Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Village Heads Seek Indefinite Terms; Local Government Expert Warns Against 'Small Kingdoms'

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Village Heads Seek Indefinite Terms; Local Government Expert Warns Against 'Small Kingdoms'
Image: Media Indonesia

The desire of several village heads, whose terms of office have expired, to continue occupying positions as Acting Village Heads (Pj) without undergoing Village Head Elections (Pilkades) is viewed as having the potential to erode democracy at the village level. The pretext of budget efficiency is deemed an unacceptable reason to eliminate the community’s right to elect their leaders.

Djohermansyah Djohan, a Professor of Government Science at the Institute of Home Affairs Governance (IPDN), believes such aspirations cannot be justified solely by the reason of budget savings. In his view, efficiency should target the costs of organising elections, not the removal of democratic mechanisms.

“Budgets may be made efficient, but democracy must not be. The village is not merely the lowest level of government; the village is one of the roots of Indonesian democracy,” Djohemanrsyah stated in a briefing on Sunday.

He noted the irony that efforts to narrow the democratic space are coming from the village government elite themselves, despite villages having long-standing traditions of deliberation and the election of leaders as part of community life.

Djohermansyah emphasised that the principle of limiting power must apply to all levels of government. No political position should be maintainable indefinitely within a democratic system.

Under Law Number 3 of 2024 concerning Villages, the term of office is regulated for eight years and can be re-elected once. Thus, a village head can lead for a maximum of 16 years.

“16 years is more than enough. If, after two terms, there is still a desire to extend or remain as an Acting Head, the issue is no longer about the term of office; it is a desire to maintain power,” he asserted.

He described the push to maintain power as ‘the greed of power’. According to him, leaders must possess the ethics to know when to end their period of service.

“A good leader must be brave enough to enter with honour, work well, and then step down with their head held high. That is democratic ethics,” said the former Acting Governor of Riau.

Djohermansyah argued that a village head is a leader of the community, not the owner of the village. Therefore, leadership transitions must continue to provide space for the community to make their choices.

“If a village head works well, the people can re-elect them. If they perform poorly, the people can replace them. After two terms, give others a chance,” he said.

He also warned of the risk of dynastic politics if power is concentrated in one person or family for too long. The influence built during an official term can become capital to maintain political control even after the term has ended.

“Another danger is dynastic politics. Village heads who hold power for too long will build influence. After stepping down, power shifts to a child, spouse, or relative. Ultimately, the village turns into a small kingdom,” he remarked.

Consequently, he believes the issue of budget efficiency should be addressed by improving the Pilkades mechanism rather than abolishing it. Several schemes could be implemented to reduce costs while preserving the political rights of the people.

“Pilkades could be conducted simultaneously across an entire regency. Campaign periods could be shortened. Costs for campaign materials could be limited. In prepared villages, e-voting could be used. There are many ways to make democracy more efficient,” he explained.

He also encouraged an evaluation of the requirements for village head candidates by strengthening aspects of track record, integrity, and leadership capacity. Such steps are necessary to ensure that political competition in villages produces not just winners, but quality leaders.

“Democracy does indeed require costs. But democracy is far cheaper than the costs resulting from uncontrolled power,” he emphasised.

Furthermore, Djohermansyah requested that the aspiration to maintain village heads whose terms have expired as acting officials without elections be rejected. He argued that budget efficiency must not serve as a pretext to extend power while closing opportunities for other potential leaders.

“Do not sacrifice democracy in the name of efficiency. Do not allow villages to turn into small kingdoms controlled by the same individuals and families. The village must remain a school of democracy, not a small kingdom,” he concluded.

More from 13 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/village-heads-seek-indefinite-terms-local-government-expert-warns-against-small-kingdoms-1789296780)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/932902/kades-minta-jabatan-tanpa-batas-waktu-pakar-otda-jangan-jadikan-desa-kerajaan-kecil), translated from Indonesian
Print