US Supreme Court Blocks Trump's Bid to End Automatic Birthright Citizenship
One of Donald Trump’s initial steps for his second term was an attempt to reinterpret the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution. Among the series of executive orders he issued, Trump sought to end the principle of automatic citizenship for anyone born in the US, a rule that has been in place since 1868.
However, this ambition failed on Tuesday (30/06), after the US Supreme Court issued a ruling that did not favour the administration. “This is one of the clearest statements about who we are as a nation,” the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) said in a statement. “Regardless of who your parents are, if you are born here, you have the right to be part of this country.”
Trump previously referred to the current policy as a “disgrace,” while his vice president, JD Vance, once described it as the “stupidest immigration policy in the world.”
The order had previously undergone a complex legal process through various courts, including the Supreme Court. Although Tuesday’s ruling did not change the legal status, according to Kim Lane Scheppele, the case leaves a lasting impact. “The fact that this issue is now open to debate, whereas previously it was not, makes citizenship status more fragile, including for those who have lived their entire lives in the US,” said the professor of Sociology and International Relations at Princeton and legal sociology expert to DW, shortly before the decision was announced.
“It must be remembered that citizenship status is being attacked in various ways by Trump. His administration has opened denaturalisation units within the Department of Justice and encouraged the requirement to show proof of citizenship to be able to vote. Yet, very few of us possess such proof. For example, less than half of US citizens have a passport.”
The Current Rule
The 14th Amendment states: “All persons born or naturalised in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”
To date, courts and the government have consistently interpreted this provision as the basis for children born in the US to automatically become US citizens, regardless of their parents’ immigration status. There are several specific exceptions to this general rule, including children born to foreign diplomats or to enemy forces during an invasion.
How many would be affected if changed?
The Migration Policy Institute estimates that 255,000 children are born in the US every year to non-citizen parents. Any changes would not be applied retroactively. This means anyone who previously qualified for citizenship by being born in the US would remain unaffected. According to research by the Pew Research Center, this number reached up to 4.4 million American citizens between 2006 and 2023, though some may have left the country or passed away.
Several prominent American figures obtained US citizenship at birth even though their parents were not citizens at the time, including many within Trump’s inner circle. These include Secretary of State Marco Rubio, FBI Director Kash Patel, and US Vice President Usha Vance’s wife, Usha Vance.
What would be the impact if the rule were changed?
Although the court has now ruled that there is no change, the Trump administration’s proposal, if implemented, would significantly alter how citizenship is determined at birth. While it is difficult to know for certain, the Trump administration stated that when a child is born, their parents’ status would be checked to determine if the child is entitled to citizenship and other accompanying essential documents. Under such a rule, a birth certificate alone would no longer suffice to apply for a passport or a Social Security number.
The child’s citizenship status would then depend heavily on the parents’ country of origin. Some countries do not automatically grant citizenship to children of their nationals born abroad, particularly in Southeast Asia. In such cases, the child would likely become stateless.
“One important thing to understand about the US is that we do not have a simple and accessible way to prove citizenship, precisely because most of us rely on being born in the US for that claim,” said Scheppele. “So, a woman who has just given birth, or even the father of a newborn, would not immediately have an easy way to prove their citizenship, even in very routine cases of birth. Imagine if the citizenship and immigration status of all new parents had to be recorded for every birth across the country. From that alone, we can begin to see the administrative chaos that would ensue.”
How do similar rules work in other countries?
Trump frequently makes the incorrect claim that the US is “the only country that has this.” In fact, data compiled by the Pew Research Center shows that 32 other countries, mostly in North and Latin America, also offer automatic citizenship to children born within their territories.
The political meaning of Trump’s failure
Trump previously described automatic citizenship for those born in the US as a “magnet for illegal immigration” which, in his view, allows foreign nationals to unfairly access US benefits and facilities. His failure to pass one of his flagship immigration policies through the courts will clearly frustrate Trump. The ability to push through such hardline immigration policies is key to fulfilling his promises. Trump has placed significant emphasis on the mass deportation of “illegal foreigners,” restricting the arrival of refugees, and the success of immigration enforcement agencies.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/us-supreme-court-blocks-trumps-bid-to-end-automatic-birthright-citizenship-1782888841)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8555138/mahkamah-agung-as-gagalkan-trump-ubah-kewarganegaraan-otomatis), translated from Indonesian