What's wrong
What's wrong
with PT Kereta Api?
The fierce price competition among airline companies serving
domestic routes has apparently affected state railway company PT
Kereta Api. PT KAI's 2003 net profit of Rp 70 million (around
US$8,000) is not only unimpressive, but completely unbelievable
for such a large company.
But, is it true that the airline price wars are the only thing
causing KAI's shocking performance? The frank answer is no.
According to the Indonesia Railway Watch (IRW), several internal
factors have been significant factors in disrupting the company's
performance.
IRW records show that KAI is finding it difficult to deal with
technical problems of locomotives, unpunctuality and collisions.
From January to February this year, IRW said, there have been 351
cases of locomotive technical failures, and 597 problems in
signal and telecommunication systems. From May to December of
last year there were "only" 164 problems affecting locomotives.
According to IRW, last year average departure of trains was 10
minute late and the average arrival was 62 minutes behind
schedule.
In February this year, the departure and arrival of the trains
averaged 20 minutes and 66 minutes late, respectively.
The facts are obviously confirmation that KAI has never
performed. Then the question is why?
It is likely that the managerial concept of the company has
failed to meet the recent demands and challenges. We are also
afraid that the management team consists of incapable persons,
then the combination of the managerial concept and unqualified
personnel that causes the company's poor performance.
-- Suara Karya, Jakarta
Sweat the cheesy stuff
As Sheldon Silver, the New York Assembly speaker, learned
recently, whatever happens in Vegas does not always stay in
Vegas. Mr. Silver and his wife went there on vacation two years
ago. They hit the jackpot as soon as they checked into the Paris
Las Vegas Hotel. The Silvers were upgraded to a US$1,500-a-night
suite usually reserved for high rollers. Never mind that he was
paying a $109 government rate; these things happen, and Mr.
Silver would have you believe it had nothing to do with the fact
that Caesars Entertainment Inc., the hotel's owner, is hoping to
get a slice of the casino action in New York State. Presumably
Caesars lobbyists invite all visitors to Las Vegas out to dinner,
as they invited the Silvers.
Mr. Silver has insisted that he has done nothing wrong.
Similarly Gov. George Pataki has protested that there was nothing
wrong with flying to St. Barts on a private jet provided by a
developer -- a developer who has business with the Port Authority
-- and the state's weak-kneed Ethics Commission agreed.
Plenty of elected officials need reminding that they were
elected to serve, not be served. They were not elected to have
their swimming pools built or the roads to their houses repaired,
courtesy of the state. Government service is not meant to be a
lifestyle enhancer.
Too many politicians figure they can get away with little
things because everyone knows you can't be bought for a free
dinner or a plane ride. That's how it starts. In Connecticut,
Gov. John Rowland's career began unraveling over such vacation-
home accouterments as a hot tub.
Former Gov. George Ryan of Illinois, renowned for his death-
penalty moratorium, now faces charges ranging from racketeering
to tax fraud. Within the pages of a very long indictment, which
Mr. Ryan has vowed to fight, there are accusations of trips to
Jamaica and Palm Springs, courtesy of an associate who had a
knack for landing state contracts.
Petty, cheesy morsels of corruption are like the proverbial
"broken windows" of violent crime. If we all shrug our shoulders
and look the other way, the consequences can be dire.
-- The New York Times
Indonesian poll is the one to watch
On Monday, the focus of Asia's Year of Voting Frequently
shifts to Indonesia, where 147 million voters will elect the
members of Indonesia's 550-seat parliament. This will be followed
by the presidential election on July 5. For Indonesia, this is a
milestone poll, the second election since Soeharto was toppled in
1998, and the first in which the president will be chosen
directly.
The euphoria of "people power" has faded, the economic rewards
that were supposed to accompany it have failed to materialize and
freedom is starting to look a bit like instability, even chaos.
This is certainly the case in Indonesia. Although economic growth
has picked up, it is nowhere near to what would be required to
improve the living standards of a nation of 235 million people
with an average annual income of US$690 ($907.50). President
Megawati Soekarnoputri has run a lazy administration, so the
greatest barrier to constructive political, legal and economic
reform in Indonesia -- endemic corruption -- has not been
addressed. The danger in these circumstances is that voters may
look for a "strongman" in the presidential poll, and turn to
former army chief Gen. Wiranto, whose role in the atrocities in
East Timor that left 1500 people dead would make him a daunting
prospect for Australia -- and the U.S. -- to deal with.
