Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

What Are the Implications of a US-Saudi Nuclear Deal for the Middle East?

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Politics
What Are the Implications of a US-Saudi Nuclear Deal for the Middle East?
Image: detikcom

Following US President Donald Trump’s latest statement on Thursday (23/07) morning, it remains unclear whether the controversial agreement with Saudi Arabia allowing the Middle Eastern autocracy to build a civilian nuclear programme will be signed.

Trump said the deal could only proceed if Saudi Arabia normalised diplomatic relations with Israel. The Saudi government has repeatedly insisted recently that it would only do so if Israel genuinely moved towards the establishment of a Palestinian state. With the current Israeli government, that is highly unlikely to happen.

The agreement also requires approval from the US Congress, where it has already drawn opposition, with critics warning it could spark a nuclear arms race in the Middle East.

One of the main reasons experts are so worried is that within the next few years, the deal, as currently drafted, could give Saudi Arabia leeway to enrich its own uranium.

The more uranium is enriched, the greater the potential for it to be diverted to weapons production. In the past, Saudi ruler Mohammed bin Salman stated that if Iran were to produce a nuclear bomb, Saudi Arabia would need one as well.

Of the roughly 38 countries with civilian nuclear energy programmes, most do not enrich their own uranium but import it instead. This scheme is the “gold standard” allowing the transfer of nuclear technology without breaching the non-proliferation regime.

The US-Saudi agreement also has regional implications, particularly because it appears less strict than similar deals concluded previously.

United Arab Emirates: Special treatment for Saudi Arabia?

A looser agreement between the US and Saudi Arabia is likely to displease the United Arab Emirates, given that the two countries often compete for geopolitical influence.

The UAE already has a nuclear power plant, Barakah, thanks to an agreement made with the US in 2009.

Like almost all US nuclear cooperation agreements, the UAE deal includes what is known as an “additional protocol” signed with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). This means the IAEA can conduct comprehensive inspections of all nuclear facilities. The UAE also agreed not to enrich uranium.

The Saudi agreement, by contrast, is purely bilateral, between the US and Saudi Arabia only, without involving the IAEA, and Saudi Arabia may ultimately be permitted to enrich its own uranium.

For the UAE, developing nuclear energy is driven more by prestige as a pioneer in the Arab world than by military ambitions, Nour Eid told DW earlier this year. Eid is a Paris-based independent researcher who has published papers on nuclear ambitions in the Middle East for a number of think tanks.

However, she pointed out that the UAE agreement also contains a clause stating that “if a regional or neighbouring state has a more flexible agreement, they reserve the right to renegotiate their terms.”

Israel: No longer the only country with the bomb?

The Saudi-US nuclear agreement would also alarm Israel, especially if it leads to the development of a nuclear bomb in the Gulf state. That would make Saudi Arabia the only other country in the Middle East to possess one.

Israel has never acknowledged possessing nuclear weapons, but their existence is an open secret, with an estimated 90 warheads along with delivery systems.

Israeli politicians view the Saudi deal as a threat and say their wishes have been ignored. “Every military nuclear programme begins with a civilian one,” warned former Israeli defence minister Avigdor Lieberman.

Saudi Arabia has lobbied for its own civilian nuclear programme for years. At one point, potential US-Saudi cooperation in this area was even seen as a bargaining chip in diplomacy: if Saudi Arabia, often regarded as the leader of the Islamic world, were willing to normalise relations with Israel, it would receive nuclear technology from the US.

Now, with the nuclear issue decoupled from the normalisation condition, Israel is clearly unhappy.

“This agreement, together with the prospect of the US selling F-35 fighter jets to Turkey, adds to existing differences between the US and Israel over Iran, the Israeli occupation of southern Lebanon and parts of southern Syria,” wrote James Dorsey, a regional expert at Singapore’s Rajaratnam School of International Studies, in his regular newsletter on Thursday (23/07).

US motives behind the nuclear transfer

There are several possible reasons why the US proposed this agreement.

Paris-based researcher Eid pointed out that it may be linked to American competition with China and Russia, the world’s main nuclear suppliers. China and Russia have bid to build nuclear power plants in Saudi Arabia, and those offers tend to come with fewer conditions, she said. Trump has also previously promised to revitalise the US nuclear sector, and the Saudi deal is worth billions of dollars.

There is also the Iran war factor to consider. The US-Israel war against Iran that began in late February prompted Iran to attack US-allied Gulf states, straining America’s relationship with Saudi Arabia, squeezed between the hegemonic ambitions of Israel and Iran.

The agreement binds the US and Saudi Arabia more closely together, said Rosemary Kelanic, director of the Middle East programme at the US-based Defense Priorities Foundation think tank.

For instance, the deal gives “Saudi Arabia a strong bargaining resource to extort future concessions from Washington, including new security guarantees, by threatening to weaponise its programme unless the US promises greater military protection,” Kelanic said in a press statement on Wednesday (22/07).

The US may feel compelled to trade defence protection for Saudi Arabia giving up its potential nuclear weapons, as happened with West Germany and South Korea, she said.

“They make nuclear progress, we want to prevent them from getting the bomb, and ultimately we offer greater US military protection so they abandon their programme,” Kelanic explained. “Giving Riyadh functional uranium enrichment could tie the US to Saudi Arabia forever.”

The agreement could also mean the US is forced to intervene to rescue the Saudi monarchy if it comes under threat, she asserted.

Iran: Regional rivalry

When the agreement was announced, observers immediately highlighted the striking irony behind it. The Trump administration is now prepared to grant Saudi Arabia the very thing that triggered the war with Iran, various experts said.

For Iran, Saudi Arabia’s mastery of nuclear technology is a blow because “their arch-enemy (the US) is giving their regional rival a head start in its own nuclear programme,” Kelanic said on the social media platform X.

That is why the deal makes a swift end to the conflict between Iran and the US increasingly unlikely, she argued. “Iran will certainly trust the US less and be less willing to make any concessions,” Kelanic noted online.

The agreement also makes Iran more likely to seek to weaponise its own nuclear programme more quickly, she continued.

Other observers agreed and are also worried about the start of a nuclear arms race in the Middle East.

However, according to Eid, all of this is unlikely to happen in the near future. It would take between 10 and 20 years for Saudi Arabia to develop nuclear power, let alone nuclear weapons, she told DW.

More from 25 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/what-are-the-implications-of-a-us-saudi-nuclear-deal-for-the-middle-east-1784973126)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8589836/apa-dampak-perjanjian-nuklir-as-saudi-bagi-timur-tengah), translated from Indonesian
Print