With ETLE in Place, Are Manual Traffic Tickets Still Needed?
Jakarta (VIVA) – Traffic law enforcement needs to be strengthened as electronic traffic law enforcement (ETLE) is rolled out. Manual ticketing is still considered necessary on a selective basis to address serious violations that cameras cannot fully monitor.
Soeharno Panca Atmaja, a member of the Indonesian House of Representatives from 2004 to 2009, said the limited reach of ETLE cameras was an important reason to assess the effectiveness of enforcement on the ground.
He said offences such as driving against the flow of traffic, dangerous driving and tampering with vehicle registration plates require firm monitoring and enforcement.
“We have to be honest: doing away with manual ticketing could weaken oversight of visible offences that electronic cameras cannot fully cover,” Soeharno said.
Soeharno said combining manual ticketing with ETLE could extend enforcement coverage, while maintaining transparency, professionalism and compliance with the law.
Firm action against violations cannot be delayed
Driving against the flow of traffic is not simply a matter of disregarding road signs. It can cause collisions, disrupt traffic and threaten the safety of other road users.
Education and warnings therefore need to be backed by consistent law enforcement, particularly in cases involving a high risk to safety.
Soeharno said direct action by officers was still needed, especially in locations where ETLE cameras do not provide adequate coverage.
He said a trial of manual enforcement prioritising wrong-way driving could be considered. Enforcement should also target other serious offences in accordance with applicable regulations.
ETLE is important, but manual ticketing is still needed
The introduction of ETLE is part of the modernisation of traffic law enforcement. The system helps record violations, supports consistent enforcement and reduces direct interaction between officers and motorists.
Nevertheless, ETLE’s effectiveness depends on camera availability, the extent of surveillance coverage and the system’s ability to identify vehicles and violations.
In some locations without adequate infrastructure, offences may go undetected. Some situations also require officers to be present to conduct direct inspections.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/with-etle-in-place-are-manual-traffic-tickets-still-needed-1792932672)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1938498-sudah-ada-etle-apakah-tilang-manual-masih-dibutuhkan), translated from Indonesian