The good news, however, is that the Indonesian election looks
like following the trend set by Malaysia last month in two
important respects: The poll should be free, peaceful and fair;
and the fundamentalist Islamic parties are languishing in single
digits. As well as being our 10th-largest trading partner,
Indonesia is our key strategic partner in the regional fight
against terror and, while there is still some mutual suspicion at
business-to-business and government-to-government levels, at the
level of police cooperation the partnership has already reaped
dividends, notably in the successful prosecution of the Bali
bombers.
-- The Australian, Sydney
Arab summit chaos
Tunisia's sudden decision to cancel the Arab summit conference
serves to highlight the utter chaos raging in the Arab camp. The
host called off the summit at the eleventh hour without even
consulting the foreign ministers who had gathered in Tunis.
No wonder, Arab League Secretary-General Amr Moussa has
expressed his "astonishment" at the decision. More chaos was in
the offing, with Egypt offering to host the conference and
Tunisia insisting that it reserved the right to call a summit
meeting whenever it wished.
There was no unanimity on the Egyptian offer: it was accepted
by Yemen and Jordan, the others sitting on the fence. All this
show of disunity comes in the wake of Israel's murder of Hamas
leader Sheikh Ahmed Yassin.
The summit cancellation was due to differences over President
George Bush's Greater Middle East Initiative, but the holding of
the conference could have demonstrated Arab unity in the wake of
Sheikh Yassin's murder.
As pointed out by a Palestinian spokesman, the disarray in
Arab ranks could encourage Israel to take "large-scale actions"
against the Palestinians. No wonder, Tel Aviv should have gloated
over the postponement, saying it showed that "the Arab world" was
changing.
The American "initiative" has little chance of success. There
are basically two problems with it: One, anything coming from
outside is bound to face resistance.
If the Arab world is to have democracy, it must grow from
within. Two, it ignores the Palestinian question. The initiative
cannot arouse the interest of Arab leaders and people unless it
seeks to undo the injustices done to the Palestinian people.
Israel is in illegal possession of Arab lands.
Washington must see to it that this occupation comes to an
end, and the Palestinians have a sovereign state of their own.
Without addressing this basic issue, Washington should not expect
its reform initiative to make any headway. As a prelude to this,
Washington must pressure Israel to end its reign of terror in
occupied territories and renounce murder as a state policy.
-- The Dawn, Karachi
On U.S.-Iraq
Did the decision by U.S. President George W. Bush to invade
Iraq last year divert attention and resources from the war on
terrorism?
The more serious of Richard Clarke's charges is that the Bush
administration was obsessed with Iraq from the beginning, and
tried to link Baghdad to Sept. 11. This charge goes to the heart
of the matter, and should be debated in this year's presidential
election.
Its entire approach to Iraq was based on the claim that regime
change in Baghdad would further the aims of the war on terrorism
by transforming an entire region. If it did not, the electorate
has every right to hold it accountable. If it did, how so?
The truth of the matter is, successive administrations failed
to curb al-Qaeda's growth. The bipartisan commission looking into
Sept. 11 will issue its final report at the end of July, but all
its initial findings indicate there will be plenty of blame to go
around.
-- The Straits Times, Singapore
Gays in the military
It's not surprising that the number of gays dismissed from the
armed services has reached its lowest level since the Pentagon
adopted its "don't ask, don't tell" policy nine years ago.
The explanation is simple: The armed forces are struggling to
maintain troop strength in Afghanistan and Iraq. Discharging
soldiers because of sexual orientation doesn't make sense.
The Servicemembers Legal Defense Network reports that the
military kicked out 787 gays and lesbians in 2003, down 17
percent from 2002 and 39 percent from 2001.
Under the "don't ask, don't tell" policy, gays may serve if
they don't reveal their sexual orientation.
Long after homosexual conduct between consenting adults was
legalized by individual states (and by a recent U.S. Supreme
Court ruling), it's still verboten under Article 125 of the
Uniform Code of Military Justice.
The military has justified its homophobia by claiming that
gays are prejudicial to "good order and discipline." (That echoed
the British armed forces, institutional ancestors of the American
military.)
But on both sides of the Atlantic, homosexuals have always
been in the ranks and have served with honor, often giving their
lives for their countries. In times of grave national crisis,
sexual orientation doesn't seem to matter as much as combat
skills.
"When they need people, they keep them," C. Dixon Osborn,
executive director of the Servicemembers group, told The
Associated Press. "When they don't, they implement their policy
of discrimination with greater force."
Britain rescinded its ban on gays in uniform in 1999, and no
one can disparage the outstanding performance of UK troops in the
Iraq war.
It's time for Congress to do the same and excise this outmoded
affront to individual liberty from military law -- and sound Taps
for "don't ask, don't tell.
