Why Judges Now Imposed Rp 5 Billion in Restitution on Ibam in the Chromebook Case
The DKI Jakarta High Court has increased the sentence of Ibrahim Arief, also known as Ibam, in the corruption case involving the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM) to five years in prison, a fine of Rp 500 million, and restitution of Rp 5 billion. The appellate judges explained their reasons for now adding the restitution penalty to Ibam’s sentence.
“The Panel of Judges at the High Court is of the opinion that it must first be emphasised that the sentencing system under the Corruption Eradication Law is not only aimed at imposing corporal punishment on the perpetrator, but also at recovering state losses arising from the criminal act of corruption,” said Presiding Judge Catur Iriantoro during Ibam’s appeal hearing at the DKI Jakarta High Court on Monday (31/8/2026).
The judge stated that the additional penalty of restitution is an inseparable part of corruption eradication. The judge noted that the Corruption Law regulates an additional penalty in the form of restitution payments amounting to no more than the assets obtained from the corruption.
“This provision shows that the lawmakers’ objective is not merely to inflict suffering on the perpetrator, but to ensure that every benefit obtained through a criminal act of corruption, or every loss arising from such an act, is restored to the state,” said Catur.
The judge stated that the additional penalty of restitution cannot be narrowly understood as a consequence only if the defendant personally enjoyed the proceeds of the crime. The judge said the restitution penalty must be assessed based on the relationship between the defendant’s actions, the economic benefits arising from the criminal act, and the portion of responsibility that can legally be imposed on each perpetrator based on the evidence.
“Therefore, the assessment of restitution must take into account the entire series of proven criminal acts as well as the actual contribution of each perpetrator to the emergence of state losses,” he said.
The judge agreed with the first-instance panel at the Jakarta Corruption Court that Ibam was proven to have participated in committing corruption that resulted in state financial losses in the education digitalisation procurement for 2020 and 2021 at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research and Technology. According to the judge, these losses were a direct result of the Chromebook procurement carried out in accordance with each person’s role and introduction.
“Thus, there is a causal relationship between the defendant’s actions and the emergence of state financial losses that are the object of recovery through the additional penalty mechanism,” the judge said.
The appellate judges therefore changed Ibam’s sentence from four years to five years in prison. The appellate judges also imposed restitution of Rp 5 billion on Ibam.
“Sentencing the Defendant to pay restitution in the amount of Rp 5 billion,” the judge said.
If it is not paid, his assets will be seized and auctioned. The judge said that if Ibam’s assets are insufficient, the penalty will be replaced with four years in prison.
“In the event that the Defendant no longer has sufficient assets to pay the restitution, the Defendant shall be sentenced to four years in prison. And if the Defendant pays restitution in an amount less than the entire obligation to pay restitution, the amount of restitution paid shall be taken into account against the length of the additional penalty in the form of imprisonment as a substitute for the obligation to pay restitution,” the judge said.
For information, Ibam is a former Information Technology Consultant at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research and Technology during the era of Minister Nadiem Makarim. Ibam was initially sentenced to four years in prison in the corruption case involving the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM) that also implicated Nadiem.
The panel of judges at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court did not impose a restitution penalty on Ibam on the grounds that Ibam did not enjoy any profits from the Chromebook and Chrome Device Management (CDM) procurement during Nadiem’s era. The judge stated that Ibam did not receive any money, goods, or facilities related to this procurement. The judge did not grant the prosecutor’s demand for restitution payments from Ibam.
The following are the prison sentences for the defendants in this case:
Nadiem Makarim: 10 years in prison
Ibam: 5 years in prison
Former Director of Primary Education at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research and Technology Sri Wahyuningsih: 4 years in prison
Former Director of Junior Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research and Technology Mulyatsyah: 4.5 years in prison.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-judges-now-imposed-rp-5-billion-in-restitution-on-ibam-in-the-chromebook-case-1788166454)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8641933/alasan-hakim-kini-bebankan-uang-pengganti-rp-5-m-ke-ibam-di-kasus-chromebook), translated from Indonesian