Why Indomaret and Alfamart Often Set Up Shop Next Door Despite Being Rivals
Jakarta - Have you ever wondered why Indomaret and Alfamart can sometimes be found just steps away from each other? Logically, it might seem that they should choose locations far apart to avoid competing for customers. However, in the retail business, the presence of a competitor can actually signal a location with profitable market potential.
Retail companies are not always looking for locations free from competition. They are more interested in areas with high consumer traffic, such as main roads, densely populated residential zones, office districts, or schools. When one minimarket is already operating and bustling with customers, it serves as ‘proof’ that consumer demand exists in that area. A competitor can then enter to capture a share of that same market.
This phenomenon is known as competitive clustering, where similar businesses tend to group together because pursuing consumers in a proven, busy area is more advantageous than opening in a quiet location just to avoid rivalry. Moreover, consumers do not always choose a store based solely on distance. Promotional prices, product completeness, loyalty programmes, service quality, and payment methods can all influence a customer’s choice between one minimarket and another.
There are several reasons why these two minimarket chains often end up in adjacent locations. Compiled from various sources, here are the key factors:
- Differentiating Their Strengths
To consumers, Indomaret and Alfamart may appear very similar, but each claims to have its own distinct advantages. One might compete on lower prices, while the other focuses on a wider product range, friendlier service, or a more comfortable store atmosphere.
- Shaping Consumer Perception
The core of this strategy is to build a positive perception. When consumers visit, the task of each store’s employees is to ensure a good experience, encouraging customers to return to their specific chain rather than the one next door.
- Capturing a Wider Market
The main reason behind this phenomenon is a marketing strategy based on Hotelling’s Law. Both chains deliberately choose locations close to each other to tap into the largest possible customer base. The theory suggests that by positioning themselves near the centre of a market, they can maximise their reach. The battle then shifts from location to winning over consumer preference.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-indomaret-and-alfamart-often-set-up-shop-next-door-despite-being-rivals-1785408789)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/lifestyle/20260730141339-33-755091/alasan-lokasi-indomaret-dan-alfamart-berdekatan-padahal-saingan), translated from Indonesian