Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

World Bank loans

| Source: The Jakarta Post

World Bank loans

The Washington-based World Bank has been accused of many
notorious acts, including raking big profits from its lendings to
poor nations. But none of the accusations went as far as the
criticism by American professor Jeffrey A. Winters of
Northwestern University, Illinois, that at least one third of
World Bank loans to Indonesia was wasted. The wide perception of
the high prevalence of malfeasance in Indonesia could provide
credence to Winters' allegations.

Winters told a news conference in Jakarta Monday that the
World Bank had for three decades allowed a large proportion of
its loan funds to Indonesia to leak into the government
bureaucracy and disappear through collusion and corruption. His
statement amplified an article on the same issue he wrote for the
Feb. 13 issue of the Hong Kong-based Far Eastern Economic Review.

Winters said he obtained the "one third" figure from
interviews with the bank's director in Jakarta, Atilla Sonmez, in
January 1993 and subsequent conversations with other officials of
the multilateral development bank in Indonesia and Washington.
That means, notwithstanding the essence of Winters' criticism,
the conclusions were not based on his own empirical studies.

We don't mean to assert that the implementation of World Bank
projects in Indonesia and other developing countries has always
been as efficient and effective as the bank has expected. But to
outrightly allege that at least one third of its loan funds has
been wasted through corruption and collusion seems way out of
line. This is because efficiency, accountability and transparency
have always been the hallmarks of the operational methods
promoted by the World Bank in its policy dialogs (loan
negotiations) with its borrowers.

The World Bank flatly denied the allegations. Its Vice
President for Asia and the Pacific Jean-Michel Severino said in a
statement in Washington that Winters' allegations were untrue and
that the World Bank knew exactly where its money went. Severino
acknowledged nevertheless that some of its projects in Indonesia
had been given unsatisfactory ratings.

Indonesian officials have often acknowledged that corruption
in the country is quite extensive. Indonesian contractors have
often complained that at least 30 percent of the value of
government projects they won should be spent for invisible costs,
including illegal payments to government officials.

But even though World Bank-funded projects are not entirely
sterilized from the bureaucratic environment of malfeasance, the
bank's funds have not been as vulnerable to embezzlements as the
government's own funds. The evaluation of World Bank projects
during their planning, preparations, implementation and post-
implementation audits have been so elaborate -- and the
evaluation mechanism has steadily been improved on the basis of
its own experiences, including mistakes -- that the opportunity
for collusion and corruption has been minimized. The bank's
procurement procedures, including the compulsory open competitive
bidding process, also make it extremely difficult for corrupt
practices.

Obviously, given its role as a development bank which
specializes in serving the least developed nations, World Bank
projects cannot always be assessed fully in terms of economic
returns. Moreover, most of the projects it finances are not
viable for commercial banking credits.

The World Bank cannot be accused of condoning corruption
practices in the developing countries even though it has never
blown the whistle on the issue which would be counterproductive
anyway. Because it deals with sovereign clients, the bank should
fight for improvement in a tactful and diplomatic manner so as
not to be accused of intervening into the internal affairs of
sovereign states. The bank has been fighting corruption in the
developing nations by helping to improve the system, encouraging
governments to ensure the rules of law and provide accountability
and transparency. Put another way, the World Bank has been
campaigning for good governance, which is reaffirmed through the
central theme of its 1997 World Development Report.

Winters nevertheless has a legitimate argument in saying that
the World Bank, the largest single creditor to the Indonesian
government, use its leverage to convince the country of the great
benefits of good governance.

More from 30 July 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/world-bank-loans-1447893297-1551628)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print