-- The Denver Post, Denver, Colorado
Sino-India relations
There's a subtle but sure shift taking place in Sino-Indian
relations: from political grandstanding to a sort of quiet
pragmatism. Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee's six-day sojourn
in China last year was clear enough indication of this. And now
the visiting Chinese Defense Minister Gen. Cao Gangchuan thinks
aloud about China and India becoming "eternal good neighbors,
good partners and good friends". And establishing defense ties.
China's wish for a multipolar world where it occupies prime
position in a unipolar Asia was never a best-kept secret. So the
post-9/11 U.S. war on terrorism must have made Beijing uneasy.
Beijing must also be concerned by the growing Indo-U.S. military
partnership.
China must be banking on military cooperation with India to be
a counterweight in such an eventuality. And, Gen. Cao may add,
even if there's little political progress made, trade relations
that include defense establishments never hurt anyone.
-- The Hindustan Times, Delhi, India
The postponed Arab summit
Surprised at a unilateral Tunisian decision to scrap an Arab
summit hours before its scheduled opening, Egypt, being the
country of the Arab League's headquarters, has stepped in to
offer to host the deferred gathering. The Egyptian offer has
drawn warm welcome from an Arab world disappointed at the
inability to convene a prescheduled summit under such crucial
circumstances.
Contacts are under way between Cairo and other Arab capitals
to set the scene for this urgent conference, which will be aimed,
among other things, at undoing the damage wrought by the sudden
decision to postpone the Tunisian gathering indefinitely. The
Palestinian-Israeli dispute, Iraq and a controversial U.S. plan
for reforms in the Arab world topped the agenda of the aborted
Tunisian event.
The Palestinian problem was moved to the top of the agenda
after Israel's cold-blooded slaying of Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the
spiritual leader of the resistance movement Hamas. The killing of
the wheel-chair-bound Yassin in an airstrike in Gaza last week
fired up sentiment across the Arab nation.
-- Egyptian Gazette, Cairo, Egypt
'The Passion of the Christ'
Once you've seen Mel Gibson's film, the most profound
remaining mystery is why this Passion arouses so many passions.
Something so excessive should be insignificant.
A sadomasochistic film, it is fascinated with violence,
suffering and hate. It is a work that could exacerbate anti-
Semitism, as the only question it raises is who had Jesus put to
death and singles out Jewish elders as the only ones responsible.
This film is not a work of art, nor an invitation to
spirituality, but a propaganda tract attempting to mobilize
believers and stir up their passions.
-- Liberation, Paris
Chirac's election setback
So, he has three years ahead of him, Jacques Chirac, with a
challenging left opposition.
Is he going to sack the prime minister or order him to change
course?
The basic forecast after the left's victory was that the head
of government would be allowed to stay on after all.
Jean-Pierre Raffarin has certainly lost some of his
credibility as the man from the countryside who understands the
common Frenchman, but he still retains his by far greatest
advantage -- that he is not a presidential candidate next time.
Jacque Chirac wants to decide on this issue himself. And as
long as he can do that, he's in control also of French politics.
-- Dagens Nyheter, Stockholm, Sweden
Faster travel
Not six months after the consigning of Concorde to the great
hangar in the sky, NASA scientists have inaugurated a new
generation of whiz-bang fast things that makes old big nose look
like a slow coach.
Whether or not it is entirely positive for human beings to be
able to hurl themselves from one side of the earth to another in
the blinking of an eye is another matter entirely. This is not to
suggest that readers should emulate the kind of naive fears about
progress that encouraged many eminent Victorians to view the
train with loathing. And regular trans-Atlantic commuters would
happily dispense with the jet lag that accompanies "red eye"
flight. However, there are many among us for whom life moves
rather too speedily as it is.
Necks may crane when jets pass over, mobile phones may have
replaced birdsong as the soundtrack to our lives. But that does
not mean that their owners should not also pore over novels, nod
over cricket and refuse to watch pots boil. After all, many's the
hare that ends up as roadkill. Tortoises more often than not see
out their three score years and ten.
-- The Times, London
Ireland's smoking ban
Most of the articles written about the ban on smoking in the
workplace, introduced in Ireland last night, have been
lighthearted in tone. They have focused on the sheer incongruity
of imposing such a ban in the homeland of James Joyce and Flann
O'Brien, where the smoke-filled bar is so much a part of the
national culture.
Britons would be foolish, however, to laugh too heartily about
the ban. What has happened in Ireland is a very serious assault
on the civil liberties of a substantial minority of the
population. Many hundreds of thousands of smokers -- a quarter of
the adult population, according to the Irish government's own
figures -- are being denied one of the great pleasures of their
lives by nannying politicians who have paid not the slightest
heed to their wishes.
