aid,
the Generalized System of Preferences or Most Favored Nation
status. These are, by their nature, privileges available in
limited quantities, so even if they are withdrawn from one
country, this means that extra resources become available to give
to others.

The country gaining aid will benefit from the aid, and the
country losing aid will benefit if the withdrawal achieves its
object of improving human rights. Curiously, the writer goes on
to say that the chief beneficiaries of aid are really big
businesses and public officials. If this is right, then it
obviously makes aid an ideal focus for economic pressure, since
its withdrawal, unlike a trade embargo, would affect principally
the wealthy and influential members of society rather than the
urban poor. Nor is it a relevant argument to say that U.S.
threats to eject Indonesia from the GSP are motivated by the wish
to protect American workers' jobs, as well as to improve
conditions for Indonesian workers. What this shows is that the
American government has more than one motive; it does not show
that such pressure does not, still less cannot, bring benefits
for the Indonesian workers.

Most alarming of the ideas in the article is that "a foreign
government has no right...to solve...the problems of another
country." The principle of national sovereignty implies that a
government has a right to do certain things in its own country
without needing the agreement of foreign countries; but it does
not mean that the government can do anything it likes, without
foreign governments saying or doing anything to discourage it.

To accept the latter would imply that foreign countries
should place the right of a government to torture its citizens
above the rights of the citizens not to be tortured. In other
words, nobody except the government would have any fundamental
rights at all. It is, therefore, necessary to be wary of the idea
that national commissions and definitions are sufficient to
guarantee the observance of people's basic rights.

Human rights abuses are almost inevitably committed by those
who are strong against those who are weak and have little hope of
defending themselves against a powerful and determined
government. Unless we believe that governments are always and
forever benevolent, then the best way to safeguard people from
abuses is through international standards and international
organizations.

JOHN HARGREAVES

Jakarta

Tolerance
needed

Referring to Chris Ashton's letter (The Jakarta Post, April 2,
1994) entitled Street vendors and tourism I have the following
comments:

Shame on you, Mr. Ashton! You sit there, enjoying so much
luxury, and all you can say about those poor people outside
seeking to scrape up a few crumbs dropping from your table is
that they make too much noise.

Now, if you were complaining about the cacophony made by so
many muezzins competing with each other to show off the loudest
and most selfishly intrusive public address system, then I would
have some sympathy with your plea.

Mr. Ashton, we guest workers and mercenaries should remember
our position here. We expect tolerance of our funny ways. We
should equally return such tolerance and be grateful for our
privileges. If all else fails, perhaps you could buy some hi-fi
headphones. That is my solution to enjoyment of Pavarotti.

ED SUTTON

Jayapura, Irian Jaya

Pleasure seeking

Chris Ashton strikes again (Street vendors and tourism, The
Jakarta Post, April 2, 1994) with his usual boring complaints,
know all and insensitive attitudes, plus God-given rights.

This person obviously gets a kick from having his letters
published in the newspaper and probably even more pleasure if his
letters draw responses from the public; the more irate the more
to his liking.

This type of person exists in every country, sending out
letters on any topic or subject, whether he has any knowledge or
not, to let everyone know how smart he is.

Most of his letters are nothing but garbage which are not
worth publishing.

I cannot be bothered giving Mr. Ashton any arguments on his
annoyance towards the street vendors as any reply to his
insensitive letter is exactly what he is waiting for to satisfy
his rather cheap and odd way of pleasure seeking.

HANNY LATIEF

Jakarta

Show must go on?

The Deputy of the Supreme Advisory Council, Suhardiman stated
that Sudomo, his superior, in light of his involvement in the
Bapindo credit fraud, should take unlimited leave until the case
has been resolved.

He does not agree if Sudomo resigns from his current position
because that will not solve the problem. Instead, he suggested
that Sudomo should fight to the last battle, just like a soldier.

I don't agree with such an assumption since the proverb is
only for positive matters and not for a situation such Sudomo's
case. Take example, when our nation had to dislodge the Dutch
colonial government from Indonesia. Whatever happened we had to
struggle to the last drop of blood.

Just look at the recent behavior in relation to responsibility
for mistakes -- refusing to resign from positions, showing
stubbornness and pretending to be a mute person.

PRIYO SANYOTO

Jakarta

Controversy over
`Supersemar'

From Editor

Mystery now surrounds the missing Supersemar historical
document of March 11, 1966. signed by the late President Sukarno.

The letter gave absolute power to then Lt. Gen. Soeharto.

Confusion surrounds the fact that it is understood that the
document was compiled at the Bogor Palace, while the existing
reproduction of the document states that it was made in Jakarta.

Also, the decree of the Provisional People's Consultative
Assembly (MPRS), TAP No. IX/MPRS/1966, which legalized
Supersemar, was dated and legalized on June 21, 1966, or just one
day before the installment of the chairman of the MPRS. Hence it
was not the result of deliberations of the highest legislative
body from June 20 up to July 5, 1966. And the decree is the only
one issued by that body without bearing the signature of its
chairman.

Unlike other MPRS decrees, the decree in question does not
begin with the usual opening phrase: "With the blessing of the
Almighty God ..."

We would like to have an explanation about the missing
document and clarification of the confusion surrounding it for
the sake of the New Order and the 1945 Constitution. A clear-cut
explanation will wipe away once and for all the existing
erroneous interpretation which casts a bad light on the New Order
as if it were the progenitor of political engineering.

ARTIE LOUIS JOHAN

Bogor, West Java

More from 5 April 1994 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/your-letter-1447899208-1022629)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print