Vaping poses narcotics risk, lawyer files judicial review
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Advocate Zico Leonard Djagardo Simanjuntak has filed a judicial review of Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health at the Constitutional Court (MK) regarding the regulation of electronic cigarettes, or vapes, which the petitioner believes could serve as a medium for narcotics abuse.
During the preliminary examination hearing at the MK Building, Jakarta, on Wednesday, the petitioner’s legal counsel, Priskila Octaviani, stated that the petition challenges Article 149, Article 150 paragraph (1), and Article 152 paragraph (2) of the Health Law.
“The petitioner is an Indonesian citizen who has never smoked in their lifetime. However, within the petitioner’s professional scope, they frequently encounter both conventional and electronic smokers,” said Priskila.
Case Number 363/PUU-XXIV/2024 is being examined by a panel of judges led by Vice Chairman of the MK Saldi Isra, alongside Constitutional Court Judges Adies Kadir and Liliek P. Adi.
The petitioner argued that the petition stems from concerns regarding the use and distribution of vapes, particularly following instances of narcotics abuse through electronic cigarette liquids.
“The petitioner is deeply concerned about vapes because authorities have discovered a new modus operandi, namely vapes being laced with narcotics,” Priskila stated while reading the petition.
According to the petitioner, this situation creates uncertainty regarding the substances entering a person’s body when using vapes obtained from third parties.
The petitioner also raised concerns about the possibility of non-vapers being exposed to aerosols from electronic cigarette liquids containing narcotics.
On this basis, the petitioner argued that the existence of vapes is not merely a matter of personal choice for users, but also carries potential risks for others in the same environment.
Furthermore, the petitioner linked this issue to the right to recognition, guarantee, protection, and fair legal certainty as guaranteed by Article 28D paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution.
According to the petitioner, the guarantee of legal protection also encompasses the state’s obligation to prevent reasonably foreseeable harm.
“Thus, fair legal protection is not only related to state action after an event has occurred, but also includes the state’s obligation to prevent the emergence of reasonably foreseeable losses,” said Priskila.
The petitioner also argued that vapes produce aerosols that carry various substances into the respiratory tract and are now widely distributed through various channels.
According to the petitioner, this condition means that the risks of using vapes cannot be viewed solely as a matter of individual consumer choice, as the resulting aerosols also affect the user’s surrounding environment.
“This situation demonstrates that the consequences of the existence of vapes have transcended the relationship between the product and the individual consumer,” concluded Priskila.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/vaping-poses-narcotics-risk-lawyer-files-judicial-review-1791395706)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5776068/vape-berisiko-jadi-medium-narkotika-advokat-ajukan-uji-materi), translated from Indonesian