When the US Was Wary of Israel’s Claims About Iran Using Chemical Weapons
The United States has received intelligence from Israel about Iran. Israel said Iran was preparing to use chemical weapons against those it considers its enemies.
A report by the New York Times, citing several US and Gulf officials, said Israel had told the US that Iran was considering using chemical weapons against its enemies. However, Tel Aviv provided no supporting evidence, leading some officials in Washington to doubt the claim, the report said. The story was reported by Al Arabiya and Anadolu Agency on Wednesday (4 November 2026).
According to the New York Times, the Israeli intelligence raised concerns in Washington but also prompted disagreement among US officials. Some members of President Donald Trump’s administration questioned the claim’s credibility and Israel’s motives for sharing it.
Some in Washington were sceptical that Tehran was genuinely preparing to deploy chemical weapons.
Although US intelligence agencies have long monitored Iran’s chemical weapons capabilities, the New York Times reported that officials in Washington disagreed over whether Tehran had the capacity to deploy such weapons effectively, or whether it would choose to use them.
Suspicions about Netanyahu’s aims
Some US officials, the New York Times reported, suspected that Israel’s claim was part of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government’s efforts to persuade Trump to launch another large-scale military operation against Iran.
Others argued that such a warning should be taken seriously. The concerns have also been conveyed to Gulf countries.
A regional official told the New York Times that Israeli officials had assessed that Iran was working to make its chemical weapons ready for use, but offered no supporting evidence.
Israel’s claim doubted
Gulf governments reportedly did not believe Tel Aviv’s claim. According to the New York Times, some US officials were prompted by the Israeli intelligence to compare the situation with erroneous intelligence assessments about weapons of mass destruction that helped lead to the US invasion of Iraq in 2003.
The debate over the intelligence has emerged as Washington weighs the risks of further escalation with Iran, with any potential military response carrying significant consequences for security across the Middle East.
The disagreement highlights the challenge facing US policymakers as they try to distinguish credible intelligence warnings from claims that could influence decisions about military action.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/when-the-us-was-wary-of-israels-claims-about-iran-using-chemical-weapons-1793839951)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/internasional/d-8738936/kala-as-sangsi-bisikan-israel-soal-iran-pakai-senjata-kimia), translated from Indonesian