Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

When Politics Devours Business: The Dangers of Oligarchy and the Death of Technocratic Reason

| | Source: siaranindonesia.com Translated from Indonesian | Politics
When Politics Devours Business: The Dangers of Oligarchy and the Death of Technocratic Reason
Image: siaranindonesia.com

The state plays a vital, strategic and important role in an economic system. It could even be said that the state determines the health and future of the economy. If the state performs poorly, the rules, laws and norms it establishes will be undermined and may damage the economy. Such practices of governance must therefore be avoided to prevent politics from killing business. If businesses collapse, the effects will spread, bringing down the economy, politics and power at the same time.

A failed state is one that has failed to build its institutions. Leaders in such states see themselves as authoritative and believe they know best, making every decision themselves without involving technocrats and experts. Their excessive authority leads to poor decisions because they disregard those around them. Policy is always decided by the leader alone. According to Acemoglu and Robinson in their seminal book, Why Nations Fail, a country’s failure is not caused by geography, nature, culture or ignorance, but by political power being centralised in the hands of a small elite without checks and balances.

Failed states are marked by information asymmetry and the “Asal Bapak Senang” (ABS) culture — the tendency to tell superiors what they want to hear. Authoritarian leaders create an atmosphere of fear, prompting technocrats, experts and subordinates in the bureaucracy to conceal bad news and report only what pleases those in power. In such a political system, power brings about the destruction of “creative destruction”. Leaders who believe they know everything obstruct creativity, innovation and new thinking from experts, seeing them as threats to the economic status quo and the regime’s political stability.

Let us look more closely at how politics can inadvertently kill business. This happens when political power, government policies and the interests of those in authority undermine the business climate, investment and productive economic activity. When power colludes with favoured businesses for its own benefit, it can be controlled from outside and become an agent of oligarchs. This kind of political power engages in transactional collusion with business. Such secret, privileged relationships produce oligarchy, monopolies, rent-seeking and the capture of public policy.

Consider how leaders can become entangled with their own interests and those of their close associates, turning public officials into businesspeople and creating conflicts of interest. This occurs when officials use state authority to benefit their personal businesses, families and cronies, blending the interests of the state with their own and those of their circle. The consequences are clear: institutions, norms and rules are damaged, and the overall business climate darkens.

There are serious signs that technocratic governance has failed to materialise, leaving public policy dependent on personal decisions. Technocrats and experts have little influence in such a system.

Policy and decision-making then shift from a democratic, technocratic approach to one based on personal intuition and confined to the regime’s inner circle. The resulting policies are inadequate, even poor, from a rational, scientific perspective: they are not evidence-based and are not grounded in expertise. Beyond lacking evidence, economic and business decisions are made for the short-term political benefit of elite groups, disregarding rational market principles and scientific risk analysis.

Before our eyes, there are signs that the state displays these characteristics. Since the time of Jokowi, shallow knowledge has, the article argues, led to institutional damage. Jokowi was not an activist and was far from the stature of statesmen such as Hatta, Sjahrir and others. The article claims that he came to power through low-grade political marketing and a fake vocational-school product, then wielded extensive authority to govern recklessly, damaging many institutions and systems. It alleges that, while in office, he openly used state institutions and officials for his own interests and carried out wiretapping to control political parties.

Power became concentrated, while Parliament was weakened through coercion, quietly eliminating checks and balances and the opposition behind an unassuming public image. Security forces and other state agencies were also controlled and coerced. The article alleges that, after failing to secure a third term, Jokowi continued to exercise power illegally from behind the scenes. It says this has been revealed by a major wiretapping scandal currently unfolding. In repressive politics, where power uses state agencies as instruments for its own interests, it is impossible that officials acted independently; there must be an intellectual author behind them.

The effects on the economy are now visible: the security of investment and economic activity can no longer be guaranteed by state agencies, which the article says are populated by “bandits” created through the leader’s own initiatives. The article says it is fortunate that the attempt to secure three terms in power failed, having been blocked by Megawati. Future leaders must be stopped if they show signs of misconduct or deviation from the Constitution. The article argues that the public, as the true holder of sovereignty, must do so, because Parliament has already been weakened.

More from 8 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/when-politics-devours-business-the-dangers-of-oligarchy-and-the-death-of-technocratic-reason-1794124230)
Originally published by siaranindonesia.com (https://www.siaranindonesia.com/baca/20261108/ketika-politik-memangsa-bisnis-bahaya-oligarki-dan-matinya-nalar-teknokratis.html), translated from Indonesian
Print