Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Women's Representation and the Party Cadre Crisis

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Women's Representation and the Party Cadre Crisis
Image: Republika

Every time the registration period for legislative candidates opens, political parties become busy searching for people willing to be listed. Not just any figures, they need women. The wives of prominent figures, children of officials, or nieces of council chairs. As long as the numbers are even, the 30 percent quota is met, and the administrative requirements are passed. Once registration closes, they return to old habits.

Through Constitutional Court Decision Number 128/PUU-XXIV/2026, the Court affirmed that political parties failing to meet the minimum 30 percent quota of female legislative candidates in an electoral district will be disqualified from participating in the election in that district. This strengthens the position of the women’s quota, which previously relied solely on technical regulations from election organisers. However, this ruling does not automatically guarantee the achievement of its primary goal: women’s representation in parliament.

Women’s representation in parliament has indeed increased from election to election. In the 2004 election, elected female representation was 11.5 percent, rising to 18.0 percent in 2009, 17.7 percent in 2014, 20.5 percent in 2019, and 21.9 percent in 2024. The data shows an upward trend, but the increase is slow and still far from the 30 percent target. In other words, fulfilling the candidacy quota has not been directly proportional to the election of women.

Quota fulfilment is often perceived as a success of affirmative politics. In reality, in many regions, this quota is nothing more than an administrative requirement rather than the result of sustainable political cadre development. This phenomenon is evident in the recurring patterns across election cycles: parties frequently register legislative candidates at the very end of the registration period, candidates move between political parties, and parties often make sudden candidate substitutions during the revision phase. This pattern indicates a recruitment process that is not fully based on long-term cadre development.

Research by Perludem during the 2014 election showed that at the district/city level, political parties struggled to meet the 30 percent quota for women’s representation because they lacked sufficient female cadres. To fulfil the requirement, parties arbitrarily recruited women from anywhere just to meet the 30 percent threshold. The author’s empirical experience indicates this pattern continues today. This means the nomination of women in elections is often merely a result of political parties’ compulsion. Many of these female candidates are directly affiliated with male political figures, such as wives, children, and other family members. This phenomenon is known as political kinship.

According to a report by the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), there are strong indications of political dynasty involvement in the 2024 election results. Of the 127 female candidates elected in 2024, 58 individuals (45.67 percent) were indicated to be linked to political dynasties. In the previous 2019 election, 40 percent of the 118 elected female parliament members had kinship ties with other political actors.

The issue is actually much deeper than just a matter of candidacy administration. Many parties still lack an ecosystem that allows women to develop as leaders naturally. In several electoral districts, the recruitment of women is often rushed just before the registration deadline. This happens not because there are no competent women, but because the parties have never prepared them from the outset.

A strong patriarchal culture further exacerbates the situation. In many party structures, women are present but not genuinely involved. They are more often meeting accessories rather than voices that are heard. Learning spaces for women in politics are almost non-existent, while development pathways for male cadres have been established long before election season arrives. This inequality makes it difficult for women to grow as independent political actors.

The good news is that a number of parties are beginning to realise that cadre development cannot forever proceed from meeting to meeting without leaving a trace. Some parties are now starting to develop internal curricula and implement competency tests for regional chair candidates. This step is noteworthy, though not yet sufficient to be called a breakthrough. Because what is being fixed is merely the surface—the selection mechanism is made tidier—but the question of who is genuinely being pushed forward and why has still not been answered honestly by any party.

On the ground, however, the story is different. Research by the National Research and Innovation Agency (BRIN) found that at the regional level, who gets promoted within the party is still more determined by proximity to elites than by track record. A cadre who has diligently engaged with constituents for years can be sidelined just before the election simply because they lack the right connections. Meanwhile, a new name arriving with the blessing of a prominent figure immediately gets a top list number. In such conditions, women are the most disadvantaged party. Those without kinship ties to elites and without money to buy strategic positions have almost no entry point except to become mere list fillers.

These findings show that the problem of women’s representation cannot be sufficiently resolved solely through candidacy quota regulations. A more fundamental change in the governance of political parties is needed so that the recruitment and cadre development process takes place systematically, openly, and sustainably.

More from 18 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/womens-representation-and-the-party-cadre-crisis-1781780028)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/764362/keterwakilan-perempuan-dan-krisis-kaderisasi-partai), translated from Indonesian
Print