Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

We Celebrate Micro and Small Businesses, but Forget to Ask Why Everyone Has to Trade

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Economy
We Celebrate Micro and Small Businesses, but Forget to Ask Why Everyone Has to Trade
Image: Republika

Indonesia appears to be entering an era in which almost everyone has a business. A neighbour opens a seblak stall, a school friend sells dim sum, a former colleague offers frozen food, while family WhatsApp groups turn into shopfronts. From cilok and fritters to fashionable drinks and extra-spicy food, people seem to have an endless supply of ideas.

We call this phenomenon the rise of micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs). The government encourages entrepreneurship, social media promotes small-business success stories, and the public is increasingly familiar with the slogan that anyone can be their own boss.

There is, of course, nothing wrong with that spirit. MSMEs are an important part of Indonesia’s economy. They provide jobs, drive local trade and help many families maintain an income.

But amid the celebration, there is one question we rarely ask: are more people trading because business opportunities are becoming more promising, or because decent employment options are becoming more limited?

Not everyone starts a business with the ambition of becoming an entrepreneur. Some may simply be trying to keep food on the table.

When entrepreneurship is no longer a choice

In an ideal scenario, someone starts a business after spotting a market opportunity, developing an innovation or wanting to build their business skills. They draw up a plan, calculate their capital, study consumers and gradually grow the business.

But reality does not always work that way.

Some workers lose their jobs and then try selling food. Some university graduates cannot find work suited to their qualifications and end up setting up a small business. Others start a home-based business because their family income no longer covers everyday needs.

For these groups, entrepreneurship is not simply a career choice, but a survival strategy.

In entrepreneurship studies, this is known as necessity entrepreneurship: business activity that arises because of limited employment alternatives or sources of income.

Unlike opportunity entrepreneurship, which begins when someone identifies a business opportunity, necessity-driven ventures often start with limited capital, little preparation and risks that are relatively high for a family’s finances.

Both deserve recognition. But treating every business activity as evidence of economic success can lead us to overlook the problems behind it.

A republic of flour and intensifying competition

Walk through a residential area or along a road near a school and you may find several sellers of seblak, cilok, cireng, bakso aci and assorted fritters within a short distance of one another.

This is notable because many food businesses have relatively low barriers to entry. Ingredients are easy to obtain, preparation methods can be learnt, and start-up costs do not always require a large investment.

For people with limited capital, a simple food business is a reasonable option.

But ease of starting a business does not necessarily mean it is easy to make a profit.

As more traders offer similar products to the same group of consumers, competition intensifies. Sellers must contend with ingredient prices, packaging costs, rent and changing customer tastes.

They also face pressure to keep prices low so customers do not go to the stall next door.

A portion of seblak sold for Rp10,000 does not generate Rp10,000 in profit. The costs of ingredients, energy, packaging, labour and time all have to be taken into account.

Unfortunately, not every micro-business owner has the opportunity to calculate all these costs in detail.

As a result, someone may feel they have spent the whole day running a business, yet take home far less net income than they expected.

This is where we need to distinguish between more people trading and traders becoming more prosperous.

If everyone is selling, who is buying?

The question sounds like a joke, but it points to a serious economic problem.

Imagine a neighbourhood where most residents run small food businesses. One household sells fritters, another sells seblak, and several more offer similar snacks.

As long as people have sufficient income, these businesses can support one another.

But if purchasing power weakens, sellers must compete for consumers with limited spending capacity.

An increase in the number of sellers does not automatically create an increase in demand.

In some circumstances, competition can even drive prices down until businesses’ profit margins become increasingly thin.

For this reason, growth in the number of MSMEs should be considered alongside other indicators, such as productivity, net income, business survival and people’s ability to secure decent work and earnings.

Without those measures, we risk concluding too quickly that a proliferation of new businesses always signals a healthier economy.

MSMEs should not be the answer to every problem

Support for MSMEs is important. Entrepreneurship training, access to finance, digital marketing and business mentoring can help them become more competitive.

But economic policy should not stop at urging people to keep setting up businesses.

Not everyone has the interest, ability or circumstances to become an entrepreneur. Some people are better suited to working as technicians, researchers, teachers, health workers, industrial employees or professionals in other fields.

Society needs a range of employment options, not merely encouragement to trade when formal jobs are hard to find.

The government and businesses should continue to expand productive employment, improve the quality of education and training, and promote the growth of industries capable of employing people at decent wages.

At the same time, MSMEs need support not only to survive, but to grow.

The success of entrepreneurship programmes should not be measured solely by how many new businesses are established. We also need to know how many survive, increase their profits and provide a better livelihood for their owners and workers.

Do not celebrate compulsion as success

We should respect everyone who works to earn a living independently. Seblak sellers, cilok vendors, small shop owners and home-based businesses show a perseverance that should not be underestimated.

But respecting their efforts does not mean ignoring the economic hardship that may have led them to start a business.

There is a major difference between someone who chooses entrepreneurship because they see an opportunity and someone who has to trade because they cannot find another job.

Both work hard, but they face different circumstances.

So when we see more people starting businesses, we should not rush to assume that entrepreneurial spirit has solved economic problems.

We should also ask whether they earn a decent profit, have social protection and can plan for the future with greater certainty.

Economic success is not a situation in which everyone is forced to become an entrepreneur. It is one in which everyone has a fair opportunity to choose how they work and make a living.

We can continue to celebrate MSMEs as a driving force of the national economy. But our applause must not be so loud that it drowns out those who simply want a job that pays enough.

Indonesia needs to be more than a country of millions of traders struggling to get by.

It also needs to be a country that gives its people the chance to live more prosperous lives without having to open yet another stall just to make it through tomorrow.

More from 5 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/we-celebrate-micro-and-small-businesses-but-forget-to-ask-why-everyone-has-to-trade-1793879546)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/791419/kita-merayakan-umkm-tetapi-lupa-bertanya-mengapa-semua-orang-harus-berdagang), translated from Indonesian
Print