Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

YLBHI Criticises Luhut’s Proposal to Change Indonesia’s Definition of Corruption

| | Source: aktual.com Translated from Indonesian | Legal
YLBHI Criticises Luhut’s Proposal to Change Indonesia’s Definition of Corruption
Image: aktual.com

Jakarta – M Isnur, chair of the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation (YLBHI), has criticised a proposal by National Economic Council (DEN) chair Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan to change the approach to defining corruption offences in Indonesia. Isnur said the element of state financial loss remained important in the fight against corruption, given the need to address the misuse of public funds and authority comprehensively.

The criticism followed Luhut’s statement that President Prabowo Subianto had approved a DEN study to bring the definition of corruption into line with international standards under the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC).

Luhut announced the approval after a limited meeting with Prabowo at Merdeka Palace in Jakarta on Tuesday (20 October 2026). According to Luhut, the DEN study advocates an approach focused on bribery rather than solely on losses to state finances.

“The President also agrees with the study produced by the National Economic Council team on the definition of corruption, because it is important for corruption handling in Indonesia to meet international standards,” Luhut said.

In response, Isnur said Indonesia still needed provisions on state financial losses as one instrument in combating corruption.

“Corruption is extraordinarily widespread in Indonesia and has become entrenched in every aspect of life, unlike in other countries, so the offence of causing state losses is still necessary,” Isnur told Aktual.com on Thursday (21 October 2026).

Isnur said the state financial-loss element in Articles 2 and 3 of the Corruption Eradication Law serves to protect public finances, punish abuse of authority and support the recovery of assets lost through criminal acts.

He said anti-corruption efforts should not focus solely on punishing offenders, but should also ensure that the state’s losses can be recovered in accordance with the law.

Nevertheless, the state-loss element must be applied carefully to distinguish losses arising from business risks or administrative errors from those caused by unlawful acts.

Luhut highlights risks for state-owned businesses

Luhut argued that the current approach, which links state financial losses to corruption cases, could make managers of state investments—including the Daya Anagata Nusantara Investment Management Agency (Danantara) and state-owned enterprises (SOEs)—fearful of making decisions.

He said every business decision carried risk, so commercial losses should not automatically be treated as corruption offences.

“Every business, whatever it is, inevitably carries risks. I think this is important,” Luhut said.

He said an adjustment was needed to provide managers of state investments with legal certainty when making business decisions. However, clear rules would still be required to distinguish reasonable commercial risks from conduct involving criminal elements.

UNCAC covers more than bribery

The DEN study refers to UNCAC, which Indonesia ratified through Law No. 7/2006 on 18 April 2006.

The convention covers various forms of corruption, including bribery of public officials, embezzlement of assets, abuse of functions or office, trading in influence, bribery in the private sector and laundering the proceeds of crime.

Any change to the approach to defining corruption should therefore take the full scope of UNCAC into account. Bribery is one of the offences covered by the convention, not the only form of corruption it addresses.

Meanwhile, Law No. 31/1999 on the Eradication of Corruption, as amended by Law No. 20/2001, still contains provisions concerning state financial losses, particularly in Articles 2 and 3.

The President’s approval of the DEN study does not, by itself, amend the legislation currently in force. Any change to the rules would still have to follow the applicable legal process.

YLBHI stresses asset recovery

Isnur also referred to law-enforcement practices in several member states of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). He said corruption cases could take account both of the harm caused and of the illegal gains obtained by offenders.

He cited cases involving international companies such as Volkswagen, Rolls-Royce, Tesco and Airbus. Isnur also pointed to deferred prosecution agreements (DPAs) used in some jurisdictions. These are agreements to defer prosecution subject to conditions, such as paying fines and improving corporate governance.

In his view, aligning with international standards should not undermine efforts to recover losses or take action against illicit gains.

The debate over the DEN proposal concerns how to balance legal certainty for state investment managers with effective anti-corruption enforcement.

On one hand, the government wants to ensure that reasonable business risks are not automatically treated as criminal offences. On the other, state financial-loss provisions remain an important part of Indonesia’s current legal framework.

Further discussion of the proposal should therefore clarify the boundaries between business risk, administrative error, abuse of authority and corruption, while ensuring that efforts to recover state assets continue.

More from 22 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ylbhi-criticises-luhuts-proposal-to-change-indonesias-definition-of-corruption-1792687828)
Originally published by aktual.com (https://aktual.com/ylbhi-kritik-usulan-luhut-ubah-definisi-korupsi-di-indonesia/), translated from Indonesian
Print