Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Yaqut's Legal Team: Criminal Liability in Hajj Quota Case Cannot Be Based Solely on Ministerial Position

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Yaqut's Legal Team: Criminal Liability in Hajj Quota Case Cannot Be Based Solely on Ministerial Position
Image: Media Indonesia

Former Minister of Religious Affairs Yaqund Cholil Qoumas, through his legal advisory team, has asserted that criminal liability in the alleged Hajj quota corruption case cannot be imposed simply because he previously served as the Minister of Religious Affairs.

This statement was delivered during the opening plea of the defendant, Yaqut Cholil Qoumas, in Corruption Case Number 42/Pid.Sus-TPK/2026/PN.Jkt.Pst. Yaqut’s legal team stated that the defence will focus on testing whether the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) prosecutors can truly prove concrete actions, intent, and conscious cooperation by Yaqut in the alleged criminal acts.

A primary point of contention is the allegation of receiving USD 271,500, the details of which are reportedly unclear. “Whether the Public Prosecutor can prove that the Defendant, Yaqut Cholil Qoumas, received funds amounting to USD 271,500,” was one of the questions posed by the defence team in court on Tuesday (1/9).

The legal team emphasised that criminal liability must be built upon the defendant’s own actions and faults, rather than solely on his position as Minister of Religious Affairs. “Criminal liability of the Minister of Religious Affairs cannot be constructed based on assumptions or the absolute application of ministerial responsibility for the actions of Ministry officials and staff,” the defence document stated.

They also highlighted the ‘complicity’ charge levelled against Yaqut. According to the defence, holding the position of Minister, having authority over Hajj administration, or possessing knowledge of the quota distribution process is insufficient to prove that an individual participated in a criminal act. “A structural relationship is not a relationship of criminal complicity,” the legal team asserted.

The defence stated that prosecutors must prove conscious cooperation between Yaqut and other parties. They identified at least five cumulative requirements that must be proven: that Yaqut knew of the criminal plan, knew of the concrete actions taken, approved or desired them, provided a contribution, and realised that such contribution was part of the execution of the crime. “If even one of these five cumulative requirements fails, the entire construction of ‘complicity’ collapses,” said the legal team.

Regarding the additional Hajj quota, Yaqut’s legal team will trace how the quota was obtained and who first proposed it. They will investigate whether the idea for additional quotas originated from Yaqut or another party, who conducted communications and diplomacy with the Saudi Arabian Government, how the additional quota was granted, and how the decision finally reached the Ministry of Religious Affairs.

According to the defence, this sequence is vital to determine whether Yaqut was an initiator of the additional quota or merely received a policy resulting from diplomacy to be implemented within his authority as Minister.

The legal team also intends to prove that Yaqut had no prior intention or plan to obtain additional quotas. They will examine previous Hajj operations to see if additional quotas actually led to issues regarding overcrowding, service quality, comfort, safety, and health risks for pilgrims.

Furthermore, the defence addressed allegations of fund collection by several Ministry of Religious Affairs employees. The legal team maintained that if employees received money without orders from Yaqult, the responsibility lies with the recipients. “There cannot be an automatic construction: if an employee receives money and works for the Ministry of Religious Affairs, the Minister is held criminally liable,” the team argued.

They argued that a chain of evidence must exist proving that the employees received money, Yaqut knew of it, desired it, cooperated, and that the receipt was part of a joint criminal act. Yaqut also explicitly denied receiving the funds as alleged in the indictment.

The legal team also questioned the alleged collection of additional funds from special Hajj pilgrims who received accelerated departures. They requested that quota policies, administrative implementation, fund collection by Special Hajj Organisers (PIHK), and fund reception by individuals not be conflated. “Fund collection by PIHK does not automatically constitute an act by the Minister of Religious Affairs,” the defence stated.

Regarding the alleged manipulation of pilgrim data through the Integrated Hajj Computerised System (SISKOHAT), Yaqut’s legal team requested that prosecutors prove technically who had access, who entered or altered data, who validated it, and who provided approval. If data changes occurred, the defence insists it must be established who initiated, ordered, executed, and profited from the act, and whether there is evidence such actions were done under Yaqut’s command or knowledge.

The legal team maintained that such technical actions cannot be directly attributed to Yaqut simply because he was the Minister. The legal counsel will also seek to prove the absence of any orders or interventions by Yaqut to receive money, collect additional funds from pilgrims, manipulate data, engineer departure lists, or alter pilgrim sequences for the benefit of certain parties.

Evidence will be presented through testimonies from Ministry officials and employees, PIHK parties, special Hajj organisers’ associations, witnesses related to quota distribution, documents, electronic communications, system data, fund flows, and expert witnesses where necessary. One critical part of the defence also targets the alleged state financial loss of approximately Rp622 billion.

More from 1 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/yaquts-legal-team-criminal-liability-in-hajj-quota-case-cannot-be-based-solely-on-ministerial-position-1788270876)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/928523/tim-hukum-yaqut-pertanggungjawaban-pidana-kasus-kuota-haji-tak-bisa-didasarkan-jabatan-menteri), translated from Indonesian
Print