What Happens if the US Halts Aid to Israel?
In recent months, two ideas once considered radical in Democratic Party policy thinking—cutting financial support and halting weapons transfers to Israel—have now become mainstream. This shift reflects rising tensions within the party over the conflict in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Palestine.
Last month, nearly half of the Democrats in the US House of Representatives voted to end aid to Israel. Meanwhile, around 40 percent of the caucus called for blocking offensive weapons sales until the Israeli government can convince Congress that American bombs will not be used to commit war crimes.
This trend is not only occurring at the legislative level but is also beginning to spread to potential candidates for the 2028 election. Rahm Emanuel, the former Mayor of Chicago known as a centrist, recently suggested that America should end aid and place conditions on weapons sales based on Israel’s compliance with US law.
On the progressive side, Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland went further by stating that Israel should be barred from accessing US-made offensive weapons until they agree to a time-bound plan to end the occupation and implement a two-state solution.
Although ending the annual aid of US$3.8 billion (around Rp60 trillion) is politically popular, analysts assess that its impact on Israeli policy would be minimal. Israel is a wealthy country capable of funding its own military.
In 2025, Israel spent around 7.9 percent of GDP on the military. Without US aid, this figure would only need to rise to 8.5 percent, an increase still considered within the limits of their economic capacity. In fact, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has previously expressed a desire to reduce financial dependence on the US in order to gain greater freedom in security operations.
Unlike monetary aid, Israel has a significant dependence on American weapons technology. Between 2021 and 2025, America supplied 68 percent of Israel’s major arms imports. The most critical dependence lies in the fleet of fighter jets such as the F-15, F-16, and F-35.
Although military pressure may limit Israel’s combat capabilities, it does not necessarily change their political stance towards Palestinian sovereignty. Public opinion in Israel has shifted to the right over recent decades. A 2025 Gallup poll showed only 27 percent of Israelis support a two-state solution, while 63 percent oppose it.
To truly change Israel’s political calculus, far more drastic measures are needed than simply cutting off offensive weapons aid.
Regardless of whether such pressure succeeds in changing Israeli policy, many on the left wing of Congress argue that the primary goal is to end US complicity in human rights violations.
Daryl Kimball, Executive Director of the Arms Control Association, stressed that the US has a moral responsibility because it has played a major role in creating Israel’s conventional military superiority. According to him, using influence to avoid being an accomplice in war crimes is a priority separate from the final political outcome in the region.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/what-happens-if-the-us-halts-aid-to-israel-1786459854)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/internasional/920670/apa-yang-terjadi-jika-as-hentikan-bantuan-kepada-israel), translated from Indonesian