Why Are Mosque Minarets Making Europe Uneasy? A Senior Egyptian Journalist's Analysis
JAKARTA — Mahmoud Sultan, an Egyptian columnist and journalist and member of the Egyptian Journalists’ Union, believes that the anxiety felt by some in Europe over the growing number of mosques and minarets is not primarily caused by theological issues or a clash of religions, but rather by concerns about the changing cultural and civilisational identity of Europe.
In his article published by Al Jazeera, quoted on Tuesday (28/7/2026), Sultan began his explanation with a personal experience during a visit to Beirut, Lebanon. He observed how the Mohammad Al-Amin Mosque stands side by side with Saint George Cathedral in the city centre.
According to him, the equal height of the two houses of worship reflects the balance of identity that has long been the foundation of life in Lebanon.
“Any attempt to alter that identity, even at the architectural level alone, could return Lebanon to the old questions of coexistence, acceptance of the other, and balance between the existing communities,” Sultan wrote.
He had a similar experience when he first visited Istanbul, Turkey. Before arriving, he had assumed that Turkey was a fully secular country following the abolition of the Ottoman Caliphate in 1924. But that impression changed as soon as he stepped out of Atatürk Airport.
“The minarets cleave the sky and are visible from several kilometres away. From its architectural identity alone, I immediately felt that this was a Muslim land,” he said.
According to Sultan, his observations in Beirut and Istanbul serve as an entry point for understanding the European perspective on Islamic symbols that are increasingly visible in public space.
An identity to be defended
Mahmoud Sultan stressed that every country has an architectural identity that is regarded as part of its very essence. For this reason, debates over mosques, minarets, or other religious symbols are not always related purely to matters of faith.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/why-are-mosque-minarets-making-europe-uneasy-a-senior-egyptian-journalists-analysis-1785221550)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tivd3e320/mengapa-menara-masjid-membuat-eropa-gelisah-ini-analisis-jurnalis-senior-mesir), translated from Indonesian