Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Vaping, Drugs, and the Younger Generation: Why the BNN's Approach is Timely

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Vaping, Drugs, and the Younger Generation: Why the BNN's Approach is Timely
Image: detikcom

I travelled to Japan for the 2026 Asian Games. Alhamdullilah, the journey felt even more special when the Indonesian badminton team successfully brought home six medals, two of which were gold. Amidst the pride of seeing the Red and White flourish, this trip also provided an opportunity to view Japan from another perspective—not just how a nation builds sporting achievements, but how a country manages risks that gradually seep into daily life, such as vaping.

There is an interesting paradox in Japan. The country has become one of the world’s largest laboratories for heated tobacco products (HTPs). However, for e-cigarettes containing nicotine liquid, the Japanese government takes an extremely strict approach. Therefore, Indonesia can draw important lessons: new threats often do not arrive with a frightening face, but rather with fruit flavours, beautiful packaging, interesting technology, and a modern image.

In Japan, the sale of e-cigarettes containing nicotine has been prohibited since 2010, based on a pharmaceutical regulatory framework. Research by Koyama, Tabuchi, and Miyashiro explains that such products cannot be traded domestically as ordinary consumer goods.

This policy remains relevant today. In July 2026, Japan’s Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare reaffirmed that unapproved nicotine-containing e-cigarette products are treated as unauthorised pharmaceutical products. Consequently, their sale, distribution, and advertising in Japan are prohibited. The Japanese government has even strengthened internet patrols, including social media, and requested the removal of illegal advertisements or posts.

This provides the first interesting lesson from Japan: if the risk changes form, the supervision must also change form. Regulation must not lag behind when products move at the speed of algorithms.

This fact does not mean Japan has resolved all issues regarding new tobacco. On the contrary, Japan’s experience shows how complex the problem is. A survey of 4,689 e-cigarette users in Japan found that 62.3 per cent of respondents used nicotine liquid. Furthermore, 49.1 per cent used e-cigarettes alongside conventional cigarettes and/or heated tobacco products. This condition implies that while bans are important, bans alone do not automatically eliminate demand. Therefore, policy requires a three-pronged approach: firm regulations, intelligent supervision, and impactful education.

Recent research in Tobacco Control found that conventional cigarette sales per capita in Japan fell by 52.6 per cent between 2011 and 2023. The decline even surged to approximately 10.5 per cent per year between 2015 and 2018, coinciding with the expansion of heated tobacco products. Does this mean heated tobacco products are the answer? Not necessarily.

A 2026 scoping review of 25 Japanese studies found that the increased use of HTPs likely contributed to the decline in cigarette use between 2015 and 2018. The study also warned that dual use is a significant issue. The lesson is not to “replace cigarettes with vapes,” but rather “do not replace one dependency with a collection of dependencies.”

Indonesia faces additional challenges that prevent this issue from being read merely as a debate between conventional cigarettes and vapes. In January 2026, the BNN, alongside Customs and Immigration, dismantled an international network disguising narcotics within vape liquids and energy drink packaging. The seized goods allegedly contained substances including MDMA and etomidate.

In February 2026, the BNN brought various stakeholders together to discuss vape regulation. The forum highlighted indications of etomidate in vape liquids, positioning this issue as a threat intersecting with technology, lifestyle changes, public health, and substance abuse.

In September 20ss, the BNN again pushed for the strengthening of e-cigarette governance through cross-ministerial and inter-agency discussions. Internally, the BNN has even issued a Circular Letter of the Head of BNN (No. SE/8/VII/KA/SM.08/2026) prohibiting the use of e-cigarettes within the BNN work environment and outside of it.

In my view, this movement deserves appreciation. The BNN is not waiting for the problem to escalate before scrambling to extinguish the fire. Instead, the BNN has moved while the embers are still recognisable. Such policies are vital to be continued consistently, based on evidence, measurable, and integrated with other ministries and agencies.

Upon returning from Japan, I brought home four lessons: first, prevent before it becomes commonplace. Once a behaviour is considered a normal part of a lifestyle, the cost of communication becomes much higher.

Second, monitor the substance, not just the device. The form of the device can change very rapidly. Therefore, regulation must be able to follow the content, distribution, promotion, and patterns of misuse.

Third, the digital world must be a zone of prevention. In 2026, Japan strengthened patrols against illegal advertisements on the internet and social media. Indonesia also needs supervision capable of following the places where the younger generation finds products—not just in street shops, but on the screens in their hands.

Fourth, and perhaps most importantly, do not stop at prohibition. Strong policy must be accompanied by research, monitoring, public education, market oversight, law enforcement, and community strengthening.

I do not believe that Indonesia needs to copy Japan’s policies wholesale, given that our market structure, regulation, demography, culture, supervisory capacity, and consumption patterns are different.

Certainly, what we can learn is the mindset: new risks require new regulations; products…

More from 1 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/vaping-drugs-and-the-younger-generation-why-the-bnns-approach-is-timely-1790852370)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8688113/vape-narkoba-dan-generasi-muda-mengapa-langkah-bnn-datang-di-saat-yang-tepat), translated from Indonesian
Print