Why Individual Hajj Fund Accounts Are Urgent for Intergenerational Fairness
Why is a Hajj fund management system that pools deposits from millions of pilgrims in “one large pool”, without individual records, still considered reasonable and adequate? Why are increases in investment returns during the long waiting period not recorded as the specific entitlement of each pilgrim, but instead distributed in a quasi-collective manner when they depart for the Hajj? And why have the potential unfairness and lack of transparency in Hajj investment returns—addressed in Law No. 34/2014, Government Regulation No. 5/2018, Law No. 14/2025 and an Ijtima Ulama fatwa—not yet served as an alarm prompting fundamental reform of individual Hajj fund management?
These are not empty rhetorical questions. They reflect structural challenges long identified in internal analysis by the Hajj Financial Management Agency (BPKH): a collective system without an individual virtual account for each pilgrim risks violating three fundamental principles at once—fairness, security and the permanence of Hajj funds.
Theoretical foundations: time value, information asymmetry and fairness
Mainstream economic theory provides a sharp and relevant framework. The concept of the Time Value of Money—adapted in Islamic finance as the Money Value of Time—holds that a deposit of Rp25 million in the first year makes a different economic contribution from the same deposit made in the tenth or twenty-sixth year. This is not interest, but recognition of the opportunity cost of time and the risks borne by pilgrims awaiting their turn.
In a Sharia-based profit-sharing investment scheme, compounding over a long waiting period produces significantly different accumulated investment returns. In theory, a pilgrim who waits 26 years accumulates returns many times greater than someone who has only just registered. Without individual accounts, this accumulation is not recorded, transparent or distributed proportionately.
Joseph Stiglitz’s theory of asymmetric information (he received the 2001 Nobel Prize in Economics) clarifies the problem. When pilgrims lack real-time information about the share of investment returns to which they are entitled, an information imbalance emerges that undermines accountability and conflicts with the transparency mandate in Article 10(f) of Law No. 34/2014.
Amartya Sen (Nobel Prize in Economics, 1998), through his entitlement approach and conception of justice as substantive freedom, reminds us that fairness is not merely about equalising aggregate outcomes, but about respecting individual contributions and rights. Redistributing investment returns without regard to waiting time and deposit size violates the principle of hifzh al-mal (protection of wealth) in maqasid al-sharia. Decision No. 09/Ijtima’Ulama/VIII/2024 of the Eighth National Ijtima Ulama of the Indonesian Fatwa Commission explicitly rules it haram to use investment returns from prospective pilgrims’ initial BIPIH deposits to finance the Hajj arrangements of other pilgrims, as this diminishes individual rights.
Richard Thaler (Nobel Prize in Economics, 2017), through his theory of mental accounting, adds a practical dimension: people treat money as belonging to separate “accounts”. Individual accounts would enable pilgrims to “see and feel ownership” of their Hajj funds, strengthening the system’s legitimacy and reducing the risk of mistrust.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-individual-hajj-fund-accounts-are-urgent-for-intergenerational-fairness-1793177584)
Originally published by Republika (https://opini.republika.co.id/berita/tnlxj8502/urgensi-pasal-kelolaan-individual-dana-jemaah-haji-demi-keadilan-antargenerasi), translated from Indonesian