Use of AI chatbots poses risk of emotional issues in adolescents
Jakarta (ANTARA) - A recent study published in the journal JAMA Pediatrics reveals a worrying connection between the use of artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots and emotional problems in children and adolescents, who are more vulnerable to negative impacts.
According to a report by the New York Post on Monday (31/1) local time, the research involved a survey of nearly 40,000 students from grade four to grade 12 in Ontario, Canada, regarding their use of AI.
More than 21 per cent of students reported using generative AI for “affective purposes,” meaning seeking emotional support or asking for advice regarding friends and family.
Using chatbots for such purposes was strongly associated with significantly higher emotional problem scores. Students were almost twice as likely to experience clinically significant symptoms of emotional distress.
This issue does not affect all groups equally. The link between AI use and emotional problems was found to be stronger in female students, students with diverse gender identities, as well as Black, Indigenous, and other racial groups.
Researchers also found that young people who turned to AI for emotional support reported feeling lonely more often and feeling that they were not “meaningful” to others. Even after these factors were excluded from the analysis, the relationship between AI use and emotional problems persisted.
Dr Consuelo Cagande, Director of the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Division at Northwell Zucker Hillside Hospital and Cohen Children’s Medical Center in New York, stated that the phenomenon of young people turning to AI chatbots to help cope with emotional problems is “very concerning.”
“Young people are gradually replacing traditional social groups and traditional treatment models with these chatbots and algorithms,” said Cagande, who was not involved in the study.
Cagande noted a larger issue, such as the lack of protection, clinical follow-up, or safeguarding systems in crisis situations for those at risk who use chatbots.
According to Cagande, individuals may choose to use AI chatbots because they fear being judged if they discuss their problems directly with others. However, if they are to use them, there needs to be supervision as well as education regarding digital literacy and AI usage due to the potential for misinformation.
Cagande believes that this technology should only be used as a supplementary tool. Generative AI should not be the primary source sought when someone experiences emotional distress or mental health issues.
Furthermore, she suggested that speaking to a doctor, who can help find sources of assistance or provide referrals to mental health professionals, as well as seeking support from teachers or school guidance counsellors, should be the first line of defence in seeking help.
“If a child does use an AI chatbot, they must inform clinical professionals about the information they received from the chatbot regarding their mental health issues and not automatically accept it as final advice,” she said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/use-of-ai-chatbots-poses-risk-of-emotional-issues-in-adolescents-1788238863)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5719941/penggunaan-chatbot-ai-rentan-pengaruhi-masalah-emosional-pada-remaja), translated from Indonesian