Why the Copyright Law Revision Is Urged to Go Beyond Royalty Arrangements
Press figures have welcomed the government’s plan to revise Law No. 28 of 2014 on Copyright, known as the Copyright Law. The regulatory change is expected not only to address royalties, but to become an effort to build a sustainable and independent media ecosystem.
According to the Chair of the Alliance of Independent Journalists (AJI), Nany Afrida, the revision of the Copyright Law is a step forward for the press ecosystem. This is because the change recognises journalistic works as copyright objects owned by journalists and press companies. In the revision draft, this provision is set out in Article 29 and Article 43 letter f.
However, Nany stressed that copyright protection alone is not enough to resolve the crisis facing the media industry. “Indonesia needs a comprehensive regulatory framework for media sustainability, not limited to the revision of the Copyright Law,” said Nany, quoted from a written statement on Friday, 10 July 2026.
According to Nany, the media industry has faced pressure over the past decade due to digital disruption and the dominance of global platforms in the distribution of information. This situation has meant journalistic works are frequently reused without fair economic compensation for press companies or journalists.
Therefore, AJI proposes that the revision of the Copyright Law be accompanied by other policies, such as the establishment of a journalism trust fund, tax incentives for the knowledge sector, stronger implementation of publisher rights rules, and a fair royalty distribution mechanism for both large and small media outlets.
On the other hand, Nany cautioned that copyright regulation should not become a gateway to restricting press freedom. The government must ensure that copyright protection does not reduce journalists’ room to use public officials’ data in their reporting.
The General Chair of the Indonesian Cyber Media Association (AMSI), Wahyu Dhyatmika, considers the revision of the Copyright Law important to guarantee fair compensation when journalistic works are used by digital platforms and developers of artificial intelligence (AI).
“There must be new governance that ensures the economic value of journalistic works is not continuously extracted without consent, without transparency, and without fair compensation,” said Wahyu in a press release on Thursday, 9 July 2026.
In his view, Indonesia needs a combination of policies covering copyright protection for journalistic works, transparent licensing mechanisms, accountable royalty management, robust metadata standards, and equal negotiating space between media companies and digital platforms.
He added that the issue concerns not only the survival of the media business, but also the future of quality journalism. “If journalistic works continue to be used to build digital and AI products without economic value returning to the newsroom, then the public will ultimately lose a credible and trustworthy source of information.”
Beyond domestic regulatory improvements, Wahyu said support for a sustainable media ecosystem in the AI era is also coming from UNESCO. The UN body is currently holding consultations on the Draft Guidance for Fair Compensation for News under its Internet for Trust initiative. The guidance will serve as a global reference for states, digital platforms, AI companies, and the media industry in building fair compensation mechanisms.
Wahyu hopes the deliberation of the Copyright Law revision in Indonesia can align with the UNESCO guidance so that it provides firmer recognition of journalistic works as objects of legal protection with economic value. To that end, he urged that compensation mechanisms be run transparently and accountably, whether through direct negotiations between media companies and platforms or through Collective Management Institutions managed by the press ecosystem.
Meanwhile, the government has stated it will push for a fair compensation scheme for journalistic works used by digital platforms and artificial intelligence developers. This position was conveyed during UNESCO consultations on the draft Guidance on Fair Compensation for News in Geneva, Switzerland, running until 30 July 2026.
“The recognition of journalistic works in the Copyright Bill is a statement of position that journalistic works have economic value that must be respected by anyone who uses them, including digital platforms and AI developers,” said Andry Indrady, Head of the Legal Policy Strategy Agency at the Ministry of Law.
Andry added that during the consultation, Indonesia put forward four proposals. First, providing firm copyright protection for journalistic works as the foundation for granting compensation.
Second, building a verification mechanism so that compensation is only given to journalists and journalistic products that meet professional standards. According to him, this mechanism is needed so that economic benefits do not flow to content producers who do not practise journalism.
Third, the government proposed that Collective Management Institutions (LMK) become bodies that collect and distribute royalties for the use of journalistic works. Their governance, Andry said, must be transparent and accountable.
Fourth, a reliable metadata system is needed to track the use of journalistic works by digital platforms and AI providers. “Without reliable metadata, we cannot know whose work is being used, where, and how much it is worth. Data transparency is the foundation of the entire fair compensation mechanism,” said Andry.
The UNESCO draft guidance was drawn up in response to the weakening of media business models in many countries. The shift of advertising revenue to digital platforms, the closure of local media, and the massive use of news content by AI systems without attribution or compensation have all threatened the sustainability of journalism.
Through the guidance, UNESCO is offering a number of compensation mechanism options that each country can adopt, ranging from mandatory negotiations between platforms and media, copyright-based licensing, competition law instruments, to the establishment of funds to support public interest journalism.
Andry said the approach being discussed at UNESCO aligns with Indonesia’s proposals at the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) on royalty governance in the digital environment. According to him, the two forums can reinforce efforts to build a more transparent and accountable compensation system for the press industry.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-the-copyright-law-revision-is-urged-to-go-beyond-royalty-arrangements-1783666513)
Originally published by Tempo Bisnis (https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/2112928/mengapa-revisi-uu-hak-cipta-diminta-tak-hanya-atur-royalti), translated from Indonesian