Vietnam Withdraws Proposal to Allow Child Organ Donation After Strong Criticism
Vietnam has withdrawn a proposal that would have allowed children aged 15 to 17 to donate their organs after death. The decision followed public criticism in a country where transplants using organs from deceased donors remain very limited.
AFP reported on Tuesday (3 November 2026), citing state media, that Vietnam began kidney transplants in 1992 and now records the highest annual number of transplants in Southeast Asia.
However, most transplants in Vietnam still rely on living donors. In many other countries, transplants generally use organs from deceased donors, which also increases the supply of organs available for donation.
Vietnamese officials say they are seeking to update the 2006 law on organ and tissue donation, aiming to increase the number of life-saving transplants while protecting donors.
A draft submitted to the National Assembly last month proposed allowing teenagers aged 15 to 17 to donate their tissue, organs or bodies after death, provided they had the consent of a parent or legal guardian.
But after the proposal drew online condemnation, officials removed the provision on donors under 18 from the published revised draft. The government said it had received feedback from parliamentarians that only those who had reached legal adulthood should be allowed to donate organs.
Although dissent is tightly restricted in communist Vietnam, public opposition in this case focused on whether parental consent could truly protect children from pressure or exploitation.
Criticism also targeted a survey conducted in October to gather views on the draft law, which included schoolchildren as young as seven.
State media outlet Tuoi Tre News said the poll prompted questions about whether minors could understand complex medical, legal and ethical issues.
The outlet said that “the provision allowing minors to register as organ donors after death has sparked major controversy and disagreement in society”.
“Taking these concerns into account, the government has revised the draft” to stipulate that only people aged 18 or over may donate their organs, Tuoi Tre wrote.
Last month, National Assembly member Pham Khanh Phong Lan urged her colleagues to reject the proposal, saying: “You cannot sacrifice one child to save another.”
A user on the Threads platform wrote: “The power of public scrutiny has borne fruit. It is a relief to see this proposal rejected.”
The newly revised draft still allows minors who are alive to donate regenerating tissue—such as bone marrow or stem cells—to family members if no suitable adult donor is available.
The procedure would require a health assessment, counselling and consent from both the child and their legal representative. The bill is expected to be passed this month.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/vietnam-withdraws-proposal-to-allow-child-organ-donation-after-strong-criticism-1793658015)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/internasional/d-8735630/revisi-uu-dikritik-keras-vietnam-batalkan-usulan-donor-organ-anak), translated from Indonesian