Weighing the 3% Limit: Between Growth Ambition and Fiscal Discipline
Discourse regarding the relaxation of fiscal deficit and debt-to-GDP ratio regulations is resurfacing. This is linked to the government’s significant financing needs to stimulate the economy towards a growth target of 6.0%–8.0% by 2029, a prerequisite for Indonesia to transition into a high-income nation by 2045.
This discussion aligns with a report by The Economist titled “Poor Asian Countries Face An Ageing Crisis,” which suggests that Asian nations, including Indonesia, may face the phenomenon of “getting old before getting rich.” According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), Thailand experienced an ageing population between 2002 and 2021, where the proportion of citizens aged 65 and above rose from 7.0% to 14%. Similarly, Indonesia’s elderly population is projected to exceed 14% by 2045.
This means Indonesia has a limited window of only 19 years to become a wealthy nation with a per capita income of US$12,500, joining the ranks of South Korea, Japan, and Singapore, before the demographic shift takes hold.
Fiscal Space
To avoid the “get old before you get rich” phenomenon, Indonesia’s economy must grow at an average of 8.0% over the next 19 years. This requires fiscal space—the capacity of the government to increase debt and run a fiscal deficit without triggering insolvency.
As noted by economist Oliver Blanchard, a country possesses significant fiscal space if the interest rate on its debt remains lower than its real economic growth rate. In such a condition, even if there is a primary balance deficit and a tendency for debt to increase, the debt-to-GDP ratio will remain stable. The primary balance is the difference between revenue and expenditure, excluding interest payments. Consequently, debt sustainability remains intact as debt increases are controlled, and the government can meet long-term obligations to holders of Government Securities (SBN) with a very low risk of default.
However, relaxing the fiscal deficit and debt-to-GDP ratios through new debt could become problematic if such measures increase aggregate demand, prompting the central bank to raise the policy rate. An increase in interest rates narrows the gap between debt interest rates and nominal economic growth, thereby shrinking fiscal space.
To meet large budgetary financing needs, it is not enough to simply manipulate the fiscal deficit ratio from 3.0% to 6.0% of GDP or allow the debt-to-GDP ratio to exceed 60%. Following Blanchard’s (2022) logic, any relaxation of the provisions in Law Number 17 of 2003 concerning State Finance must consider several factors: first, the primary balance ratio; second, the lagged debt ratio (previous year’s debt relative to GDP); and third, the spread between the debt interest rate and economic growth.
Fiscal Credibility
The proposal to relax fiscal deficit and debt-to-GDP ratios clashes with efforts to build fiscal credibility and discipline. Historically, the government has been consistent with fiscal policy rules, maintaining a maximum debt-to-GDP ratio of 60% and a maximum fiscal deficit of 3.0%.
Jan Priewe, a senior researcher at the Macroeconomic Policy Institute (IMK) in Germany, notes that the fiscal discipline guidelines in the 1992 Maastricht Treaty were not based solely on academic arguments but on the experiences of several EU countries, such as Germany’s “golden rule,” where the fiscal deficit ratio is at least equal to the value of government investment.
To maintain fiscal credibility, fiscal policy must adhere to strict rules, such as ensuring that interest payments are not funded by issuing new debt. “Ponzi financing” would destroy national macroeconomic stability and sacrifice long-term economic growth. Furthermore, such relaxation should not lead to fiscal dominance over monetary authority, where the fiscal authority dictates monetary policy—for instance, by pressuring the central bank to lower interest rates to reduce the cost of new debt. Such fiscal dominance would undermine national macroeconomic credibility and increase the perception of economic risk. Referring back to Oliver Blanchard (2022), the focus should remain on the fiscal policy rule: ensuring that the debt interest rate remains lower than economic growth.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/weighing-the-3-limit-between-growth-ambition-and-fiscal-discipline-1790333768)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260925141546-14-770946/menimbang-batas-3-antara-ambisi-pertumbuhan-dan-disiplin-fiskal), translated from Indonesian