Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Why Indonesian Industry is Increasingly Vulnerable to Layoffs

| | Source: suaragarut.id Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Why Indonesian Industry is Increasingly Vulnerable to Layoffs
Image: suaragarut.id

The Ministry of Manpower recorded approximately 53,000 workers affected by layoffs (PHK) between January and August 2024. This figure must be interpreted with caution, as layoffs are the result of many factors. However, behind these numbers lies a problem far more fundamental than the mere fluctuations in labour absorption.

Layoffs are a symptom. The more important question is: why is Indonesian industry becoming increasingly vulnerable to both global and domestic economic shocks? Labour groups cite several direct causes: a reduction in orders from international buyers, wars and global economic weakening, rising energy and raw material prices, the weakening of the Rupiah, declining domestic purchasing power, the influx of imported products, and decisions by some principals to move production away from Indonesia.

The business community sees more structural issues: declining national industrial competitiveness, high production and logistics costs, regulations that fail to provide adequate certainty, expensive financing, and increasing pressure on labour-intensive industries.

These two perspectives are not contradictory; both describe two sides of the same problem. External shocks are not always avoidable. However, the magnitude of the impact of these shocks on Indonesian industry is heavily determined by the resilience of the domestic real sector. This is where Indonesia’s policy issues need deeper scrutiny.

Not Just a Matter of Purchasing Power

When layoffs increase, the easiest explanation is the weakening of public purchasing power. This holds some truth. When consumption weakens, demand for products drops, production is reduced, and labour is affected. However, making purchasing power the primary explanation risks overlooking more fundamental issues.

Industry does not survive solely on domestic purchasing power. Indonesian industry is connected to global markets, international supply chains, energy prices, exchange rates, logistics costs, trade policies, taxation, financing, technology, productivity, and the investment decisions of multinational corporations.

Therefore, when international buyers stop ordering, the issue is not merely that ‘buyers are not buying’. The policy question is how strong Indonesian industry is in withstanding a drop in orders. Industries with competitive cost structures will have the room to survive. Industries with high productivity will have the margins to absorb shocks. Industries with strong domestic supply chains will be less vulnerable to changes in imported raw material prices.

Conversely, if the cost structure is already high before a crisis occurs, even a small shock can push a company into an unprofitable territory. At that point, layoffs become the last resort. Thus, layoffs are not merely a labour issue; they are an indicator of the resilience of the real sector.

Four Burdens Weighing Down Industry

In my view, there are at least four domestic issues that require serious attention. The first is the increasing burden of taxation and compliance costs. Taxes are certainly necessary; the state requires revenue to fund development and public services. Therefore, the issue is not whether taxes are needed.

The issue is whether the tax design can differentiate between economic activities with a high capacity to pay and productive sectors struggling to maintain investment, production, and employment. In a situation where industry faces weakening demand, rising energy costs, expensive raw materials, competition from imports, and global uncertainty, every additional cost has consequences for corporate decisions.

Tax is not the only cost. It sits in a basket alongside energy, logistics, financing, labour, regulatory compliance, raw materials, and other transaction costs. Companies do not experience government policies in isolation; they experience all these policies as a single figure: the cost of doing business.

Therefore, good fiscal policy is not just about increasing state revenue. It must also ensure that the production base and employment do not shrink. The state needs revenue, but state revenue ultimately depends on the sustainability of economic activities. Closed industries do not pay taxes. Workers who lose their jobs also lose their purchasing power and their ability to pay various other economic levies.

Secondly, there is what can be called the informal cost of doing business. Indonesia faces issues that are often not adequately reflected in corporate production cost tables: informal levies, pressure on companies, intervention by non-state actors, and various forms of transaction costs that arise around business activities.

In this context, attention must be directed towards the behaviour of certain community organisations that exert pressure or levy fees against industry. It is, of course, unfair to generalise all community organisations. Many organisations perform vital social functions. However, if there are acts of coercion or levies against the business world, the issue is no longer merely a relationship between a company and a community organisation.

It is a matter of state capacity. The state has an obligation to ensure that companies can conduct their business legally, safely, and productively. If companies must provide additional costs to face informal pressures, those costs will ultimately be reflected in product prices or reduce company margins.

In industries with thin margins, even the smallest additional cost can determine whether a factory remains viable to produce or not. Therefore, protection for the business world is…

More from 27 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-indonesian-industry-is-increasingly-vulnerable-to-layoffs-1790547691)
Originally published by suaragarut.id (https://suaragarut.id/industri-indonesia-mudah-tertekan-phk), translated from Indonesian
Print