When State Institutions Weaken, How Great Is the Impact on Indonesia’s Economy?
Economic development depends on more than investment and the availability of labour. Another foundation often overlooked in discussions of growth is the quality of state institutions. This includes legal certainty, the independence of the judiciary and the government’s ability to apply rules consistently, all of which influence the movement of capital and the development of businesses.
For businesses, the law is not merely a mechanism for resolving disputes. Trustworthy institutions determine the security of business assets, the certainty of contracts and the risks involved in making long-term investment decisions. When rules can change to suit those in power, or enforcement is not independent because it is constrained by political interests, economic activity faces uncertainty that can raise business costs and even cause losses.
These issues are particularly relevant amid criticism of the state of democracy and institutions in Indonesia voiced by economist and Paramadina University rector Didik J. Rachbini. In his analysis of recent political developments in Indonesia, Didik has highlighted abuses of power, the weakening of law-enforcement institutions, political patronage and the use of state instruments to serve those in power.
Didik links these issues to the ideas of Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson in their book Why Nations Fail. He says the character of political and economic institutions is one of the fundamental factors determining a country’s success or failure.
“In Why Nations Fail by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, a country’s failure is largely determined by the nature of its economic and political institutions, not by geography, climate, culture or its leaders’ ignorance,” Didik wrote in a statement to KabarBursa.com on Thursday, 5 November 2026.
The quality of institutions is also reflected in the Rule of Law Index published by the World Justice Project (WJP). In 2026, Indonesia scored 0.51 on a scale of 1, down from 0.52 the previous year. It ranked 75th out of 143 countries, six places lower than in 2025.
Several indicators in the index highlight the challenges Indonesia continues to face. The score for Constraints on Government Powers was 0.60, while Criminal Justice scored just 0.37. Absence of Corruption stood at 0.42.
These indicators offer a picture of the challenges involved in limiting government power, ensuring integrity in government and upholding the law. Although they do not directly measure economic losses caused by institutional problems, these factors are relevant to the business climate: investors need a legal system that provides protection and certainty as they conduct economic activity.
The link between institutional quality and investment decisions is also evident in a 2024 study entitled Investment Decision, Legal Certainty and Its Determinant Factors: Evidence from the Indonesia Stock Exchange. The study, which involved 270 investors in Indonesia, found that judicial independence and legal culture positively affect legal certainty. Legal certainty, in turn, has a positive and significant effect on investment decisions.
Legal certainty is a consideration for investors
The findings show that investment decisions depend not only on profit prospects, interest rates or the availability of government incentives. Legal certainty is also a consideration when investors assess the risks of committing capital. In practice, uncertainty over asset protection, regulatory consistency and dispute resolution can force companies to incur additional costs to manage risk.
For a company planning to build a production facility, for example, uncertainty over land ownership and permits can affect a project’s viability calculations. The same applies to investors seeking to acquire a company or make a long-term investment. When protection of property rights and contractual certainty are in doubt, investment risks also change.
From the perspective of institutional economics, these issues are related to transaction costs. Economist Douglass North explains that institutions establish the rules of the game for economic interaction. Clear, enforceable rules help economic actors reduce uncertainty. Conversely, ineffective institutions can increase the costs of gathering information, drawing up contracts, monitoring transactions and resolving disputes.
Even so, Indonesia’s investment figures do not indicate that capital formation has come to a halt. Statistics Indonesia (BPS) recorded gross fixed capital formation (GFCF) of Rp6,452.5 trillion at current prices in 2024, equivalent to 29.15 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP). It grew by 4.61 per cent that year.
The figures show that investment remains an important component of the national economy. It would therefore be wrong to conclude outright that institutional problems have caused investment in Indonesia to slump. However, growth in capital formation alone does not answer whether investment is taking place in a business environment that provides certainty and protection equally.
This is where Didik’s criticism of the use of law as an instrument of power has economic relevance. He argues that institutional damage over the past decade has involved not only open violations of the rules, but also a shift in the role of law, which should serve to constrain power.
“Over the past 10 years, constitutional damage has occurred not only through open violations, but also through the law being turned into an instrument of power,” Didik wrote.
For the economy, the issue is how to ensure that the law remains a set of rules applying to all economic actors. Without such certainty, business opportunities risk being determined not solely by competitiveness, productivity and efficiency, but also by access to power.
The issue extends beyond legal certainty in business transactions. When access to power may determine who gains economically, competition also faces the risk of distortion. In such circumstances, a company’s ability to produce goods and services efficiently may cease to be the main determinant of business success.
