Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

When Algorithms Meet Fatwas: The Dilemma of Sharia Governance in the Digital Era

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Finance
When Algorithms Meet Fatwas: The Dilemma of Sharia Governance in the Digital Era
Image: Republika

There is something disquieting when a customer opens a Sharia financing application on their mobile phone and, within seconds, an automated system approves the funding request based on a credit scoring algorithm. No supervisory board examines the contract; no council ensures the transaction is free from gharar or hidden riba within implicit interest structures. Everything runs on the logic of code, not the logic of fiqh.

At this point, a big question emerges: who exactly safeguards Sharia compliance when financial decisions are made by machines rather than humans? This phenomenon feels close to everyday life for many people, given that such applications can now be downloaded as easily as ordering food online, without many realising the genuine Sharia complexities hidden beneath.

This question is not merely a theoretical concern. Research published in Quality Access to Success shows that the growth of Sharia-based fintech in Indonesia prompted the regulator to issue new rules, namely POJK No. 10/POJK.05/2022 concerning Information Technology-Based Joint Funding Services, in response to a pre-existing governance vacuum (Yuspin & Fauzie, 2023). The presence of this regulation is important, but it also proves that digital innovation always races ahead whilst oversight frameworks follow behind.

This phenomenon is not new in the history of Islamic finance. Mohd Haridan et al (2023) in the Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research found that the interaction between Sharia Supervisory Boards and fintech in Islamic banks remains reactive, with technological innovation often launched before an adequate Sharia compliance framework is truly ready to accompany it.

What was once seen as a temporary state of emergency has now become a permanent pattern in the industry. This regulatory issue also crosses borders, as shown by Muryanto (2023) in the Journal of Financial Crime, which compared the urgency of Sharia compliance regulation in fintech across Indonesia, Malaysia and the United Kingdom, concluding that all three face the same gap between the speed of digital innovation and the maturity of their legal frameworks.

The problem lies in the character of the algorithm itself. Artificial intelligence systems operate on historical data patterns and statistical optimisation, whilst fatwas and decisions of the Sharia Supervisory Board (DPS) rest on contextual reasoning that considers the maqasid syariah, whose primary objective is to realise the wellbeing (goodness and welfare) of humankind in this world and the hereafter, whilst preventing harm. These two logics do not automatically align. An algorithm may be highly efficient in disbursing financing, but such efficiency does not automatically mean Sharia compliance, let alone substantive justice for customers.

An editorial by Sairally (2022) in the ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance affirms the same point: governance challenges in contemporary Islamic finance are growing more complex precisely because technology changes the speed and scale of transactions, whilst Sharia supervision mechanisms were designed for a far slower rhythm. A DPS accustomed to reviewing contracts one by one now faces millions of automated transactions per day — a condition that clearly requires an entirely different supervisory approach.

From here the real dilemma emerges. On one hand, digitalisation opens Islamic financial access to segments of society previously unreached by banking services, in line with the spirit of inclusion that is one of the main objectives of the Islamic economy. On the other, digital speed and scale themselves risk eroding the quality of Sharia oversight if not matched by a redesigned governance framework, rather than one merely patched from the old system.

More from 8 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/when-algorithms-meet-fatwas-the-dilemma-of-sharia-governance-in-the-digital-era-1783529495)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/thurax415/ketika-algoritma-bertemu-fatwa-dilema-tata-kelola-syariah-di-era-digital), translated from Indonesian
Print