Why the Judge Exempted 11 Little Aresha Daycare Carers from Paying Restitution
The panel of judges sentenced 11 carers at Little Aresha Daycare in Jogja to between two and three years in prison and fined each Rp60 million. However, the judges did not order them to pay restitution to the child victims, as prosecutors had demanded.
In its ruling, the panel said the 11 carers were employees who received a monthly salary. The foundation’s chair, Diyah Kusumastuti, had also required them to follow her instructions to restrain and swaddle the children.
The carers were forbidden from telling outsiders about these actions, which were considered company secrets. If they failed to comply with either rule, their wages would be cut.
“The defendants’ actions followed unwritten, binding standard operating procedures to restrain and swaddle the children, or were carried out on the orders of defendant Diyah Kusumastuti,” the panel said in its verdict, read at a hearing in the Nusantara courtroom of Jogja District Court on Wednesday (28 October 2026).
“If the defendants did not follow defendant Diyah Kusumastuti’s orders, their wages would be cut,” the panel added.
The carers also felt compelled to obey Diyah’s rules because they did not want to lose their jobs. Their diplomas were withheld, and those seeking to retrieve them before their contracts ended faced a penalty of up to Rp3 million.
“The defendants continued working to support themselves financially, so their fundamental motive for staying at Little Aresha Daycare was economic,” the judges said.
The 11 carers were also said to have had no direct control over the monthly fees paid by parents. On these grounds, the panel concluded that they should not be ordered to pay restitution.
“The management of tuition fees and other payments was handled entirely by defendant Diyah Kusumastuti through her personal bank account,” the panel said.
“It therefore exempts the defendants from paying restitution, as sought by the public prosecutors,” it added.
Prosecutors had previously sought restitution from the 11 carers for 83 child victims, with the amount to be paid under the same terms as a fine.
“The defendants should be ordered to pay restitution to each of the 83 child victims in the amount of Rp14,168,914, as set out in the LPSK decision dated 9 September 2026,” the public prosecutor said during the hearing on the charges on Monday (12 October).
“If seizure and auction of assets are insufficient to cover the amount, the restitution payment should be replaced by a 14-day prison sentence,” the prosecutor added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-the-judge-exempted-11-little-aresha-daycare-carers-from-paying-restitution-1793202646)
Originally published by detikJogja (https://www.detik.com/jogja/berita/d-8728618/alasan-hakim-bebaskan-11-pengasuh-daycare-little-aresha-dari-restitusi), translated from Indonesian