-- The Daily Telegraph, London
Australian forces in Iraq
The consequences of the U.S.-led coalition's invasion of Iraq
for the wider war against terrorism remain a matter of
contention. What ought to be beyond contention is that, having
taken part in that invasion, members of the coalition have
thereby incurred an obligation to the people of Iraq.
When Australian troops return from Iraq should be determined
by when that obligation is fulfilled. Civil order must be
restored and essential infrastructure rebuilt, and the Iraqi
people must be supported in establishing democratic structures of
government.
It has been generally recognized that this process will not be
completed by the time Iraqi sovereignty is restored. Now,
however, Opposition Leader Mark Latham has pledged that if Labor
wins office later this year he will ensure that the remaining
Australian troops in Iraq are home by Christmas.
Perhaps Mr. Latham believes that the popular mood is shifting,
and that the Howard Government is increasingly vulnerable because
of its commitment to the Iraq war. That may be so, but it does
not remove Australia's responsibilities in Iraq.
The time to go will become clear as events unfold in Iraq. So
Labor's policy used to be, and so Mr. Latham should have left it.
-- The Age, Melbourne, Australia
The French regional elections
The defeat of the right in the French regional elections ...
has made many of our commentators, as well as many Italian
politicians, think that in Europe the left has suddenly become
victorious.
It is not like that.
In Germany only a miracle could save the red-green coalition
from a political "debacle" at the next elections.
Part of the explanation should be sought in the way the
electoral campaign was managed ... the left presented itself as
more united.
This explanation is correct but incomplete. There's more.
There's the fact that the French government pays for its
attempts, however shy, to reform the welfare state.
The lesson of the French case is that whoever tries to oppose
economic stagnation and decline stands a great chance of being
punished by the electorate.
Oppositions are not rewarded for their eventual virtues,
governments (of any color) are punished for their attempts ... to
bring their respective countries out from the dead canal of
stagnation.
If this is really the new European trend, we should be
frightened.
-- Corriere della Sera, Milan, Italy
---
The Dallas Morning News, on Sudan's genocide:
Ten years ago, the world stood by while the Hutu government of
Rwanda and its extremist allies tried to exterminate the
country's Tutsi minority. About 800,000 Tutsis and politically
moderate Hutus died in what author Samantha Power called "the
fastest, most efficient killing spree of the 20th century."
Once the extent of the pogrom became clear, world leaders
regretted their failure to respond. During his 1998 visit to
Rwanda, President Bill Clinton even went so far as to apologize.
In Sudan, the warning signs of a similar tragedy are evident.
The crisis has nothing to do with the long-simmering civil war in
southern Sudan, which pits the mostly Arab and Muslim central
government against Christian and animist blacks. That war is
winding down, thanks in large measure to U.S. diplomacy. Rather,
the crisis emanates from the western province of Darfur, where
government-backed Arab Muslim militiamen are carrying out a
scorched-earth campaign against the region's Muslim blacks.
Roger Winter of the U.S. Agency for International Development
recently told Congress that the war there is "arguably the most
serious humanitarian crisis on the African continent." Half of
Darfur's 6 million people have been affected, and a sixth of them
are on the run. The militiamen's method of operating, Mr. Winter
testified, "is to rape, loot and burn villages with total
impunity."
Humanitarian organizations have difficulty getting through
with food and medicine. Even when they do get through, the
militiamen steal their supplies.
The central government has a right to attack Darfur's rebels.
It doesn't have a right to murder and chase out civilians.
There's oil in Sudan, but that isn't why the United States should
involve itself. No, the United States should involve itself so
that another president won't feel obliged to apologize for having
ignored genocide.
As a presidential candidate, George W. Bush said he agreed
with the decision not to intervene in Rwanda. As president, he
should realize that the United States and the rest of the world
have a duty to mankind that transcends self-interest.
---
San Diego Union-Tribune, San Diego, California, on American censors:
The closing of the Baghdad newspaper, Al Hawza, is a case of
egregious bad judgment by the American occupation authority; it
should be reversed. The Bush administration wants to create
democracy in Iraq. Democracies include newspapers of all stripes,
good and bad, those that support governments and those that
don't.
One can make a case against public speech that incites
violence or insurrection ... but that was not the charge against
Al Hawza, a Shiite weekly. The charge rather was that it was
anti-occupation, printed unsubstantiated rumors and occasional
lies.
As to printing unsubstantiated rumors and lies, we suggest the
checkout stand of your local supermarket for an assortment of
scandal sheets published in this country. ...
