Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

World Bank clarifies

| Source: The Jakarta Post

World Bank clarifies

I read with interest the article entitled WB finds N. Sumatra
administration guilty of graft in your April 6 edition. This
article on the World Bank and corruption in a project that we
financed, the Kecamatan (district) Development Project (KDP),
made several important and correct points, but it also made
several factual errors.

Unlike what was stated in the article, the KDP is not meant
"to kick start businesses or regional investments". KDP is a
poverty program that gives money to poor people so that they can
build basic infrastructure and make economic investments. The
fact that KDP is to help Indonesia's poor makes the corruption
even more disturbing.

KDP goes as grants to the kecamatan, not as loans. Therefore
the statement that only about 10 percent has been returned is not
correct, because it implies that money should have been repaid.
However, within villages, KDP funds can be used for economic
activities, such as micro-finance. That micro-finance does have
to be repaid -- but to the kecamatan account, not the World Bank
or the province, so that it can move on to other poor families.

Only the economic portion of the grant revolves to other
villages. When villages use the grant to build a road or other
such public good, it remains as a grant. In the second year of
project implementation, for example, 88 percent of the money went
for infrastructure, which does not revolve, and only 12 percent
went for economic activities. So while it is true that only 10
percent of the money revolved, only 12 percent was supposed to.

The money hasn't been stolen since November 2001, as the
article states. November is when a World Bank supervision mission
went to North Sumatra and saw the problems there. At that point
all further disbursements in North Sumatra were stopped. There
have been no disbursements since then.

Despite these minor mistakes, the main point of the article is
correct. I applaud your journalist for making the story public.

The World Bank has said that it will resume disbursements only
when the missing money has been returned to the people of North
Sumatra (not to the World Bank). The Governor has also gone on
record saying that the people responsible will be prosecuted
through the legal system. We support this statement.

SCOTT GUGGENHEIM

Project Coordinator

Kecamatan Development Project (KDP)

World Bank

Jakarta

Note: We apologize for the statement that the KDP "is meant to
kick start businesses or regional investments". However the
article did not use the term "loans". The statement on the misuse
of the funds since November 2001 quoted the World Bank's
management consultant in the province. Thank you for the
clarification.

--Editor

More from 11 April 2002 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/world-bank-clarifies-1447893297-1264146)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print