Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Why Should the State Provide an Allowance for Assignments Away from an Employee’s Home Base?

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Why Should the State Provide an Allowance for Assignments Away from an Employee’s Home Base?
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Staff transfers have always been a sensitive issue in human resource management, particularly in government. Every transfer decision has consequences for the employee concerned, from adjusting to a new working environment to changes in family life.

The issue becomes more complex when an assignment requires someone to work far from their home or home base. On the one hand, the government needs the flexibility to distribute staff according to organisational needs. On the other, employees must bear the economic and social consequences of such decisions.

This tension between organisational and employee interests should be a concern in reforms to the management of the state apparatus. The question is not whether the government has the right to post employees throughout Indonesia. That right is part of the needs of government organisations. The more fundamental question is whether employees should have to bear the financial consequences of those postings entirely on their own.

Staff distribution and the consequences of postings

Calls for employees to be posted closer to their home regions have recently become more prominent. Policies accommodating this preference may gain support in the short term. However, if applied widely without regard to organisational needs, they could create long-term problems with staff distribution.

The distribution of the population and employees’ location preferences do not always align with the distribution of government units. For example, more than half of Indonesia’s population is concentrated on Java, while government units needing staff are spread across the country.

If proximity to employees’ home regions becomes the dominant consideration, staff could become increasingly concentrated in certain areas while vacancies elsewhere become harder to fill. Establishing new government units simply to accommodate employees’ location preferences would not be a rational solution.

The issue was apparent in the resignations of prospective civil servants recruited through the optimisation route. A total of 1,967 candidates reportedly resigned after learning that their work locations were far from their home regions.

The optimisation route is one way of filling vacancies that remain unoccupied. It includes cases in which applicants meet the minimum score but do not obtain a position in their initial choice. The resignations show that willingness to serve as a state employee does not necessarily mean readiness to bear all the consequences of a posting.

The government cannot guarantee every employee a workplace of their choosing. It can, however, assess whether the existing compensation system adequately accounts for the consequences of distributing staff in this way.

Willingness to accept a posting is not consent to bear every cost

During recruitment, willingness to be posted anywhere in Indonesia is one of the conditions attached to certain types of work. This is particularly relevant to civil servants, the Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI) and the National Police (Polri), who may be assigned or transferred across regional boundaries in line with organisational needs and applicable regulations.

This differs from government employees working under employment agreements (PPPK), whose employment relationships are governed by contract terms and a specified posting. The distinction affects both posting flexibility and certainty about the work location.

For civil servants, the TNI and Polri, willingness to serve anywhere in Indonesia gives the state flexibility to meet organisational needs. But that willingness should not be interpreted as consent to bear without limit all the additional costs arising from a posting decision.

Consider two employees with the same rank, length of service and income. The first works in their home region, lives with their family and can visit their parents without significant travel costs.

The second is posted to another province. To maintain family ties, they must set aside income for travel tickets, pay for their partner and children to visit, or meet the costs of maintaining a split household.

Administratively, both receive the same income. Yet their ability to save, build assets and prepare for retirement may differ significantly. An employee posted far from their family may have less disposable income because part of their earnings goes towards needs that do not arise for an employee living near their family.

These costs are not simply the result of personal consumption choices. In many cases, travel expenses arise from a posting decision made by the organisation. The cost of visiting family may recur for decades, from appointment until retirement. Without an adequate compensation mechanism, this continuing burden could erode savings and employees’ ability to build long-term financial security.

A distinction therefore needs to be made: the obligation to accept a posting and the obligation to bear the cost of that posting are separate matters. The state can require employees to be willing to serve anywhere in Indonesia without placing all the economic consequences on them.

A pay structure that is not yet fully adaptive

This issue points to the need to review the state apparatus’s pay structure. Current remuneration includes basic salaries, family allowances, position allowances, performance allowances and various special allowances related to the nature of the job or location. However, the purpose of each component is not always clearly reflected in the overall compensation design.

One concern is the tendency to provide similar compensation to employees facing different assignment conditions. Pay should take into account not only rank, length of service, position and performance, but also the specific burdens arising from an assignment.

Certain allowances are available to employees working in special regions or areas with particular characteristics, including allowances related to the cost of living, such as the Papua Allowance. But location-based compensation does not necessarily address the costs of being separated from one’s family by distance.

