Why Kim Jong Un Is So Often Reported Dead
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — North Korean leader Kim Jong Un recently appeared in the country’s state media looking in good health. His appearance seemed to dispel fresh rumours that he had died following a stroke and brain haemorrhage.
Recent photographs released by the government’s official newspaper, Rodong Sinmun, showed the 42-year-old dictator inspecting an exhibition of clothing and footwear. Kim was accompanied by his daughter, Kim Ju Ae, and senior officials from the Pyongyang regime.
The photographs went viral just hours after a China-born activist living in the United States made an unsupported claim that Kim had been taken to a Beijing hospital in a coma and later died.
For analysts and foreign intelligence agencies, such rumours are nothing new. North Korea, widely regarded as the world’s most closed-off country, is fertile ground for speculation and misinformation.
The latest claim that Kim had died was made by Wanjun Xie, who describes himself as chairman of the Chinese Democracy Party, an organisation banned by the Beijing regime. Xie has previously been known for spreading unverified claims, including a prediction that Chinese President Xi Jinping would die.
Xie alleged that Kim had suffered a severe brain haemorrhage and was evacuated to Beijing because Pyongyang lacked adequate medical facilities. He also claimed that Kim’s body had been secretly smuggled back to North Korea to conceal the death from the public.
Evidence on the ground undermines the rumour
The images released by Pyongyang, however, tell a different story. Kim appeared to be actively inspecting the exhibition items and speaking with the officials accompanying him.
Although there is no definitive information about when the photographs were taken, analysts say the claim is beset by inconsistencies.
If Kim’s health had suddenly collapsed, the North Korean border would be expected to become unsettled. China would normally increase its military presence along the border in anticipation of a potential refugee crisis. Diplomatic activity at North Korean embassies would also be expected to rise sharply, the BBC reported on Saturday (31 October 2026).
In reality, none of these emergency signals was detected. South Korea’s National Intelligence Service (NIS), speaking through the Yonhap news agency, said there had been no unusual movements or indications to support reports of Kim’s death.
The episode recalls a similar incident in 2020. At the time, a senior North Korean defector said he was “99 per cent certain” that Kim had died after heart surgery. Soon after the claim attracted widespread coverage, Kim appeared in public, dispelling the speculation.
Why rumours of Kim’s death keep spreading
The main reason reports about Kim’s health attract worldwide attention is the uncertainty surrounding the succession.
Although North Korea has been ruled by the Kim dynasty for three generations, the path of transition after Kim Jong Un is far less clear than it was under his predecessors.
The country’s founder, Kim Il Sung, spent decades preparing his son, Kim Jong Il, as his designated successor. As a result, the transfer of power in 1994 proceeded smoothly.
By contrast, Kim Jong Un’s rise to power was swift and precarious. After Kim Jong Il suffered a stroke in 2008, the young Kim was rapidly promoted through the military hierarchy before taking power in 2011. He then spent years carrying out political purges to secure his position.
South Korean intelligence now suspects that Kim is preparing his daughter, Kim Ju Ae, as a future leader, as she increasingly accompanies him at military and state events. But Ju Ae is thought to be only 13, and North Korea’s patriarchal culture has never seen a woman lead the country. These factors could fuel a power struggle if a crisis were to occur suddenly.
A second factor driving the rumours is Kim’s lifestyle.
Kim is known to be obese and a heavy smoker. The NIS has repeatedly warned that these habits put him at high risk of cardiovascular disease, which is also part of the Kim family’s medical history.
Any serious development affecting Kim would have major consequences for regional geopolitical stability. A leadership crisis in Pyongyang would immediately raise global concerns about control of its nuclear weapons, possible aggression by military hardliners and a large-scale refugee crisis on the Chinese border.
But North Korea remains an information “black hole” that is difficult even for foreign intelligence agencies to penetrate, meaning rumours about the dictator’s health are likely to keep recurring.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-kim-jong-un-is-so-often-reported-dead-1793411428)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261031002258-4-781103/ternyata-ini-alasan-kim-jong-un-sering-dikabarkan-meninggal-dunia), translated from Indonesian