What Is China Seeking from a Trump-Putin Summit on Ukraine?
US President Donald Trump’s administration is stepping up diplomatic efforts to revive stalled negotiations aimed at ending Russia’s war in Ukraine.
Washington has increased pressure on Kyiv and its European partners, while seeking to bring Moscow back to the negotiating table through a series of concessions. These include an agreement on Russian diesel exports to the US and the temporary easing of some sanctions.
Russia, however, appears in no hurry to resume substantive peace talks. After a meeting between US special envoy Steve Witkoff and Russian President Vladimir Putin in St Petersburg on 21 October, Russia said it was ready to hold technical-level talks with Ukraine next month.
Putin’s adviser Yury Ushakov said after the meeting that Putin had agreed to resume US-mediated peace talks after 10 November. He added that the next round could take place in Abu Dhabi and would focus on “building a security system for Russia and Ukraine after the war ends”.
Ushakov said Putin had also shared views with Witkoff on a possible trilateral meeting involving Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping. He said Beijing was preparing for such a meeting.
A three-country summit without Ukraine
Moscow has proposed a trilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, scheduled for 18–19 November in Shenzhen, China. The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported the proposal earlier this week. According to the newspaper’s sources, Putin hopes to reach an agreement with Trump and Xi to end the war in Ukraine on terms favourable to Russia.
Moscow’s proposal for a meeting between Russia, the US and China, excluding both Ukraine and the European Union, offers a glimpse of the negotiating format Russia wants. Moscow insists that Ukraine must be prepared to make territorial concessions before talks can resume. Putin has also repeatedly said he will negotiate only if Russia’s interests are taken into account.
According to the WSJ, Putin sees the proposed meeting in Shenzhen as a possible new Yalta Conference. The term refers to the 1945 meeting of the US, British and Soviet leaders to discuss Nazi Germany’s defeat and the post-war order in Europe.
The newspaper reported that Chinese officials had indicated through diplomatic channels that Beijing had no objection to a three-way format if Trump was willing to attend. Trump, whose relations with Kyiv have deteriorated significantly in recent weeks, has also said he is open to the talks.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said during a visit to Oslo on 20 October that any dialogue about his country’s future would be acceptable only if Ukraine had a seat at the negotiating table.
What would China gain from the talks?
Temur Umarov, a Berlin-based researcher at the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center who focuses on China-Russia relations, said he was not surprised by the Kremlin’s proposal. He told DW that Moscow wants Washington to show it respect and treat it as a great power in international politics.
Previous US administrations had been unwilling to discuss issues concerning Ukraine’s sovereignty with Russia in Kyiv’s absence. But, Umarov said, Russia now believes that such talks may be possible.
Moscow appears to hope that any agreement reached at the meeting would prompt the White House to pressure Ukraine and the European Union to accept Russia’s terms. But what role would China play in the talks?
Umarov believes Beijing would most likely participate as a symbolic partner, rather than as an active mediator responsible for the outcome. “Beijing has no intention of taking responsibility for Ukraine’s future,” he said.
China’s participation in the summit would not create any additional obligations for it. “It is not surprising that the Kremlin insists on this format,” Umarov explained. “Russia wants to show that it is on an equal footing not only with the United States, but also with China. Objectively, however, Moscow is not the more dominant partner in that relationship.”
Umarov believes China has few direct interests in talks of this kind. Even if the leaders issued a joint statement, he said, Beijing would seek to use language as vague and non-binding as possible. This would allow China to portray almost any subsequent development in the war as consistent with the understanding reached at the summit. According to Umarov, such flexibility would be a key condition for Beijing’s participation.
Yurii Poita, a senior researcher at the Mercator Institute for China Studies (MERICS), takes a different view. He believes China and Russia have overlapping strategic interests, particularly in efforts to build an alternative security architecture across Eurasia.
In his view, both countries would benefit from a reduction in Western military presence in Europe and Asia and a weakening of NATO’s influence. “If Russia and China succeed in persuading the United States to reduce its military presence in Europe and its military aid to Ukraine, Russia will gain an additional advantage on the battlefield,” Poita told DW.
He added that such a development would further undermine the European Union’s confidence in the US as a NATO ally. Poita believes Moscow and Beijing will seek this outcome in any negotiations with Washington.
How important is Putin’s continued rule to China?
Michael Kimmage, director of the Kennan Institute in the United States, also doubts that Beijing is preparing to take a more active diplomatic role in ending the war.
Kimmage told DW that China may see the conflict as a source of instability and want to preserve trade relations with Ukraine and other countries in the region. But he believes other priorities matter more.
“What matters more to China is the continuation of Vladimir Putin’s political rule,” he said.
According to Kimmage, Russia offers China several geopolitical advantages, including low-cost energy supplies and a foreign-policy partner that rarely obstructs Beijing’s interests.
He believes China will continue to provide indirect support for Russia’s military effort to prevent Moscow from being defeated. An outright Russian victory may not be Beijing’s objective, he said, but ensuring that Putin does not lose is very important. Kimmage therefore does not expect China to pressure the Russian president to end the war if Putin himself is unwilling to do so.
EU absence: a sign of the region’s weakening?
Neither Ukraine nor the European Union would be included in the proposed talks in China.
Kateryna Krasina, a junior researcher at the Kyiv-based New Geopolitics Network, believes their exclusion could reveal how Beijing views the international influence of both parties.
In her assessment, China’s approach suggests that Beijing does not regard Ukraine as an independent party to the negotiations and sees Europe as relatively weak.
Kimmage, however, argues that Europe’s exclusion from the summit would not necessarily diminish its influence over the course of the negotiations.
He acknowledged that European governments may have limited ability to prevent a meeting between Trump, Putin and Xi. But he pointed to European diplomatic efforts ahead of the 2025 Trump-Putin summit in Alaska, which he said helped prevent an outcome that could have harmed Europe.
Kimmage said Europe’s influence had grown through financial assistance to Ukraine and extensive defence-industrial cooperation, particularly involving Germany and other European countries.
He said European support had played an important role in Ukraine’s ability to hold back the advance of Russian forces. “And that support means leverage,” Kimmage said.
Russia, China and the US may all have an interest in portraying Europe as a secondary power, he believes. But such a portrayal would overlook Europe’s real influence.
“Appearance and reality are not entirely the same,” he said, distinguishing the great-power diplomacy evocative of the Yalta Conference from Europe’s role in supporting Ukraine.
Umarov offered another perspective.
He believes that any diplomatic agreement between the US, Russia and China would still have to contend with realities on the ground.
“China understands that whatever the outcome of talks with the United States and Russia, the reality on the ground will be very different and will depend above all on Ukraine,” he said.
“Whether it likes it or not, the Kremlin has to accept that Ukraine is capable of deciding its own actions. Neither the United States nor Western countries can fully determine what happens on the battlefield through diplomatic pressure alone.”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/what-is-china-seeking-from-a-trump-putin-summit-on-ukraine-1792731170)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8720262/apa-yang-diincar-china-dari-ktt-trump-putin-soal-ukraina), translated from Indonesian