For example, an employee from Papua working in their home region may not face the same family-travel costs as an employee from Java posted to Papua. Conversely, an employee from outside Java assigned to Java may face a similar problem if their family remains in their home region.

The high cost of living in a particular area is distinct from the additional costs caused by geographical separation from one’s family. The two problems therefore require different policy responses.

An assignment allowance as an instrument of fairness

An allowance for assignments away from an employee’s home base could help address this gap. Its purpose would not be to give special privileges to employees posted far from home, but to reduce the financial inequality arising from posting policies.

The principle is straightforward: when the state posts an employee far from their family to meet organisational needs, it should consider compensating them for the additional costs they must bear.

Travel to visit family, for example, can reduce an employee’s ability to save and build long-term financial security. The government should therefore design a clear, measurable compensation mechanism to help cover these costs.

From a human resource management perspective, this kind of compensation could also improve incentives for accepting postings. Employees would continue to fulfil their obligations, while the government would have a means of reducing the financial barriers that make cross-regional assignments increasingly difficult. Compensation would not guarantee that everyone would be willing to serve anywhere, but it could reduce resistance to staff distribution.

In the long term, the proposal could form part of a more adaptive pay-system reform for the state apparatus. Comprehensive change would, however, require fiscal analysis, regulatory harmonisation and a review of the existing pay components.

While that reform is pending, the government could consider a short-term policy providing periodic travel support for employees who meet the criteria for assignments away from their home base.

Family travel support as a first step

To keep the policy measurable and avoid an excessive fiscal burden, compensation need not take the form of additional cash. One alternative is support for periodic travel home to visit family, perhaps once a year.

Such support could draw on practices at some international organisations, which provide return-travel benefits to personnel posted far from home. The arrangements for Indonesia’s state apparatus would nonetheless need to reflect the nature of the assignments, public finance rules and the government’s fiscal capacity.

Travel support could be provided to employees and, subject to certain conditions, members of their immediate family listed in the payroll records. The aim would be to enable visits to parents or parents-in-law living in the employee’s home region, or to bring together partners and children living separately because of a posting. These limits would prevent the benefit from becoming a travel allowance with no direct connection to its policy objective.

Funding should follow a measurable mechanism, such as reimbursement of actual travel costs (at cost), subject to applicable rules and reasonable limits. Providing travel support rather than cash could help ensure that public funds are used to compensate for the costs the policy is intended to address.

Eligibility criteria would also need to be clearly designed. As a first step, the government could consider employees whose posting is in a different province from the residence of their immediate family. A provincial boundary would offer a relatively simple administrative threshold, although it would not perfectly reflect travel distance or costs. The criteria should therefore be tested through simulations and an assessment of the fiscal impact.

The government would also need to estimate the number of potential beneficiaries, family composition, different modes of transport and an appropriate travel frequency. This would allow the policy to be introduced gradually and evaluated in terms of both its benefits and costs.

Restoring balance between obligations and compensation

As a unitary state, Indonesia needs public servants who can work in different regions. The distribution of civil servants, TNI personnel and Polri officers is an important tool for ensuring that government functions and public services are not concentrated in particular areas. But successful distribution depends on more than the authority to transfer employees. The design of compensation also affects whether posting policies can be sustained.

The state needs employees willing to work outside their home regions. That willingness should not, however, be a reason to disregard the financial consequences that arise during an assignment. The obligations set out during recruitment should be balanced by compensation policies that take into account the reasonable burdens employees face.

An allowance for assignments away from an employee’s home base does not mean that the state must reimburse every personal expense, nor does it guarantee that every posting will be easy. Its more fundamental aim is to ensure that employees do not bear alone the additional costs directly linked to organisational needs and the state’s posting decisions.

Good management of the state apparatus is not only about placing the right people where they are needed. It also requires the consequences of assignments to be shared fairly.

If the state expects the flexibility to distribute employees throughout Indonesia, it is reasonable for it to consider commensurate compensation. A willingness to serve the state should not come at the cost of employees having fewer opportunities to secure their families’ financial wellbeing.

More from 16 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-should-the-state-provide-an-allowance-for-assignments-away-from-an-employees-home-base-1792129853)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261016112715-14-776794/tunjangan-penugasan-di-luar-homebase-mengapa-perlu-diberikan-negara), translated from Indonesian
Print