Al Hawza supports Moktada al-Sadr, a fiery cleric who has no
use for the American occupation. Unlike Grand Ayatollah Ali al-
Sistani, a fellow Shiite whose opposition to the occupation is
more subtle (and, many would argue, more dangerous), Sadr's views
are expressed openly and defiantly. He is anti-occupation, anti-
American and unreliable. Al Hawza reflects those positions and
qualities.
But should it be censored and closed? Does it make sense to
drive such sentiments, which clearly exist, underground? Does
censorship ever do anything but create more interest in what has
been censored and more anger in those who, denied the pen, are
left with the sword?
Under Saddam Hussein, the world knows, there was no
dissent. ...
Americans should never compromise the free press principle, so
vital to democracy, whether at home or in nations that fall
temporarily under our control. As long as Al Hawza does not
incite public violence, its freedom to print should not be
curtailed.
---
The Palm Beach Post, Palm Beach, Florida, on the 9/11 Commission:
Apparently, the Bush administration is so threatened by
information that it assumes everyone is afraid of public
disclosure. Republicans sent out last week to discredit former
anti-terror chief Richard Clarke thought they could scare him by
threatening to declassify his 2002 testimony before a bipartisan
congressional committee.
But the truth, the whole truth and the public truth seems not
so intimidating to Mr. Clarke and others, such as Sen. Bob
Graham, Democrat-Florida, who was co-chairman of that committee
and was demanding release of needlessly classified material long
before Mr. Clarke made headlines.
Most notably, Sen. Graham objected last year when the White
House classified an entire section of his committee's report on
Saudi Arabia's ties to the 9/11 attacks. Mr. Clarke, who says
President Bush let Al-Qaeda slip in priority and damaged the war
on terror by invading Iraq, on Sunday embraced the Bush
administration's "threat."
He called for release of his 2002 testimony as well as memos
he exchanged with national security adviser Condoleezza Rice
prior to Sept. 11, 2001. Sen. Graham last week said that he
didn't think Mr. Clarke's testimony before the congressional
committee conflicted with Mr. Clarke's recent testimony before
the 9/11 commission. ...
The Bush administration threatens to tell what it knows. Why
is that a threat? It should be a promise.
GetAP 1.00 -- APR 2, 2004 01:41:15
;AP;
ANPA ..r..
Editorial Roundup
By The Associated Press=
JP/
By The Associated Press=
Here are excerpts from editorials in newspapers around the world:
---
The East African, Nairobi, Kenya, on challenges for Rwanda:
Rwanda next week commemorates 10 years since the 1994 genocide
in which more than 800,000 people were killed in the space of 100
days. The government will spend $7 million on the weeklong
festivities that will see several heads of state and government
converge at Kigali from April 7.
... In the past 10 years, the country has made giant strides
toward economic revival, which even critics of President Paul
Kagame's government cannot ignore.
Growth rates averaging 6 per cent have been recorded,
inflation kept under 5 per cent and the exchange rate brought
under control. Tea output has increased and the privatization
process is described as a success. ...
Peace has returned to the nation of 8.2 million and thousands
of troops that had been deployed to the Congo are back in the
country. Some Interahamwe commanders have also given up their
rebellion and returned to Kigali.
However, we urge the government in Kigali to use the
celebrations to reflect on the challenges ahead. Among these are
the high level of poverty, which currently stands at 60 per cent;
the incidence of HIV/Aids, which is estimated at more than 13 per
cent; unemployment; and the issue of returning refugees from
neighboring countries like Tanzania and Uganda.
---
---
---
---
Asahi Shimbun, Tokyo, on EU's decision to fine Microsoft:
One of the reasons for the repeated antitrust offensives
against Microsoft around the world is obviously its near monopoly
on the market for PC operating systems, the basic software on
which a computer runs. Much of the blame, however, falls on the
company for its aggressive and questionable marketing strategy
aimed at dominating the market for important applications as
well.
If many applications are bundled together with the dominant
operating system, software developers will have little incentive
to offer alternatives, thus curbing competition. As a result,
better programs would not be developed and prices of existing
applications would tend to rise. The lack of alternatives could
also make computer systems more vulnerable to computer viruses,
with attacks concentrating on the only program available. All
these considerations provided good justification for the EU's
tough action to stop Microsoft's bundling approach.
Unfettered competition on a level playing field has been the
principle driving force of technological innovation, especially
in the area of information technology. Microsoft should learn to
live with this competitive dynamic of a free market and act in a
manner that befits the leading player in the field.
[ MORE[
GetAP 1.00 -- APR 2, 2004 01:41:05