Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Why Luhut Is Insisting on Changing the Definition of State Loss in Corruption Cases

| | Source: afu.id Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Why Luhut Is Insisting on Changing the Definition of State Loss in Corruption Cases
Image: afu.id

JAKARTA — National Economic Council (DEN) chair Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan says legal certainty is one of the most important factors in developing Indonesia’s economy. Legal uncertainty, he said, can hold back investment, restrict businesses’ room to operate and make companies reluctant to take risks to grow. He made the remarks during a discussion on the Akbar Faizal Uncensored podcast, watched by Afu.id in Jakarta on Tuesday (3 November 2026).

During the discussion, he highlighted the use of the concept of state losses in law enforcement, particularly in cases involving business and investment decisions. Luhut said legal certainty was one of the main issues discussed at the DEN when it identified obstacles to economic growth. “At the DEN, we discussed what the most important issue in the economy was. The conclusion was that legal certainty has a major impact on the economy. If you have no legal certainty, things can be turned upside down,” he said.

Businesspeople, he said, need clarity about the line between a risky business decision and an act that can be classified as a criminal offence. Without clear boundaries, decisions made on commercial grounds may lead to legal problems when their results do not meet expectations.

Luhut said that 81 per cent of people imprisoned in the context under discussion were connected with state losses. He questioned the heavy reliance on state losses as a basis for corruption cases, saying the approach should be compared with international legal practices and standards. Under the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), corruption is not defined solely as conduct that causes financial losses to the state.

UNCAC identifies a range of conduct that may constitute corruption offences, including bribery of national and foreign public officials, embezzlement or misappropriation of assets by public officials, trading in influence, abuse of functions or office, and bribery and embezzlement in the private sector.

The convention also covers laundering the proceeds of crime, concealing the proceeds of crime and obstructing justice. Illicit enrichment is addressed in Article 20 as conduct that may be considered for criminalisation, subject to each country’s constitution and the fundamental principles of its legal system.

Accordingly, financial loss to the state is not the only element that determines whether conduct constitutes corruption under the UNCAC framework. Bribery, for example, may be a criminal offence even when no financial loss to the state has been proven. However, UNCAC does not prohibit countries from including state losses as an element in their domestic law. Luhut argued that using the concept too broadly could create legal uncertainty. “No other country uses state losses, except perhaps communist countries,” he said.

State losses must not become a catch-all provision

Luhut said he had discussed the issue with several legal figures, including Jimly Asshiddiqie and Yusril Ihza Mahendra. He said Yusril had proposed retaining the state-loss clause, but applying it within clear limits. “Yusril’s proposal was not to remove the state-loss clause, but to make sure it does not become a catch-all provision,” Luhut said.

Luhut also cited Yusril’s explanation that he had been involved in signing a United Nations document on the definition of corruption and had studied the issue. Indonesia, Luhut said, should review how the concept of state losses is applied to ensure it is not used excessively in law enforcement.

In Indonesian legal usage, a “rubber article” refers to a provision worded so broadly or ambiguously that it does not clearly define prohibited conduct. Such a provision can create uncertainty because its application depends heavily on the interpretation of law-enforcement officials. In corruption cases, the concern arises when losses arising from business decisions are immediately treated as evidence of a criminal offence, without distinguishing administrative errors and commercial risks from conduct meeting the elements of corruption.

The state-loss element in Indonesian law nevertheless has its own legal basis. The Law on the Eradication of Corruption Crimes provides that certain acts which harm state finances or the state economy constitute criminal offences. The issue Luhut raised, therefore, is not simply whether to abolish or retain the state-loss element, but how to define and apply it proportionately.

Luhut also questioned whether international best practice had genuinely been adopted in Indonesia’s legal system. Ideas originating abroad, he said, should not be adopted blindly. Each legal concept needs to be examined, including its compatibility with Indonesia’s economic characteristics, legal system and institutional conditions.

He referred to Indonesia’s takeover of Dutch assets as part of a discussion about the country’s legal history and practice. In Luhut’s view, Indonesia should be cautious when adopting international legal concepts. Practices considered successful elsewhere may not be transferable to Indonesia in the same way. It is therefore important, he said, to ensure that the application of the state-loss concept does not obstruct legitimate economic activity.

Oil exploration risks and Pertamina’s competitiveness

Luhut also linked the issue of state losses to oil and gas exploration. He said the national oil company faced challenges when making high-risk investment decisions. One example is drilling an oil well, which does not always yield commercially viable reserves.

In the oil and gas industry, failing to find reserves is an inherent risk of exploration. Drilling costs may still be borne by a company even when a well does not produce oil in commercially viable quantities.

Luhut said that if exploration failures were automatically viewed as state losses, national companies such as Pertamina could become more cautious about drilling decisions.

“Why is our company behind foreign firms in oil drilling? Because a dry well is considered a state loss, while the success rate of drilling an oil well is one in six. That is why Pertamina is losing out to foreign oil companies,” Luhut said.

He suggested that foreign oil companies had greater flexibility to explore because they did not face state-loss rules in the same way as state-owned companies. The difference, however, needs to be considered in the context of each company’s ownership structure, governance and applicable legal regime.

National oil companies must still account for the use of state capital, while private companies also have legal and governance obligations relating to their investments. Luhut’s concern is how to ensure that reasonable business risks are not automatically treated as criminal offences, without removing accountability where irregularities or corruption are found.

Those affected by the “state losses” provision

Luhut also cited several legal cases which, he said, demonstrated the importance of legal certainty in business decision-making. One was the case involving Karen Agustiawan, former president director of Pertamina, who faced a corruption case related to the company’s investment in the Basker Manta Gummy (BMG) block in Australia.

The case became one example in the debate over the boundary between risky business decisions and corruption. Investment issues and company losses formed part of the legal proceedings, in which the evidence and applicable elements of the offence had to be assessed.

Luhut also mentioned the case of Ibam, a consultant who, he said, had made a mistake in his work and gained nothing from the decision. He questioned whether it was fair for someone who had received no benefit from a business decision to subsequently face legal problems. “This is wrong; it violates human rights,” Luhut said.

His remarks reflected concern about what he considers disproportionate enforcement, particularly when someone faces criminal proceedings over decisions made in a professional capacity.

Luhut also referred to a case involving former Education, Culture, Research and Technology Minister Nadiem Makarim. The case concerning the procurement of educational technology devices formed part of the discussion about alleged state losses and accountability for decision-making.

Luhut said legal certainty was directly connected to companies’ willingness to invest and expand. Business decisions made in good faith and in accordance with procedures, he said, should receive legal protection, particularly when they involve reasonable risks.

At the same time, legal certainty must continue to ensure action against corruption, abuse of authority and conduct that causes actual losses to state finances. He therefore called for the state-loss concept to be applied in a more measured way, taking account of international practice as well as the needs and characteristics of Indonesia’s legal system.

More from 3 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-luhut-is-insisting-on-changing-the-definition-of-state-loss-in-corruption-cases-1793703061)
Originally published by afu.id (https://afu.id/nasional/alasan-luhut-terus-ngotot-agar-definisi-merugikan-negara-dalam-korupsi-diubah), translated from Indonesian
Print