Didik has highlighted political patronage and dynastic politics, which he says can give certain groups privileged access to institutions and state resources. This may create unequal opportunities, particularly when ties to those in power matter more than business capacity and competence.
“Practices like this create a problem: family connections to those in power can provide privileged access to institutions and resources, or influence over rule changes, that others do not enjoy,” Didik said.
In political economy, this is related to rent-seeking: attempts to obtain economic gains by influencing policy and regulation or securing privileged access to resources, rather than by improving productivity and efficiency.
In The Rise and Decline of Nations, economist Mancur Olson explains how organised interest groups can influence policy and preserve particular advantages. Over the long term, the dominance of such groups can hinder economic change, restrict competition and reduce the efficiency of resource allocation.
Indonesia’s business-competition indicators, however, show developments that do not entirely align with these concerns. The Indonesia Competition Commission (KPPU) recorded a Business Competition Index score of 5.01 in 2025, up from 4.95 in 2024. Despite the improvement, the score remains below the 5.35 target in the 2025–2029 National Medium-Term Development Plan (RPJMN).
The increase indicates an overall improvement in competitive conditions. But a national figure does not, by itself, show whether competition is equal across all sectors or whether barriers to market entry remain concentrated in particular industries.
Governance issues are also reflected in the 2025 Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI), published by Transparency International. Indonesia scored 34 out of 100 and ranked 109th among 182 countries. The score fell by three points from the previous year. The index measures perceptions of public-sector corruption, so it should not be interpreted as a direct count of cases or the cost of corruption.
The low score points to governance challenges that warrant attention. In economic activity, corruption and rent-seeking can alter business incentives. Companies may be encouraged to devote resources to gaining access to policymakers rather than developing technology, improving workforce skills or making production more efficient.
The impact is not limited to companies that lose out in competition. When resources are not allocated according to productivity, the economy risks losing potential value creation. New businesses may also find it harder to enter the market, while consumers could face fewer choices and less competitive prices.
Another issue Didik has raised is the erosion of meritocracy through patronage. He argues that political ties can create preferential access to positions and resources, putting professionally qualified people at risk of being sidelined.
“Good practices such as meritocracy are weakened when professionals are pushed aside by political patronage and dynastic politics,” Didik said.
In economic terms, meritocracy is closely linked to the quality of decision-making. A bureaucracy staffed on the basis of competence is needed to implement fiscal policy, oversee business activity, manage natural resources and ensure that public spending delivers economic benefits. When professional capacity is not a priority, the effectiveness of policy and the quality of public services may also suffer.
Investment and productivity are at stake
The amount of capital entering the economy does not always translate directly into higher productivity. Once investment is realised, the next question is how effectively that capital generates additional goods and services. In other words, development quality should be measured not only by the value of investment, but also by its ability to create added value.
One indicator used to assess investment efficiency is the Incremental Capital Output Ratio (ICOR). BPS data put Indonesia’s ICOR at 6.33 in 2023. In simple terms, the figure indicates that a relatively large amount of additional capital is needed to generate extra output in the economy.
Even so, ICOR alone cannot be used to conclude that institutional problems have made investment in Indonesia inefficient. The capital required to generate additional output is also affected by industrial structure, technology, infrastructure quality, workforce capacity and the characteristics of investment in each sector.
The indicator nevertheless provides a reason to broaden the discussion beyond the scale of investment to the quality of capital use. Indonesia’s GFCF grew by 4.61 per cent in 2024 and by 6.12 per cent year on year in the fourth quarter of 2025. Capital formation is therefore continuing, but its effectiveness in driving productivity needs to be examined.
Didik also warns that government control over the bureaucracy, state facilities, assistance programmes and public-policy instruments can cause problems if these are used for particular political ends. In his view, the abuse of incumbency can shift policy away from the public interest and towards the interests of those in power.
“The government controls the bureaucracy, state facilities, assistance programmes and various public-policy instruments,” Didik said.
From the perspective of public economics, this concerns how state budgets and resources are allocated. Government spending should be based on public needs, the viability of programmes and the economic benefits they deliver. When budget decisions are influenced more by political interests, there is a risk of waste, poorly targeted spending and less fiscal room for programmes with productive effects.
Institutional quality therefore determines not only how the government exercises power, but also how public resources are used. Independent oversight, budget transparency and a professional bureaucracy are needed to ensure that development policies deliver benefits felt by society as a whole.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/when-state-institutions-weaken-how-great-is-the-impact-on-indonesias-economy-1793983834)
Originally published by kabarbursa.com (https://www.kabarbursa.com/makro/ketika-institusi-negara-melemah-seberapa-besar-dampaknya-bagi-ekonomi-indonesia), translated from Indonesian